01Facts
BSNL's Corporate Office issued a Circular dated 16 July 2015 declaring that a diploma in the appropriate engineering field with 10 years' experience is equivalent to a Degree in Engineering for promotion to EE (Civil/Electrical) under Note 2, Schedule IB of the BSNL MSRR-2009
¶ 2The Circular relied on a Ministry of Education & Social Welfare O.M. dated 26 May 1977 recognizing such equivalence
¶ 2 · ¶ 3Respondents 1 to 6 challenged the Circular before the Central Administrative Tribunal in OA 2905/2015
¶ 4By judgment dated 14 November 2025, the Tribunal allowed the OA. It held the 1977 O.M. to be "false and fictitious," relying on a 23 March 2016 MHRD Gazette notification and a Chandigarh Bench decision in OA 892/2018, and reasoned that the Circular, being founded on an illegal foundation, could not stand
¶ 5The Tribunal had also followed this Court's judgment dated 25 November 2024 in WP(C) 2671/2017, which recorded that the 1977 O.M. was not traceable per the Directorate of Publications and that the Punjab & Haryana High Court had held it could not be treated as validly issued by the Union
¶ 6 · ¶ 9–14 of quoted judgmentBSNL sought review (RA 4449/2026), relying on the Gujarat High Court's judgment dated 11 January 2022 in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. v. Mamta Gadura (SCA 223/2022), which upheld the diploma-plus-10-years equivalence
¶ 8–9The SLP against Mamta Gadura was dismissed in limine on 16 April 2025
¶ 8–9By order dated 13 July 2026, the Tribunal declined to examine Mamta Gadura, holding it fell outside review jurisdiction
¶ 12BSNL filed the present writ petition challenging both the 14 November 2025 judgment and the 13 July 2026 order
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal, in review, could decline to consider the binding effect of the Gujarat High Court's judgment in Mamta Gadura and the dismissal of the SLP against it, on the ground that the issue fell outside review jurisdiction
¶ 10–12ii.2. Whether the Tribunal's review order dated 13 July 2026 can be sustained, having been passed without a merits determination of the review application
¶ 12–1503Law Applied
Where the correctness of a judgment under review is challenged on the ground of binding judicial precedents not noticed in it, the Court must examine that aspect even in review jurisdiction
¶ 13An order which renders clear findings on the merits of a review application cannot be passed in circulation
¶ 14An illegal foundation vitiates the superstructure
¶ 5, quoting Tribunal's para. 8The 1977 O.M. was not traceable, as recorded in this Court's 2024 judgment in WP(C) 2671/2017
¶ 6 (quoting WP(C) 2671/2017 · ¶ 9–15)Judicial recognition of the diploma-plus-experience equivalence under Mamta Gadura was treated as a binding precedent warranting consideration
¶ 8–1004Reasoning
The Court identified a conflict between two judicial directions: the Tribunal's striking down of the 2015 Circular and the Gujarat High Court's affirmation of the Circular's validity, left undisturbed after dismissal of the SLP
¶ 5, 7 · ¶ 8–10BSNL faced contrary directives on the same Circular, which the Court recognised as a matter requiring consideration
¶ 11The Tribunal's refusal to address Mamta Gadura on the ground of review limits was held unsustainable, since review jurisdiction extends to examining binding precedents overlooked in the impugned judgment
¶ 13The Tribunal's dismissal of the review through circulation, with reasoned findings on the merits, was procedurally improper
¶ 14The Court expressly declined to determine the correctness of the Tribunal's 14 November 2025 judgment, or the merits of the Circular's validity, leaving these for the Tribunal on a fresh hearing
¶ 13, 1905Holding
The Tribunal could not decline to examine the binding effect of Mamta Gadura and the dismissal of the SLP on review jurisdictional grounds
¶ 12–13The review order dated 13 July 2026 in RA 4449/2026 is quashed and set aside, and the RA is remanded for fresh consideration on merits. The writ petition is allowed only to this extent, with no order as to costs. The Court directed the parties' counsel to appear before the Tribunal on 23 November 2026, with no adjournment permitted, requested the Tribunal to decide the RA within four weeks, and asked for expeditious disposal given the large number of affected BSNL employees. The Court expressed no opinion on the merits of the RA or the validity of the 2015 Circular
¶ 14–16 · ¶ 21 · ¶ 17 · ¶ 20 · ¶ 18 · ¶ 19The judgment does not expressly set aside the Tribunal's 14 November 2025 judgment
Original Court PDF
Bharat Sanchar Nigam LtdvsAdesh Jain
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
