01Facts
The Respondent No. 2 borrower obtained a ₹30 crore term loan from the Respondent No. 4 Bank under a sanction letter dated 13.12.2012, and the Respondents No. 1 in the two petitions, as guarantors/mortgagors, mortgaged two parcels of land in Village Daulatabad, Gurgaon.
¶ 3(i)–(iii)The loan was declared an NPA on 31.12.2013, and a Demand Notice dated 05.02.2014 claimed ₹32,17,65,461.23.
¶ 3(iv)–(v)CIRP was initiated against the borrower on 08.05.2018, and the Resolution Plan was approved by the CoC on 11.06.2024, with the Bank's claim dealt with under the plan.
¶ 3(vi)–(vii)Sale Notices dated 06.02.2023, 24.03.2023 and 07.09.2023 claimed ₹126.20 crore, ₹127.67 crore and ₹137.78 crore respectively.
¶ 3(viii)The DRT dismissed the Respondent No. 1's Securitization Applications on 09.01.2026.
¶ 3(ix)The Respondent No. 1 appealed to the DRAT and sought reduction of the pre-deposit to 25% under Section 18(1) SARFAESI.
¶ 3(x)The Respondent No. 1 contended that agricultural land is exempt under Section 13(1), that Rules 8 and 9 were not complied with, and that the Demand Notice violated Section 31(1).
¶ 4–5The DRAT found that the Bank issued the 07.09.2023 Sale Notice nine years after the Section 13(2) notice without explanation, declined to apply Sidha Neelkanth, and rejected the guarantor/mortgagor joint-liability argument.
¶ 6–8The DRAT directed a pre-deposit of 30% of ₹32,17,65,461.32 (as stated in the Demand Notice).
¶ 9The auction purchaser (Petitioner) challenged only the quantum of the pre-deposit under Articles 226 and 227.
¶ 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the auction purchaser has locus standi to challenge a DRAT order that fixes only the quantum of pre-deposit under Section 18 SARFAESI.
¶ 10(i) · ¶ 11(i)ii.2. Whether the DRAT, by fixing the pre-deposit at 30% of the Demand Notice amount, acted beyond its jurisdiction, given the 25%/50% limits in the proviso to Section 18(1) and the "debt due" principles in Sidha Neelkanth.
¶ 10(iii)–(viii) · ¶ 18iii.3. Whether the DRAT's observations on the merits (mortgagor-only status and settlement under the Resolution Plan) can be interfered with at the interim stage.
¶ 10(ii) · ¶ 20iv.4. Whether the scope of judicial review under Articles 226 and 227 permits interference with the DRAT's discretionary pre-deposit order.
¶ 13–14 · ¶ 1903Law Applied
Section 18(1) SARFAESI bars entertaining an appeal unless the borrower deposits 50% of the debt due, as claimed by the secured creditor or determined by the DRT (whichever is less), and the third proviso empowers the Appellate Tribunal, for reasons recorded in writing, to reduce this to not less than 25%.
¶ 15–16Sidha Neelkanth Paper (P) Ltd. v. Prudent ARC Ltd., 2023 SCC OnLine SC 12, holds that "debt due" under Section 18 is the Section 13(2)/(4) demand amount where those steps alone are challenged, the sale certificate amount where only the sale is challenged, and the higher of the two where both are challenged.
¶ 17, quoting paras. 33–35Article 226/227 review is supervisory, not appellate, and a writ court does not substitute its own conclusion for the Tribunal's unless the order is perverse or wholly contrary to law, as laid down in L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, (1997) 3 SCC 261, and M.S. Sanjay v. Indian Bank, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 368.
¶ 13–14A mere wrong decision does not attract Article 227 jurisdiction, as held in Mohd. Yunus v. Mohd. Mustaqim, (1983) 3 SCC 566.
¶ 18An interim order is not a final expression on the merits of the appeal.
¶ 20Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 Section 2Section 13Section 17Section 18Section 31
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Section 7Section 31
Recovery Of Debts And Bankruptcy Act, 1993 Section 2
04Reasoning
The Court did not decide the locus question expressly and proceeded to the merits.
The DRAT exercised the discretion conferred by the third proviso to Section 18(1) within its jurisdiction, after recording reasons, namely the Bank's unexplained nine-year delay and the Respondent No. 1's status as mortgagor whose debts were addressed by the Resolution Plan.
¶ 6–9, 19The Petitioner's reliance on Sidha Neelkanth was an attempt to have the Court re-examine whether the Tribunal applied the judgment correctly, which is a question of law within the appellate domain and does not establish a jurisdictional error or a patent illegality amounting to a supervisory-jurisdiction ground.
¶ 18–19The 30% figure exceeded the statutory 25% floor, so the discretion was not exercised outside the statutory range.
¶ 19The DRAT's remarks on the Resolution Plan and the Bank's delay were made at the interim stage and therefore could not bind the final adjudication of the appeal on merits, which removed the prejudice the Petitioner had alleged.
¶ 20The reasoning on the scope of judicial review rests on the principle that a mere wrong decision is not enough to invoke Article 227.
¶ 18–1905Holding
The challenge to the quantum of pre-deposit did not disclose a jurisdictional error, patent illegality, or perversity warranting interference under Articles 226/227.
¶ 18–19The DRAT's fixing of a 30% pre-deposit under the third proviso to Section 18(1) was within its discretion, and any non-application of Sidha Neelkanth was at most a wrong decision, not a jurisdictional error.
¶ 18–19The DRAT's observations at the interim stage do not finally decide the appeal on merits.
¶ 20The Court did not record a finding on locus standi.
Both writ petitions were dismissed, along with pending applications.
¶ 21Original Court PDF
Vayuu Propmart Pvt. Ltd.vsNuray Realtech Pvt. Ltd
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
