Delhi High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceIntellectual Property Law

Additional documents contradicting the pleaded case cannot be taken on record until pleadings are amended.

Sh. Amar Guptav.M/S. Arvi Lights & Anr.

Additional documents contradicting the pleaded case cannot be taken on record until pleadings are amended.. Sh. Amar Gupta vs M/S. Arvi Lights & Anr.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Additional Documents (Ex. PW-2/1 to PW-2/6) could be taken on record with leave under Order XI CPC where they are inconsistent with the pleaded case that Vinayak Industries was the Petitioner's proprietorship.

The court held

The Court held that the Additional Documents could not be placed on record because they contradict the pleaded case in Plaint para 4, and no amendment had been sought.

It also directed

The impugned order dated 12.08.2026 is not perverse.

The Petition is dismissed without costs.

The Court granted liberty to the Petitioner to move an amendment application, which must be decided on its own merits without being influenced by the observations in the judgment.

The delay of 19 days in refiling was condoned (CM 297/2026).

01Facts

The Petitioner instituted CS(COMM) No. 543/2024 on 02.05.2024 against the Respondents, seeking injunction against infringement of the registered trade mark 'BAISUN', passing off, copyright infringement, delivery up, accounts and damages.

¶ 7

On 11.12.2024, the Commercial Court framed Issue No. 6, whether the Petitioner is not the owner of the mark or is a fraudulent adopter from a third party, with the onus on the Respondents.

¶ 8

Respondent No. 1 settled on 28.02.2025 and a compromise decree was passed; the suit continues against Respondent No. 2.

¶ 9

The Petitioner nominated Mr. Lokesh Kumar Gupta (PW-2), a partner of Vinayak Industries, and filed his affidavit of evidence on 25.04.2025.

¶ 10

On 12.06.2025, PW-2 exhibited the Additional Documents before the Local Commissioner, and Respondent No. 2 cross-examined him on them while objecting that leave had not been obtained.

¶ 11

On 22.07.2025, the Commercial Court directed the Petitioner to move an appropriate application before final arguments, and the Petitioner filed the application on 21.08.2025.

¶ 12

The Additional Documents are: the GST Registration Certificate (Ex. PW-2/1), the 2014 Partnership Deed of Vinayak Industries (Ex. PW-2/4), the 2021 Re-Constitution Deed (Ex. PW-2/5), PW-2's 2022 Re-Constitution Deed (Ex. PW-2/3), and PW-2's Aadhaar Card (Ex. PW-2/6).

¶ 28–29

The Commercial Court dismissed the application by the order dated 12.08.2026, holding these routine business documents not in the exclusive possession of the witness's family.

¶ 13

The Petitioner contends the Commercial Court wrongly treated Shyam Lal Gupta as PW-2's father, when he was the Petitioner's father.

¶ 15–16

Plaint para 4 describes Vinayak Industries as the Petitioner's proprietorship, whereas PW-2's affidavit describes it as a partnership firm.

¶ 27–28

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Additional Documents (Ex. PW-2/1 to PW-2/6) could be taken on record with leave under Order XI CPC where they are inconsistent with the pleaded case that Vinayak Industries was the Petitioner's proprietorship.

¶ 25, 31–34

ii.2. Whether the Commercial Court's dismissal of the application is perverse, warranting interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.

¶ 36

03Law Applied

The Court relied on Order XI CPC, under which additional documents may be admitted with leave on showing reasonable cause, but only if they are in aid of the pleaded case and do not contradict it.

¶ 32

Documents that set up a new case or withdraw an admission cannot be admitted; a party must first seek amendment of pleadings under law, and "merely filing documents is not sufficient".

¶ 32

The Petitioner's argument under Order XI Rule 1(12) CPC, concerning documents produced by witnesses, was recorded but not separately adjudicated.

¶ 19

The Court applied the Article 227 perversity standard, examining whether the impugned order is perverse.

¶ 36

No precedents were cited in the judgment.

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151

04Reasoning

The Court first identified the core issue as whether the documents could establish commercial continuity and prior lawful use through the Petitioner's late father, and authenticate invoices already exhibited as Ex. PW-1/5, to rebut Issue No. 6.

¶ 25

It noted that Plaint para 4 pleads Vinayak Industries as the Petitioner's proprietorship, while the Additional Documents establish a partnership in which the Petitioner's father was a partner and the Petitioner was not inducted.

¶ 27–29, 33

Because the documents would prove a case contrary to the pleaded case, the Court held that they could not be admitted without prior amendment.

¶ 32

The Court rejected the Petitioner's explanation that the pleading was a typographical error, as no such correction had been made in the Plaint.

¶ 34

It further held that, absent any pleading of the father's partnership role, the documents were not relevant to any controversy in the suit.

¶ 34

The invoices were already exhibited, so the documents could not be admitted to prove the father's involvement in the business.

¶ 35

On that basis, the Court found no perversity in the impugned order, without deciding the Commercial Court's error regarding PW-2's parentage.

¶ 36

The Court's reasoning rests on pleading inconsistency rather than the Commercial Court's "exclusive possession" finding.

05Holding

The Court held that the Additional Documents could not be placed on record because they contradict the pleaded case in Plaint para 4, and no amendment had been sought.

¶ 32–34

The impugned order dated 12.08.2026 is not perverse.

¶ 36

The Petition is dismissed without costs.

¶ 38

The Court granted liberty to the Petitioner to move an amendment application, which must be decided on its own merits without being influenced by the observations in the judgment.

¶ 37

The delay of 19 days in refiling was condoned (CM 297/2026).

¶ 4
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Sh. Amar GuptavsM/S. Arvi Lights & Anr.

Delhi High Court · November 06, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment