01Facts
The plaintiffs sue for specific performance of an Agreement to Sell dated 17.03.2008 in respect of B-4, Nizamuddin West, New Delhi, or alternatively for damages.
¶ 2The total consideration was Rs. 5.05 crores, of which Rs. 3.35 crores was allegedly paid by 23.08.2008, with the balance due by 31.08.2008.
¶ 2The plaintiffs state they withheld the balance after learning the property was mortgaged to Citibank.
¶ 2The defendant disputes readiness, willingness and financial capacity.
¶ 3Issues were framed on 31.01.2014, including readiness and willingness (Issue (i)) and the defendant's title and mortgage position as on 31.08.2008 (Issue (iv)).
¶ 4By order dated 09.10.2018, the Joint Registrar declined to place on record post-institution bank passbooks, bank statements and an income tax return, as they were not relevant to financial capacity on or before institution of the suit.
¶ 5The plaintiffs' chamber appeal (O.A. 157/2018) was withdrawn on 09.01.2024.
¶ 6The plaintiffs' later application (I.A. 8861/2024) to summon witnesses to prove the same documents was dismissed on 22.09.2025.
¶ 6The Local Commissioner was appointed on 24.11.2025, and PW-1 and PW-2 were examined.
¶ 7The plaintiffs then sought summons to witnesses at Serial Nos. 7, 12, 13 and 14 of their list.
¶ 7The defendant did not object to Serial Nos. 7 and 14 but opposed Serial Nos. 12 and 13, the bank officials, who were to produce records of accounts of plaintiffs 3 and 4 from January 2007 onwards.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether the plaintiffs' witnesses at Serial Nos. 12 and 13 (bank officials) may be summoned to produce bank records of plaintiffs 3 and 4, given the defendant's objection that the records should have been filed with the plaint and that the request is an indirect attempt to introduce documents.
¶ 9 · ¶ 12ii.2. Whether the bank records are relevant to Issue (i) (readiness and willingness and financial capacity), so as to justify their production.
¶ 17 · ¶ 18iii.3. Whether the plaintiffs were required to proceed under Order VII Rule 14 CPC rather than by summoning witnesses.
¶ 19iv.4. Whether the period of production may extend beyond the period disclosed in the list of witnesses, namely January 2007 onwards rather than January 2007 to September 2009.
¶ 20 · ¶ 2103Law Applied
Order XVI Rule 1(1)–(4) CPC permits parties to list witnesses and obtain summons, and permits the Court to allow witnesses not so listed on sufficient cause shown.
¶ 13Chapter XI, Rule 7 of the Delhi High Court (Original Side) Rules, 2018 is to similar effect.
¶ 14Sections 5 and 6 of the Bankers' Books Evidence Act, 1891 govern the compelling of bank officers to prove bankers' book entries "by order of the Court or a Judge made for special cause" and the production of certified copies.
¶ 14U.N. Krishnamurthy v. A.M. Krishnamurthy (SC, 12.07.2022) holds that a plaintiff seeking specific performance must plead and prove, by evidence, the availability of funds or a financing arrangement to pay the balance consideration in time.
¶ 17Order VII Rule 14 CPC governs documents in the plaintiff's possession or power, and sub-rule (2) governs documents in a third party's possession.
¶ 19The earlier order dated 09.10.2018, which had attained finality, is binding on the scope of admissible financial evidence.
¶ 20Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
Serial Nos. 12 and 13 were not new witnesses, since they appeared in the list dated 24.02.2016 with the stated purpose of producing account records for January 2007 to September 2009. The defendant therefore had notice from the outset, and there was no surprise.
¶ 15The transactions in those accounts were already referred to in the cheques filed with the plaint (Index-4).
¶ 16Since the defendant had disputed the plaintiffs' financial capacity and cross-examined PW-1 on the source of funds, the bank records bearing on that question were relevant to Issue (i).
¶ 17 · ¶ 18The Court rejected the objection based on Order VII Rule 14. The request sought the banks' official records through their officials, not the plaintiffs' own copies, so access to passbooks did not bar production. Admissibility and evidentiary value were left for the appropriate stage.
¶ 19The request for records "from January 2007 onwards" exceeded the period in the list of witnesses. No explanation was given for the extension, and allowing it would enlarge the evidence beyond the original disclosure and reintroduce post-institution material already excluded by the 2018 order.
¶ 20The Court therefore limited production to January 2007 to September 2009, a period covering the pre-agreement phase, execution, and the 31.08.2008 payment date.
¶ 2105Holding
The application is allowed. The Court holds that bank records bearing on the plaintiffs' financial capacity are relevant to Issue (i), that the summoning of Serial Nos. 12 and 13 is not barred by Order VII Rule 14 CPC, and that the scope of production must be confined to the period disclosed in the original list of witnesses.
¶ 17–21Summons to be issued to witnesses at Serial Nos. 7, 12, 13 and 14 of the list dated 24.02.2016, on a date to be fixed by the Local Commissioner.
¶ 22(i)Since Oriental Bank of Commerce merged with Punjab National Bank on 01.04.2020, the witnesses at Serial Nos. 12 and 13 shall be officials of Punjab National Bank, Farrukhabad, producing records only for January 2007 to September 2009.
¶ 22(ii)The Local Commissioner is requested to proceed expeditiously. Nothing in the order is an opinion on the merits, and the matter is listed on 08.04.2027.
¶ 22(iv) · ¶ 24 · ¶ 25Original Court PDF
Mehar Elahi & OrsvsAman Ullah Khan
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
