01Facts
The appellant (plaintiff) filed a suit for specific performance of an Agreement to Sell dated 05.10.2019 concerning land measuring 19 Kanal 9 Marla in Village Sultanpur, Tehsil and District Sonipat, Haryana (the "suit property").
¶ 2 · pp. 1–2The total sale consideration was Rs. 95,00,000, of which Rs. 15,00,000 was paid as part consideration.
¶ 2 · p. 2The sale deed was to be executed within six months, but the respondents failed to do so.
¶ 3 · p. 2A legal notice dated 08.12.2020, served on 09.12.2020, preceded the suit, which was instituted before the Trial Court at Delhi.
¶ 3 · p. 2The Agreement to Sell contained an exclusive jurisdiction clause (Clause 19) in favour of Delhi courts, and both parties were Delhi residents, with the agreement executed in Delhi.
¶ 5 · pp. 2–3The Trial Court (ASJ-02, North-West, Rohini Courts) held that Section 16 CPC applied, the proviso was inapplicable, and directed return of the plaint for presentation before the competent court by order dated 08.12.2023.
¶ 1 · ¶ 4 · p. 202Issues
i.1. Whether the Courts at Delhi have territorial jurisdiction to entertain a suit for specific performance of an Agreement to Sell where the subject immovable property is situated in Haryana.
¶ 8 · p. 4ii.2. Whether the proviso to Section 16 CPC (relief obtainable through personal obedience of the defendant) is attracted to such a suit, including where consequential possession is sought.
¶ 5–6 · pp. 2–3 · ¶ 9–10 · pp. 4–6 · ¶ 18 · pp. 8–9iii.3. Whether an exclusive jurisdiction clause in the agreement can confer territorial jurisdiction on Delhi courts over immovable property situated outside Delhi.
¶ 16 · p. 8 · ¶ 19 · p. 903Law Applied
The Court applied Section 16 CPC, which mandates that suits for specified immovable property, including specific performance and delivery of possession (cl. (d)), be instituted where the property is situated. Its proviso permits such a suit where the relief can be obtained entirely through the personal obedience of the defendant, but the proviso is an exception that cannot enlarge the main provision and applies only where the defendant need not leave the court's jurisdiction.
¶ 9 · pp. 4–5The Court relied on Harshad Chiman Lal Modi v. DLF Universal Ltd. (2005) 7 SCC 791, holding that a clause conferring jurisdiction on one court can operate only where two or more courts already have jurisdiction, and that parties cannot confer jurisdiction otherwise.
¶ 9 · pp. 5–6The Court applied Rohit Kochhar v. Vipul Infrastructure Developers Ltd. (2024 SCC OnLine SC 3584), holding that the proviso is not attracted where execution and registration of the sale deed require defendants to go to another jurisdiction, and that parties cannot, by agreement, confer jurisdiction on a court lacking it.
¶ 10 · pp. 6–7Under Swastik Gases (2013) 9 SCC 32, a jurisdiction clause only selects among courts already competent.
¶ 16 · p. 8Section 39 CPC governs transfer of decrees for execution and does not confer jurisdiction at the institution stage.
¶ 17 · p. 9Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 16Section 17Section 39
04Reasoning
The Court first noted that the suit property was admittedly in Haryana and that the reliefs sought (specific performance, execution and registration of the sale deed, and possession) concerned immovable property outside Delhi.
¶ 18 · pp. 8–9Because the sale deed would have to be executed and registered in Haryana, the defendants would have to go outside Delhi, so the relief could not be obtained through personal obedience within Delhi, and the proviso to Section 16 did not apply.
¶ 18 · p. 9 · ¶ 10 · pp. 6–7The appellant's authorities were distinguished: Sidharth Choudhary and Karan Mahendru predated Harshad Chiman Lal Modi and Rohit Kochhar and could not prevail over them; Dr. Ramesh Chander Munjal involved multiple properties under Section 17 CPC and was not a specific performance suit; and Adcon Electronics concerned Letters Patent Clause 12 and was considered in Rohit Kochhar.
¶ 12–13 · p. 7 · ¶ 14 · p. 8 · ¶ 15 · p. 8On the jurisdiction clause, the Court held that Clause 19 cannot override Section 16 because it only operates where a court already has jurisdiction, and the parties' residence, the place of execution of the agreement, and the clause together could not vest territorial jurisdiction in Delhi.
¶ 16 · p. 8 · ¶ 19 · p. 9Reliance on Section 39 CPC was rejected because it concerns transfer of decrees for execution, not jurisdiction in the first instance.
¶ 17 · p. 905Holding
The Court held that Delhi courts lack territorial jurisdiction over a suit for specific performance and consequential possession of immovable property situated in Haryana, notwithstanding the parties' Delhi residence, execution of the agreement in Delhi, and the exclusive jurisdiction clause.
¶ 18–19 · pp. 8–9The proviso to Section 16 CPC is not attracted, and the parties cannot confer jurisdiction by agreement.
¶ 19 · p. 9 · ¶ 20 · p. 9The appeal was dismissed, and the order of 08.12.2023 directing return of the plaint for presentation before the court of competent jurisdiction was upheld.
¶ 20–21 · p. 9The pending application was disposed of accordingly.
¶ 22 · p. 9Original Court PDF
Rishipal BansalvsNarender Aggarwal & Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
