01Facts
The ten suits concern alleged infringement of patents, designs, copyright, and trademarks, with passing off claims in some.
Each plaint pleaded Delhi jurisdiction under s.20 CPC, and in some cases s.134(2) of the Trade Marks Act or s.62(2) of the Copyright Act
¶ 2Delhi was pleaded through website accessibility, e-commerce listings, investigator or trap purchases, exports via the Delhi port, or the plaintiff's own Delhi presence
¶ 6.4, 7.3, 8.1, 9.2, 10.4, 11.2, 12.5, 13.2, 14.1, 15.2The defendants' operations were located elsewhere. Manufacturing and principal business were in Punjab, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, Telangana, Uttarakhand, and other States, and the agreements or tenders at issue were elsewhere
¶ 6, 7.1, 8, 9, 10.1, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15.1The court had called for a jurisdictional response in several matters
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether this Court has territorial jurisdiction under s.20 CPC (and, where pleaded, s.134(2) TM Act or s.62(2) Copyright Act) to entertain each suit, including where a plaintiff pleads website access, e-commerce listings, trap or investigator purchases, or its own Delhi presence
¶ 2, 3(H), 10, 10.5, 13.3ii.2. Whether, even if a part of the cause of action arose in Delhi, the court should decline to entertain the suit on the doctrine of forum non conveniens
¶ 3(I), 10.11, 16–17iii.3. Whether leave to sue under s.20(b) CPC should be granted where defendants do not reside or carry on business in Delhi and have not acquiesced
¶ 10.6–10.703Law Applied
The court applied s.20 CPC and, for trademarks and copyright, s.134(2) of the Trade Marks Act and s.62(2) of the Copyright Act, which permit suit at the plaintiff's principal or sub-ordinate office only where the cause of action accrues there
¶ 2, 3(B)Where a suit combines reliefs, jurisdiction must be established for each relief
¶ 3(A), 10.5Under ABD Maestro, which relied on Patel Roadways, Dhodha House, Sanjay Dalia, and Ultra Home, jurisdiction turns on where the material, integral and essential part of the cause of action arose
¶ 3(B), 3(I)(ii)–(iii)Mere website accessibility does not confer jurisdiction; the plaintiff must show purposeful targeting and commercially concluded transactions with the defendant in the forum
¶ 3(F) · Banyan Tree · ¶ 7.5, 14.6Sales to distributors are relevant, but a sole transaction through a third party is insufficient
¶ 3(D) · ¶ 14.6Delivery to the plaintiff's agent is deemed delivery to the plaintiff
¶ 3(D)(iii)Investigator-set-up transactions are generally disregarded unless the exceptions apply
¶ 3(H)Impact or effect of infringement felt in the forum is not a cause of action; the "dynamic effect" theory is rejected
¶ 3(G), 12.9Pleadings may be pierced under Manjula where unsupported by documents
¶ 3(J), 13.6Forum non conveniens, derived from Smith Kline & French v. Block, applies to suits and asks where the integral part of the cause of action lies
¶ 3(I), 17–19 · Sai Maghalakshmi Traders · ¶ 4Under s.104 and s.48 of the Patents Act, a patent-infringing product may be offered, sold, imported, or made, but the locus of manufacture is central to the dispute
¶ 7.4, 7.9Order VII Rule 10 CPC governs return of a plaint
¶ 20Provisions in the judgment · 12 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Trade Marks Act, 1999 Section 28Section 29Section 56Section 134
Copyright Act, 1957 Section 62
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 19Section 20Section 151
Patents Act, 1970 Section 47Section 48Section 104
Sale of Goods Act, 1930 Section 39
04Reasoning
The court held that, in each suit, Delhi-linked acts were peripheral to the dispute's substance.
In PRVNÍ BRNĚNSKÁ (CS(COMM) 973/2026), exports from Delhi were admitted, but the goods were manufactured in Punjab, which the court treated as the origin of the lis
¶ 6.5, 6.14In Gebr Schmid (350/2026), the products were manufactured at Surat, and an offer for sale or a single delivery in Delhi was a slender connection, so the court declined jurisdiction on forum non conveniens
¶ 7.8–7.11In HLE Glascoat (1054/2024), both parties were in Gujarat, and the website and IndiaMart pages were equally accessible there
¶ 8.2–8.3In Mold-Tek (609/2024), all defendants were in Surat; the court held that mere website accessibility or listing on marketplaces did not amount to carrying on business in Delhi, and that the defendants' non-objection could not confer jurisdiction
¶ 9.3–9.4In Sotkon (484/2021), the tender was floated by Gandhinagar Municipal Corporation, and the plaintiff's copyright and patent claims could not be aggregated for s.62(2) jurisdiction; the defendants did not acquiesce, so leave under s.20(b) was refused
¶ 10.5–10.10In Novartis (1060/2026), the Mumbai plaintiff and its import license lay in Mumbai, and sample orders delivered to Delhi did not explain why Delhi was chosen
¶ 11.3–11.4In Global Music (1208/2026), the agreements were executed outside Delhi and provided for exclusive Mumbai jurisdiction; accessibility of streamed content in Delhi and the plaintiff's impact there were insufficient
¶ 12.7–12.10In Nyra (785/2026), a trap purchase was discounted for lack of pleaded fairness and documentary support, and delivery was deemed at Indore; the court also noted the bill's exclusive Siwan jurisdiction clause and held the Delhi connection miniscule
¶ 13.3–13.7In Dr. Reddy's (1176/2026), a single e-pharmacy purchase was not a transaction with the defendant, the defendant's business lay in Madhya Pradesh, and the impact theory failed under the merger principle
¶ 14.4–14.7In Plusplus (251/2026), the quia timet cause of action existed, but the plaint's Delhi averments were unsupported and "cleverly drafted"; Delhi was not shown as the place of the infringing activity
¶ 15.6–15.905Holding
The court held that territorial jurisdiction under s.20 CPC (and s.134(2) TM Act or s.62(2) Copyright Act, where invoked) was not established in any of the ten suits.
¶ 6.15, 7.12, 8.4, 9.8, 10.11, 11.5, 12.11, 13.10, 14.8, 15.10Even where a minor Delhi connection existed, the court declined to entertain the suits on forum non conveniens, because the material, integral and essential part of each cause of action lay elsewhere.
¶ 6.15, 7.12, 8.4, 9.8, 10.11, 11.5, 12.11, 13.10, 14.8, 15.10Leave under s.20(b) was refused in Sotkon.
¶ 10.10All ten plaints were returned to the plaintiffs under Order VII Rule 10 read with s.151 CPC for presentation before the appropriate courts, pending applications were disposed of, and liberty was granted to seek directions under Order VII Rule 10A.
¶ 20–21Original Court PDF
Sotkon Sp SluvsWestern Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
