Allahabad High CourtTransport, Maritime, and Aviation LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Absence of a journey ticket alone cannot negate bona fide passenger status for Section 124-A compensation.

Jairam And Anotherv.Union Of India Throu General Manager Northern Railway N.Delh

Absence of a journey ticket alone cannot negate bona fide passenger status for Section 124-A compensation.. Jairam And Another vs Union Of India Throu General Manager Northern Railway N.Delh. Allahabad High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the deceased could be denied compensation as "not a bona fide passenger" merely because no train ticket was found with him.

The court held

Issue 1 is answered in the affirmative: the deceased was a bona fide passenger, and the absence of a ticket did not defeat the claim.

It also directed

Issue 2 is answered in the affirmative: the death was an untoward incident under Section 123(c)(2) read with Section 124-A, and no proviso applies.

The Tribunal's findings on Issues 1 and 2 are set aside as perverse.

The appellants are held to be bona fide dependants under Section 123(b).

The impugned order dated 17.01.2013 is set aside and the appeal is allowed.

The respondent is directed to pay Rs. 8,00,000 as a lump sum within eight weeks of receiving the certified copy, failing which 9% per annum interest applies from the default date.

The lower court records are remitted to the Railway Claims Tribunal, Lucknow, with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The deceased, Sanjay, boarded Satyagrah Express (Train No. 5274) at Delhi Railway Station on a second-class general ticket for Sitapur.

¶ 3

On 06.08.2009, he allegedly fell from the moving train between Sitapur City and Hempur Railway Station, sustaining fatal injuries.

¶ 3

The journey ticket was reportedly lost in the incident.

¶ 3

The appellants, his parents, filed an Original Application on 02.08.2010 under Section 16 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 read with Sections 123(c)(2) and 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989, claiming Rs. 8,00,000.

¶ 2, 4

The Tribunal framed four issues: bona fide passenger, untoward incident, dependants, and relief.

¶ 6

The appellants produced AW-1 (father's affidavit), AW-2 (Baijnath, a witness to the ticket purchase, cross-examined on 12.10.2011), panchnama, post-mortem report, voter card and ration card.

¶ 7, 8

The respondent relied on a statutory DRM report, RPF letters and inquiry, Station Master's memo, diary entry, and statements of Ram Baksh and Rajendra Prasad, together with a panchnama and post-mortem report.

¶ 7, 8

The Tribunal held that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger and that death was not an untoward incident. It found that the body had crush injuries and was cut into two pieces, that AW-1 signed the inquest opinion that death was "cut down by the train," and that the respondent's DRM documents related to another person.

¶ 8, 15

The Tribunal dismissed the claim on 17.01.2013.

¶ 8, 9

The appellants challenged this under Section 23 of the 1987 Act.

¶ 2, 10

The respondent argued that two bodies were found cut on the track at Km. 76/6-9 on the same day, and that the claimants did not disclose this.

¶ 21, 22

02Issues

i.1. Whether the deceased could be denied compensation as "not a bona fide passenger" merely because no train ticket was found with him.

¶ 24

ii.2. Whether the death, where the body was found severed into two pieces with crush injuries, falls within "untoward incident" under Section 123(c)(2) read with Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989.

¶ 24

iii.3. Whether the appellants are entitled to compensation and, if so, its quantum.

¶ 24, 47–49

03Law Applied

The Court applied Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act, 1989, which defines "untoward incident" to include the accidental falling of a passenger from a train carrying passengers.

¶ 31

It applied Section 124-A, which imposes strict liability on the railway administration for death in an untoward incident, subject to the provisos.

¶ 32, 44

It applied Section 123(b) for the meaning of "dependants".

¶ 46

It relied on Union of India v. Rina Devi (2019) 3 SCC 572, which holds that mere presence of a body on railway premises is not conclusive of bona fide passenger status, that absence of a ticket does not negate the claim, and that the claimant's initial burden may be discharged by an affidavit, after which the burden shifts to the Railways.

¶ 25

It followed Lata v. Union of India (2026 SCC OnLine SC 1350), which holds that the standard is preponderance of probabilities and that the foundational facts are a valid ticket and an accident causing death.

¶ 26

It followed Sukhabhai Nanjibhai Makwana v. Union of India (2026 SCC OnLine SC 2008), which holds that absence of a recovered ticket cannot defeat the claim where the claimant's sworn statement is credible.

¶ 27

It cited Solanki Chimanbhai Ukabhai v. State of Gujarat (1983) 2 SCC 174, which holds that medical evidence is ordinarily only corroborative and does not displace eyewitness testimony unless it completely rules out the alleged manner of injury.

¶ 35

It cited Prempal Singh v. Union of India (Del HC, 2018), which holds that the impossibility of a passenger being crushed after falling from a moving train has not been established in law.

¶ 36

It cited Lali v. Union of India (2026 SCC OnLine All 26470), which holds that severance or fragmentation does not by itself establish a Section 124-A proviso exception, and that the Railways must prove any exception by cogent evidence.

¶ 37

It relied on Union of India v. Radha Yadav (2019) 3 SCC 410 for computing compensation where the accident predates the 2017 Schedule amendment.

¶ 33, 48

Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 Section 23Section 16

Railways Act, 1989 Section 123Section 129Section 191

04Reasoning

The Court held that the Tribunal's rejection of bona fide passenger status was unsustainable. AW-1's affidavit and AW-2's evidence on the ticket purchase at Delhi discharged the claimants' initial burden.

¶ 28

The Tribunal discarded AW-2 for not describing the fall and not explaining his presence at Delhi. The Court held that AW-2 was a witness to the purchase, not an eyewitness to the fall, and that no contradiction was elicited in cross-examination.

¶ 28

The respondent did not produce the Delhi ticket-sale records or any other material disproving travel, so no rebuttal was made out.

¶ 29

On the untoward incident issue, the Court held that the Tribunal's finding rested on presumption. The geometry-based reasoning on crush injuries was not supported by any independent oral or expert evidence.

¶ 34

It held that the crush-injury inference was "unacceptable," since a limb may be severed in an accidental fall and nothing on record excluded that theory.

¶ 42

The phrase "cut down by the train" in the panchnama described the injuries and did not exclude a fall.

¶ 39

The Court distinguished Sumitra Mishra and Tara Chand Mathur, because the Tribunal there drew no inference from the body's condition alone and believed the claimants' version. Here, the Tribunal's inference was drawn from body condition and track geometry alone, and the DRM documents concerned a different person.

¶ 38

The absence of any eyewitness or loco-pilot report that a passenger was run over also weighed against the respondent.

¶ 41

The Court held that the case fell within the first part of Section 124-A and none of its provisos, applying the beneficial, liberal construction of the statute.

¶ 43, 44

On dependency, the uncontroverted affidavit and ration card were accepted, and the respondent had not appealed that finding.

¶ 46

For quantum, the Court found that remitting the matter would prolong litigation. It applied Radha Yadav: with 6% interest, Rs. 4,00,000 (the 2009 figure) would not reach the enhanced Rs. 8,00,000 Schedule amount, so the higher figure applied.

¶ 47–49

05Holding

Issue 1 is answered in the affirmative: the deceased was a bona fide passenger, and the absence of a ticket did not defeat the claim.

¶ 29, 45

Issue 2 is answered in the affirmative: the death was an untoward incident under Section 123(c)(2) read with Section 124-A, and no proviso applies.

¶ 43, 45

The Tribunal's findings on Issues 1 and 2 are set aside as perverse.

¶ 45

The appellants are held to be bona fide dependants under Section 123(b).

¶ 46

The impugned order dated 17.01.2013 is set aside and the appeal is allowed.

¶ 50

The respondent is directed to pay Rs. 8,00,000 as a lump sum within eight weeks of receiving the certified copy, failing which 9% per annum interest applies from the default date.

¶ 49, 50(i)–(ii)

The lower court records are remitted to the Railway Claims Tribunal, Lucknow, with no order as to costs.

¶ 51
Allahabad High Court

Original Court PDF

Jairam And AnothervsUnion Of India Throu General Manager Northern Railway N.Delh

Allahabad High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment