Delhi High CourtHuman Rights LawAdministrative and Public Law

Delhi HC Dismisses SSC Plea, Says Disabled Candidate Cannot Be Disqualified for Not Re-Submitting Accepted Exemption Papers

Union Of India & Ors.v.Mohammad Saquib

Delhi HC Dismisses SSC Plea, Says Disabled Candidate Cannot Be Disqualified for Not Re-Submitting Accepted Exemption Papers. Union Of India  & Ors. vs Mohammad Saquib. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the respondent, a PwD candidate who submitted the exemption undertaking and Annexure-XIV certificate in the forenoon session and was provided a scribe, could be marked absent and disqualified from the typing test for failing to re-submit those documents in the afternoon session of the same day.

The court held

A PwD candidate's mere failure to re-submit an exemption undertaking and medical certificate in the afternoon session, after the same had been submitted and accepted in the forenoon, cannot justify treating him as absent from the typing test and disqualifying him.

It also directed

The writ petition was found to be contrary to the principle of reasonable accommodation and the RPwD Act.

The writ petition is dismissed in limine. Costs were considered but not imposed, as the petition was dismissed at the threshold.

The Registry was directed to forward a copy of the judgment to the Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities and the Ministry of Law so that an informed decision may be taken before challenging similar orders.

01Facts

The respondent, Mohammad Saquib, suffers from 54% Post Head Injury Right Hemiparesis, a "benchmark disability" under Section 2(r) of the RPwD Act.

¶ 13

The Staff Selection Commission (SSC) does not dispute the nature or extent of the disability.

¶ 13

He applied for the Combined Higher Secondary (10+2) Level Examination, 2022 (CHSL-2022). The examination included a written test and a skill/typing test, both held on 26 June 2023: the written test in the forenoon and the skill test in the afternoon.

¶ 14

Clause 14.9.7.6.7 of the Notice of Examination permits exemption from the typing test for candidates with permanent physical disability, on submission of an Annexure-XIV certificate from a competent medical authority, with supporting medical certificates (Annexures XI–XIII) to be furnished at the time of the typing test.

¶ 14

On the morning of 26 June 2023 the respondent submitted a physical-limitation certificate, sought a scribe for the written test, and filed an undertaking seeking exemption from the typing test.

¶ 14

A scribe was provided and the documents were accepted.

¶ 15, 19

He did not re-submit the documents in the afternoon, was marked absent in the typing test, and was declared unsuccessful.

¶ 16

The Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) allowed his Original Application (OA 2627/2024) by judgment dated 10 March 2026, holding that the afternoon default could not justify disqualification.

¶ 1, 17, 19

The SSC's position that Annexures XI–XII were not furnished is unsupported by anything on record.

¶ 20–21

The SSC has challenged the CAT order by this writ petition.

¶ 17

02Issues

i.1. Whether the respondent, a PwD candidate who submitted the exemption undertaking and Annexure-XIV certificate in the forenoon session and was provided a scribe, could be marked absent and disqualified from the typing test for failing to re-submit those documents in the afternoon session of the same day.

¶ 16, 22–23, 26

ii.2. Whether the writ petition challenging the CAT's order raised a maintainable challenge consistent with the principle of reasonable accommodation under the RPwD Act.

¶ 1, 11, 27

03Law Applied

The Court relied on Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution, treating reasonable accommodation as a constitutional imperative and an aspect of substantive equality.

¶ 9, 11

Section 2(y) of the RPwD Act defines reasonable accommodation as necessary and appropriate modifications without disproportionate or undue burden, and is to be read purposively.

¶ 7

From Vikash Kumar v. UPSC, equality for PwDs requires additional support beyond non-discrimination, and reasonable accommodation is a positive obligation.

¶ 6

From Omkar Ramchandra Gond v. Union of India, reasonable accommodation should not be read narrowly, and rules and instructions must be construed purposively to further the RPwD Act.

¶ 7

From Anmol v. Union of India and Om Rathod v. DGHS, there is no "one size fits all" approach, and denial of reasonable accommodation constitutes discrimination.

¶ 8

From Ch. Joseph v. Telangana SRTC, Rajive Raturi v. Union of India and Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal v. Union of India, accommodation enables candidates to perform at their optimum level and is a facet of substantive equality.

¶ 9–10

Instruments promoting reasonable accommodation must not be interpreted to defeat their purpose.

¶ 11

Clause 14.9.7.6.7 of the examination notice governs exemption from the typing test for candidates with permanent physical disability.

¶ 14

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016. Section 2

04Reasoning

The SSC's knowledge of the respondent's disability was not disputed. The SSC had provided a scribe for the written test and accepted the certificate and undertaking that morning.

¶ 15, 19, 22

The validity of the Annexure-XIV certificate, and the respondent's entitlement to exemption on its basis, were also not disputed.

¶ 23, 25

The only alleged default was the failure to re-produce the same documents in the afternoon. The Court held that this technical default could not justify treating the candidate as absent and disqualifying him, because such an approach would defeat the purpose of the exemption and the reasonable accommodation mandated by the RPwD Act.

¶ 24–26

The Court relied on the Tribunal's reasoning that the terms of the notice must not be interpreted to frustrate accommodation, and that no provision of the notice or the examination scheme required re-submission on the same day.

¶ 19 (quoting para. 6.9 of the CAT order)

The Court rejected the SSC's unsubstantiated argument regarding Annexures XI–XII.

¶ 20–22

Having found the CAT's view "eminently reasonable" and in sync with the RPwD Act, the Court held that the writ petition ought not to have been filed.

¶ 27

On the maintainability issue, the Court held that challenging such an order militates against the constitutional imperative of reasonable accommodation and would defeat the RPwD Act's purpose.

¶ 1

05Holding

A PwD candidate's mere failure to re-submit an exemption undertaking and medical certificate in the afternoon session, after the same had been submitted and accepted in the forenoon, cannot justify treating him as absent from the typing test and disqualifying him.

¶ 26

The writ petition was found to be contrary to the principle of reasonable accommodation and the RPwD Act.

¶ 1, 27

The writ petition is dismissed in limine. Costs were considered but not imposed, as the petition was dismissed at the threshold.

¶ 28, 30

The Registry was directed to forward a copy of the judgment to the Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities and the Ministry of Law so that an informed decision may be taken before challenging similar orders.

¶ 29
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Union Of India & Ors.vsMohammad Saquib

Delhi High Court · November 05, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment

Related judgments

Recent judgments that share this one’s subject or court. Hover a card to read what was held.

All Human Rights Law judgments →