01Facts
The Respondent, M/s R.K. Associates, obtained decrees for possession in CS No. 305/2009 (600 sq. yd.) and CS No. 304/2009 (200 sq. yd.) over parts of Khasra No. 75, Village Zamrudpur, Delhi, by judgment dated 05.03.2011.
¶ 7Execution Applications 146/2022 and 138/2022 followed.
The Judgment Debtors' objections under Order XXI Rule 97 CPC were rejected by order dated 20.12.2022, which also directed possession with police assistance.
¶ 2, 8The Appellants appealed as EX.F.A. 1/2023 and 2/2023.
¶ 8On 28.07.2023, neither the Appellants nor counsel appeared, and both appeals were dismissed for non-prosecution by a common order.
¶ 4, 9The Appellants claim their erstwhile counsel, Sh. Shivom Garg, did not inform them of the dismissal or supply the case files, and that one legal representative is illiterate.
¶ 11The Appellants engaged new counsel in February 2024 and obtained the files on 20.03.2024.
¶ 12Applications for recall and restoration were filed on 23.04.2024, with a stated delay of 235 days.
¶ 10, 12The Respondent relies on the counsel's continued appearance before the Executing Court on 04.08.2023, 06.12.2023 and 19.12.2023, the 01.09.2023 order recording dismissal for default, and the Appellant's conduct on 16.01.2024 and 22.01.2024.
¶ 25–27The Appellants also rely on later execution orders dated 13.01.2023 (as recorded) and 07.02.2024 concerning possession and demarcation.
¶ 19, 6002Issues
i.1. Whether the Appellants have shown "sufficient cause" under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 for condoning the 235-day delay in filing the restoration applications, given the 30-day period under Article 122.
¶ 36 · ¶ 54–55ii.2. Whether the Appellants' non-appearance on 28.07.2023 was for sufficient cause, warranting recall of the common dismissal order and restoration of the appeals.
¶ 37, 58–59, 65iii.3. Whether the alleged default of the erstwhile counsel, without more, excuses the Appellants' lack of diligence.
¶ 44–46, 50iv.4. Whether subsequent execution orders on possession and demarcation can justify restoration of the appeals.
¶ 61–6303Law Applied
The Court applied Article 122 of the Limitation Act, which prescribes 30 days to re-admit an appeal dismissed for default or want of prosecution, and Section 5 of the Limitation Act, which permits condonation on proof of sufficient cause.
¶ 36The power of restoration derives from Order XLI Rule 19 CPC read with Section 151 CPC, and is discretionary and contingent on statutory conditions.
¶ 37Under the settled approach to "sufficient cause," the expression is to be construed liberally to advance substantial justice. However, liberal construction does not make condonation automatic. The applicant must give a bona fide, reasonable and detailed account of the delay and of steps taken once the impediment ceased, tested against the contemporaneous record and the applicant's diligence.
¶ 38–39A litigant ordinarily should not suffer for a bona fide lapse of counsel, but this principle cannot be applied mechanically without examining the litigant's own diligence.
¶ 44–45No specific precedent is cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5Section 122
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The Court examined the Appellants' explanation against the record of the execution proceedings. It found that counsel Garg continued to appear before the Executing Court after the 28.07.2023 dismissal, on 04.08.2023, 06.12.2023 and 19.12.2023.
¶ 41–42The 01.09.2023 order expressly recorded the dismissal for default, and Appellant Rajesh Kumar was personally present in Court that day. The Court held that this record made the plea of complete ignorance "insufficiently convincing" and did not show reasonable diligence in tracking the appeals.
¶ 42, 43, 46, 47The illiteracy plea was rejected because the record contains pleadings and affidavits signed by Rajesh Kumar in English, and the Appellants were shown to be attending and paying in the execution proceedings.
¶ 48The Court held that the counsel-default plea does not, in these circumstances, justify the delay.
¶ 45, 49–50The explanation for the file-retrieval period (February to 20.03.2024) was also found insufficient, because the Appellants gave no particulars of steps taken in the intervening period, and the 22.01.2024 statement showed they were already aware of counsel's difficulties.
¶ 51–53The Court noted that no complaint to the Bar Council or communication to counsel was made, which undermined the allegations against him.
¶ 56The execution orders on possession and demarcation do not explain the non-appearance or the delay, and any rights in execution must be pursued before the competent forum.
¶ 61–6305Holding
The Court held that the Appellants failed to show sufficient cause either for the non-appearance on 28.07.2023 or for the 235-day delay in seeking restoration. Reliance on counsel's lapse did not cure the lack of diligence, and the subsequent execution orders could not supply sufficient cause.
¶ 63–65The applications for condonation of delay (CM APPL. 24997/2024 and 25391/2024) were dismissed.
¶ 66Consequently, the applications for recall of the common order dated 28.07.2023 and restoration of EX.F.A. 1/2023 and EX.F.A. 2/2023 (CM APPL. 24996/2024, 25390/2024) were also dismissed, with no order as to costs.
¶ 67–68Original Court PDF
Kishan Lal Deceased Through Lrs & Ors.vsR K Associates
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
