01Facts
On 13.04.2017, the appellant, after purchasing platform ticket No. 88333889 for Rs. 10, went to Gurgaon Railway Station to see off a friend travelling by Jaisalmer–Howrah Express.
¶ 2He alleged that while alighting after helping his friend settle luggage, the train started with a jerk, causing him to lose balance and fall at about 02:00 p.m.
¶ 2He was admitted to Civil Hospital, Gurgaon, and then Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi (13.04.2017 to 05.05.2017), where his right leg was amputated above the thigh.
¶ 2He filed a claim (OA/II(u)/243/2017) under the Railways Act, 1989.
¶ 2The Railway Claims Tribunal dismissed the claim by judgment dated 29.11.2018, finding that the platform ticket did not appear in the original hospital list of articles and was added as the last item in the furdpeshkardgi, and that there was no cogent evidence of a fall from a train.
¶ 3The DRM report recorded that the appellant attempted to de-board Train No. 12372 from the off side of the platform.
¶ 4, 10The respondent Union relied on statements of the Pointsman and RPF Head Constable, the RPF diary entry, and a separate two-passenger journey ticket (No. 001-88333888) issued at the same time, and argued that the appellant was found lying between the Up and Down Main Lines with no eyewitness.
¶ 502Issues
i.1. Whether the appellant qualifies as a "passenger" under the Explanation to Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989, despite the absence of a journey ticket, where he holds a valid platform ticket.
¶ 7–8ii.2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in disbelieving the appellant's case on the basis of the discrepancy between the original hospital record and the furdpeshkardgi, notwithstanding independent verification of the platform ticket.
¶ 9iii.3. Whether the injuries were sustained in an "untoward incident" within the meaning of Section 123(c)(2), given the DRM report's finding of an attempt to de-board from the off side.
¶ 10–1203Law Applied
The Explanation to Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989 includes within "passenger" a person holding a valid platform ticket who becomes a victim of an "untoward incident," so the absence of a journey ticket is not by itself a bar.
¶ 7The definition of "untoward incident" in Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act, 1989 applies to the occurrence.
¶ 12Union of India v. Rina Devi, (2019) 3 SCC 572 holds that liability under Section 124-A is based on no-fault principles, and that victim negligence does not take a case outside the provision unless a statutory exception applies.
¶ 12Under Union of India v. Rina Devi, (2019) 3 SCC 572, an accidental fall while boarding or de-boarding, even from the off side, is an untoward incident.
¶ 12The Court exercised appellate jurisdiction under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987.
¶ 1Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987 Section 23
Railways Act, 1989 Section 123
04Reasoning
On the first issue, the Court held that the statutory Explanation resolves the passenger question in the appellant's favour, so the lack of a journey ticket could not defeat his claim.
¶ 7On the second issue, the Court found that the platform ticket was independently verified by the Railway Authorities. A communication dated 26.12.2017 from the Office of the Chief Commercial Manager, Northern Railway, confirmed that UTS ticket No. 00188333889 was a platform ticket for one passenger issued at Gurgaon at 12:09 hours on 13.04.2017 for Rs. 10.
¶ 8The Court held that the hospital-record discrepancy could not displace this documentary evidence of issuance of the platform ticket on the date of the incident.
¶ 9On the third issue, the Court noted that the DRM report attributed the incident to an attempt to de-board, which supports the appellant's account of a fall from the train, whereas the respondent's written statement alleged crossing railway lines.
¶ 10The absence of an eyewitness did not justify rejecting the sworn testimony, given the contemporaneous record of grievous injury in the railway yard and immediate hospitalisation, and the Pointsman's and RPF's statements recording the appellant's explanation for his presence at the station.
¶ 11Applying Rina Devi, even the DRM version of an off-side de-boarding attempt would not take the occurrence outside the "untoward incident" definition.
¶ 1205Holding
The appellant is a passenger under the Explanation to Section 124-A on the strength of a valid, independently verified platform ticket.
¶ 7–8The Tribunal's reliance on the hospital-record discrepancy was not sustainable.
¶ 9The injuries arose from an "untoward incident" under Section 123(c)(2), consistent with Rina Devi.
¶ 10–12The impugned judgment dated 29.11.2018 was set aside and the matter remanded to the Tribunal to assess compensation in accordance with law, with disbursement to be made within two months of receipt of the order. The matter is listed before the Tribunal on 07.12.2026.
¶ 13The appeal is allowed and disposed of accordingly.
¶ 14–15Original Court PDF
Vasu DevvsUnion Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
