Delhi High CourtTax LawAdministrative and Public Law

Delhi HC Sets Aside Tax Assessment Over HSBC Swiss Account Document Not Found During Search

Parag Dalmiav.Commissioner Of Income Tax.Circle-1 & Anr.

Delhi HC Sets Aside Tax Assessment Over HSBC Swiss Account Document Not Found During Search. Parag Dalmia vs Commissioner Of Income Tax.Circle-1 & Anr.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the ITAT was right in upholding the assessment made under Section 153A of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

The court held

The Court answered the framed questions in favour of the Assessee. It held that a Section 153A assessment cannot rest on a document that was neither found during the search nor connected to incriminating material found during it, and that the first-round remand was erroneous in law.

It also directed

The Court did not expressly answer Question 2 (jurisdictional pre-conditions) or Question 3 (abatement) in separate terms; the answers are implicit in paras 14–15 and 19–20.

Both appeals were allowed and the remand order was set aside.

Since the remand was set aside, all consequent orders, including the impugned orders dated 26.02.2018 and 30.08.2024, were set aside.

01Facts

The Assessee, an individual, filed his return for AY 2006-07 declaring Rs. 20,73,131.

p. 2, para 3(i)

A search under Section 132 was conducted at his residence on 20.01.2012. During the search, a seven-page document, allegedly showing him as beneficial owner of HSBC Bank (Switzerland) accounts, was shown to him but was already in the officer's possession and was not recovered.

p. 2, para 3(ii)

The search yielded only jewellery.

p. 30, para 14

A Section 153A notice was issued on 17.10.2012, and the Assessee filed a return declaring the same income.

pp. 2–3, para 3(iii)

The Assessing Officer (AO) issued a Section 142(1) notice on 18.07.2013 and made an addition of Rs. 1,20,37,863 under Section 69.

pp. 3, para 3(iv)–(v)

The CIT(A) confirmed the addition and rejected the objection that no incriminating material was found during the search.

pp. 3–4, para 3(vi)

The ITAT, in the first round (order dated 26.02.2018), held the verification of the documents was pending and remanded the matter to the AO for verificatory reports from Switzerland.

pp. 4–5, para 3(viii) · p. 5, para 36 of ITAT order

On remand, the CIT(A) upheld the addition, relying on the Assessee's earlier agreement to pay tax, which he retracted after nine months, and his refusal to sign a consent waiver.

pp. 5–6, para 3(ix)–(x)

In the second round (order dated 30.08.2024), the ITAT held that jurisdiction under Section 153A could not be reopened and that the refusal to sign the waiver supported an adverse inference.

pp. 7–9, para 3(xi)

Both orders are challenged in these appeals.

p. 9, para 3(xii)

02Issues

i.1. Whether the ITAT was right in upholding the assessment made under Section 153A of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

pp. 11–12, para 9 and para 11

ii.2. Whether the jurisdictional pre-conditions for making an addition of undisclosed income from the HSBC account in a Section 153A assessment were met.

pp. 11–12, para 9 and para 11

iii.3. Whether the assessment for AY 2006-07 abates where the document containing entries in the Assessee's name was not found or seized during the search, was only shown to him during search, and no addition was made on the basis of any seized material.

p. 12, para 10 and para 11

03Law Applied

The Court examined Sections 132, 132A and 153A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which together make a Section 153A block assessment contingent on a search or requisition.

pp. 12–30, para 12–13

Section 153A does not authorise assessment on the basis of material that was neither found during the search nor connected to incriminating material found during it.

p. 30, para 14

The Supreme Court in CIT v. Abhisar Buildwell (P) Ltd., (2024) 2 SCC 433 held that the foundation of a Section 153A assessment is incriminating material detected during the search; where none is found, completed assessments cannot be disturbed, and the Revenue's only remedy is reassessment under Sections 147/148.

pp. 31–37, para 16 (paras 29–36.4 of the judgment)

The Delhi High Court in CIT v. Kabul Chawla, (2016) 380 ITR 573 held that once a search occurs, notice under Section 153A is mandatory, pending assessments abate, and completed assessments may be interfered with only on the basis of incriminating material unearthed during the search.

pp. 36–38, para 17 (para 37 of the judgment)

Law declared by constitutional courts is declaratory and has retrospective effect, so authorities must apply it to proceedings pending on the date of their pronouncement.

p. 39, para 18

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Information Technology Act, 2000 Section 2

04Reasoning

The Court first noted that the search recovered only jewellery and no HSBC-related documents, and that the seven-page document was already with the Revenue before the search.

p. 30, para 14

It held that if Section 153A were read to permit notice based on a document neither found during the search nor corroborating a document found during it, the provision would be open to abuse and would give the Revenue unbridled power.

p. 30, para 14

The Court held that the Revenue could reopen assessment under other provisions of the Act relying on such material, but not through Section 153A.

pp. 30–31, para 15

Rejecting the Revenue's argument that the first-round remand pre-dated Abhisar Buildwell and Kabul Chawla, the Court noted that the ITAT's order of 26.02.2018 was passed after Kabul Chawla (28.08.2015) and that the law laid down by those decisions applied to it.

p. 39, para 18

On that basis, the Court held that the ITAT erred in remanding the matter to verify a document that could not, on the facts, support a Section 153A assessment.

p. 39, para 19

The Assessee's earlier agreement to pay tax and his subsequent retraction were held not to assist the Revenue, since a defective Section 153A notice vitiates all proceedings founded on it.

p. 39, para 20

The Court therefore did not reach the merits of the addition or the consent-waiver issue.

pp. 39–40, para 20

05Holding

The Court answered the framed questions in favour of the Assessee. It held that a Section 153A assessment cannot rest on a document that was neither found during the search nor connected to incriminating material found during it, and that the first-round remand was erroneous in law.

p. 30, para 14 · p. 39, para 19 · pp. 39–40, para 20

The Court did not expressly answer Question 2 (jurisdictional pre-conditions) or Question 3 (abatement) in separate terms; the answers are implicit in paras 14–15 and 19–20.

pp. 30–31 · pp. 39–40

Both appeals were allowed and the remand order was set aside.

pp. 40, para 21–22

Since the remand was set aside, all consequent orders, including the impugned orders dated 26.02.2018 and 30.08.2024, were set aside.

p. 40, para 22
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Parag DalmiavsCommissioner Of Income Tax.Circle-1 & Anr.

Delhi High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment