01Facts
The appellant sought probate under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 ("ISA") of a Will dated 05.05.2006 executed by his mother, Smt. Sushila Devi, who died on 07.05.2006.
¶ 2The Will allegedly bequeathed a 100 sq. yd. property at House No. 643, Guru Ram Das Nagar, Laxmi Nagar, Delhi, to the appellant, and was attested by Sh. Chhotey Lal and Sh. Prem Prakash.
¶ 2The probate petition was filed on 10.12.2015, and the original Will was placed on the judicial record on 16.12.2015.
¶ 2Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 (sisters) objected that the Will was forged and that the testatrix died intestate.
¶ 3The Probate Court framed issues on due execution (Issue 1) and forgery (Issue 2).
¶ 4The original Will was exhibited as Ex. PW-1/2.
¶ 5, 12Both attesting witnesses were examined, but neither was shown the original Will.
¶ 12PW-3 identified signatures only on a photocopy (Mark-A), without objection from Respondents 2 and 3.
¶ 13PW-2 stated, when shown only his own affidavit, that he could not say whether it was the same document.
¶ 12The Probate Court held that the Will was not proved under Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, decided Issue 1 against the appellant, decided Issue 2 in his favour, and dismissed the petition.
¶ 6The appeal was filed with a 49-day delay, which was condoned.
CM Appl. 31195/2019 · ¶ 1-302Issues
i.1. Whether the Will dated 05.05.2006 was proved in accordance with Section 63(c) of the ISA read with Section 68 of the Evidence Act, where the original Will was never shown to the attesting witnesses for identification.
¶ 14ii.2. Whether this procedural omission is a curable defect warranting remand, or whether it justifies dismissal of the probate petition on a technicality.
¶ 16, 19-2003Law Applied
Section 63(c) of the ISA requires a Will to be attested by two or more witnesses who have seen the testator sign or received his acknowledgment, and Section 68 of the Evidence Act bars use of an attested document unless at least one attesting witness, if alive and capable, is examined to prove its execution.
¶ 11The attesting witness must ordinarily speak to the very original document by identifying the testator's and his own signatures on it.
¶ 11M.B. Ramesh (Dead) by LRs v. K.M. Veeraje Urs (Dead) by LRs, (2013) 7 SCC 490 holds that Section 71 of the Evidence Act is an enabling provision that does not absolve the propounder of the Section 68 obligation, and endorses the approach of the Bombay High Court in Vishnu Ramkrishna v. Nathu Vithal.
¶ 15-16A court dealing with a Will must act as a "court of conscience," must not allow the testator's wishes to be defeated by technicality, and may call for necessary evidence to determine due execution.
¶ 15-16A probate decision operates in rem, so rejection on a curable omission would amount to deciding on a technicality rather than the merits.
¶ 19Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 276Section 63
04Reasoning
Identification of signatures on a photocopy does not prove the execution of the original, and PW-2's testimony was never linked to the Will, so Section 63(c) read with Section 68 was not satisfied on the record as it stood.
¶ 14The Court found the defect to be one of procedure, not of evidence. The original Will had been on the judicial record and exhibited from the outset, both attesting witnesses were alive and present, and their affidavits spoke to due execution.
¶ 17PW-2's cross-examination answer about "the SDM office document" could only be resolved by showing him the original, so the Probate Court could not safely conclude that he had never put his thumb impression on the Will.
¶ 18Neither witness denied or failed to recollect execution, so Section 71 was not the operative route; the issue was the manner of examination.
¶ 16Applying Ramesh, the Court held that dismissing the petition on this omission would defeat the testator's wishes on a technicality, so the appellant was entitled to an opportunity to cure the defect.
¶ 16-20Because the Will was not found proved and no finding on forgery was disturbed, the Court did not grant probate itself, and declined the appellant's prayer for a direct grant.
¶ 1405Holding
On Issue 1, the Court held that the Will was not proved in the manner required by Section 63(c) ISA and Section 68 Evidence Act on the existing record.
¶ 14On Issue 2, the Court held that the omission was curable and that the ends of justice required an opportunity to cure it rather than outright rejection.
¶ 20The Court remanded the matter to the Probate Court limited to Issue 1, with directions that: (i) the appellant may recall PW-2 and PW-3 to be shown the original Will (Ex. PW-1/2) for proof of execution and attestation; (ii) Respondents 2 and 3 may cross-examine the witnesses afresh; and (iii) the Probate Court must decide Issue 1 afresh on the entire record, uninfluenced by the judgment's observations, with the finding on Issue 2 remaining undisturbed.
¶ 20.1, 20.2, 20.3The parties are directed to appear before the Probate Court on 08.12.2026, and the appeal is disposed of accordingly.
¶ 21, 22Original Court PDF
Kishan MurarivsThe State (Govt Of Nct Of Delhi) & Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
