Delhi High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceProperty and Real Estate Law

Delhi HC Upholds Order Letting Brother Prove 2016 Lease Deed as Market Rent Evidence in Janakpuri Property Suit

Shri Umesh Kumar Sahniv.Sushil Kumar Sahni

Delhi HC Upholds Order Letting Brother Prove 2016 Lease Deed as Market Rent Evidence in Janakpuri Property Suit. Shri Umesh Kumar Sahni vs Sushil Kumar Sahni. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Joint Registrar was justified in permitting the plaintiff to summon an official witness not named in the original list of witnesses, under Order XVI Rule 1(3) CPC, where the lease deed was executed after the list was filed.

The court held

The Joint Registrar's order of 17.11.2025 was free from infirmity, and the appeal was dismissed.

It also directed

Sufficient cause existed under Order XVI Rule 1(3) CPC for summoning the Sub-Registrar's official, since the lease deed post-dated the witness list.

Comparability of the leased property is a matter for evidence and rebuttal, not a ground to exclude proof.

Section 139 of the Evidence Act did not bar cross-examination of the official, who had been examined as a witness.

The Joint Registrar's direction to summon the witness, along with the relevant document, and to fix the matter for plaintiff's evidence on 06.02.2026 stands.

The defendant may cross-examine the official and lead rebuttal evidence, and the Court will assess the evidentiary value of the lease deed at the appropriate stage.

01Facts

The plaintiff (younger brother) sued for partition, rendition of accounts and permanent injunction over House No. A-1/49, Janakpuri, New Delhi, which the defendant occupies exclusively.

¶ 3

Issues were framed on 19.02.2010, and an additional issue on rendition of accounts on 01.12.2011.

¶ 2, 4

The plaintiff's list of witnesses, filed 29.11.2013, named six witnesses and no witness or document on accounts.

¶ 4

In 2017 the plaintiff sought mesne profits (I.A. 3480/2017) and annexed a copy of a registered lease deed dated 27.01.2016 for a different property, A-1/358, Janakpuri.

¶ 5

The Single Judge ordered deposit of Rs. 10,000 per month on 02.05.2017.

¶ 5

The Division Bench, in FAO(OS) 206/2017 (order dated 31.07.2018), held that the amount was not binding and that the parties could lead evidence on mesne profits.

¶ 5

After his cross-examination, the plaintiff filed I.A. 3612/2023 under Order XVI Rule 1(3) CPC to summon an official of the Sub-Registrar-II B, Rajouri Garden, with the lease deed record.

¶ 6

The defendant opposed the application on grounds of non-listing, lack of comparability and delay.

¶ 7

The defendant relied on Dr. Anil Gupta v. Panna Lal Gupta (CM(M) 866/2017) before the Joint Registrar.

¶ 13(7)

The Joint Registrar allowed the application on 17.11.2025.

¶ 13

The defendant appealed to the High Court.

¶ 1–2

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Joint Registrar was justified in permitting the plaintiff to summon an official witness not named in the original list of witnesses, under Order XVI Rule 1(3) CPC, where the lease deed was executed after the list was filed.

¶ 14–16

ii.2. Whether the plaintiff could prove a document already placed on record, and whether the alleged non-comparability of the leased property barred its proof at this stage.

¶ 14, 17

iii.3. Whether Section 139 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (now Section 144 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023) prevented cross-examination of the summoned official.

¶ 8–9, 18

03Law Applied

Order XVI Rule 1(3) CPC permits a party, with leave, to summon a witness not in the witness list if sufficient cause is shown.

¶ 16

Under Section 139 of the Indian Evidence Act, a person summoned merely to produce a document is not a witness and cannot be cross-examined unless called as one.

¶ 8, 18

The Division Bench order dated 31.07.2018 in FAO(OS) 206/2017 governs: the Rs. 10,000 figure was not conclusive, and both parties could lead evidence on mesne profits.

¶ 5, 17

Comparability and evidentiary value are matters for trial, not for pre-trial exclusion.

¶ 17–18

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151

Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 Section 144

04Reasoning

The court found sufficient cause because the lease deed (dated 27.01.2016, registered 03.02.2016) post-dated the witness list of 29.11.2013, so the official could not have been listed earlier.

¶ 15–16

Since a copy had already been filed with I.A. 3480/2017, the court treated the application as one to prove an existing document, not to introduce a new one.

¶ 16

The mesne profits and rendition-of-accounts issue was open under the Division Bench's liberty order. Whether the leased property is comparable to the suit property, given location, area and condition, is a question of appreciation of evidence and cannot bar proof at this stage.

¶ 17

Section 139 did not apply because the plaintiff sought the official's examination on existence, execution and registration, and his examination-in-chief had already been recorded. The defendant could therefore cross-examine him under the ordinary law.

¶ 18

Admitting the document did not amount to accepting its contents or fixing any mesne profit.

¶ 18

05Holding

The Joint Registrar's order of 17.11.2025 was free from infirmity, and the appeal was dismissed.

¶ 19–20

Sufficient cause existed under Order XVI Rule 1(3) CPC for summoning the Sub-Registrar's official, since the lease deed post-dated the witness list.

¶ 16

Comparability of the leased property is a matter for evidence and rebuttal, not a ground to exclude proof.

¶ 17

Section 139 of the Evidence Act did not bar cross-examination of the official, who had been examined as a witness.

¶ 18

The Joint Registrar's direction to summon the witness, along with the relevant document, and to fix the matter for plaintiff's evidence on 06.02.2026 stands.

¶ 13 (order · ¶ 12) · ¶ 20

The defendant may cross-examine the official and lead rebuttal evidence, and the Court will assess the evidentiary value of the lease deed at the appropriate stage.

¶ 18
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Shri Umesh Kumar SahnivsSushil Kumar Sahni

Delhi High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment