01Facts
The Respondent-Assessee is engaged in real estate construction and development, including townships, housing and commercial premises.
¶ 2For AY 2012-13 the Assessee declared a loss of Rs. 7,82,95,075.
¶ 3In scrutiny assessment under Section 143(3), the AO on 19.03.2015 disallowed 90% (Rs. 8,73,10,314) of revenue expenditure of Rs. 9,70,11,460, holding it was connected with projects under development and should be capitalised as project cost or work-in-progress (WIP), since no project revenue was recognised that year.
¶ 3–4The AO thus allowed only 10%.
¶ 4The CIT(A) confirmed the addition on 02.01.2017.
¶ 5The ITAT, by order dated 31.07.2025, deleted the disallowance. It found that the Assessee had allocated project-related costs to inventory under AS-7 and the ICAI Guidance Note, claimed the balance as revenue expenditure, and followed this consistently from AY 2011-12.
¶ 6The revenue had accepted that method in AY 2011-12 (except finance cost) and in later years, and the AO had completed some later assessments accepting the claim.
¶ 7–8The Revenue appealed under Section 260A, raising six proposed substantial questions of law.
¶ 7, 1902Issues
i.1. Whether the ITAT erred in allowing Rs. 9,70,11,460 as revenue expenditure in a year in which no project revenue was recognised under POCM and the AS-7/Guidance Note threshold was not crossed.
¶ 19(A)ii.2. Whether the ITAT misapplied the law by holding that expenditure not capitalised is automatically allowable, ignoring the matching principle and Supreme Court precedent.
¶ 19(B)iii.3. Whether the ITAT erred in treating the AO's 10% allowance as an admission that the entire expenditure is allowable.
¶ 19(C)iv.4. Whether the ITAT wrongly permitted deferral of income under POCM while claiming immediate deduction of overheads attributable to unfinished projects, thereby violating Section 145.
¶ 19(D)v.5. Whether reliance on the co-ordinate bench decision in AB Multiplex and the rule of consistency is legally sustainable against Supreme Court precedent on matching.
¶ 19(E)vi.6. Whether the ITAT order is perverse on law and facts.
¶ 19(F)03Law Applied
The Court's jurisdiction under Section 260A is confined to a "substantial question of law," which must be debatable, not previously settled, and materially affect the outcome; the ITAT is the final fact-finding authority, and its findings may be disturbed only if perverse or based on no evidence or misapplied law, citing CIT v. Hamdard National Foundation, 2022 SCC OnLine Del 513; Shri Chunilal V. Mehta, AIR 1962 SC 1314; Santosh Hazari, (2001) 3 SCC 179; Hero Vinoth, (2006) 5 SCC 545; Vijay Kumar Talwar; and Mangalore Ganesh Beedi Works.
¶ 20–21Under Section 37, allowability of expenditure depends on its nature and whether it is wholly and exclusively for business; earning revenue in the year is not a precondition.
¶ 6, 23AS-7 and the ICAI Guidance Note on real estate distinguish project-directly-attributable costs (capitalised as WIP) from general administrative and selling costs (which are not project costs).
¶ 9, 14Per Virtual Soft Systems Ltd. v. ACIT, 404 ITR 409 (SC), ICAI accounting standards may inform income recognition, as relied on by the ITAT.
¶ 6The rule of consistency in accounting cannot override the provisions of the IT Act.
¶ 24A partial allowance by the AO is not a conclusive admission of deductibility.
¶ 24The Revenue also relied on Tuticorin Alkali Chemicals, 227 ITR 172 (SC), and the Court noted that AB Multiplex (ITA 739/Del/2014) was relied upon by the ITAT.
¶ 6, 12Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The Court held that the six questions were, at their core, questions of fact. The ITAT had considered the accounting method, the allocation of expenditure to WIP, the business purpose of the expenses, and the applicable AS-7 and Guidance Note framework, and had found the 90% ad hoc disallowance "totally arbitrary."
¶ 6–7, 23The ITAT's findings were grounded in the material on record and were not shown to be perverse.
¶ 23On Questions C and E, the Court accepted that the AO's partial allowance is not an admission, and that consistency cannot override the statute, but noted that the ITAT's conclusion rested independently on its factual findings on nature and allocation of expenses.
¶ 24Question D raised the same underlying factual distinction between project-attributable and Section 37-deductible overheads. The Revenue did not show that the ITAT misread the Guidance Note or the statute.
¶ 25Question F identified no specific material establishing a substantial question of law.
¶ 26The ITAT's consistent-method finding, its reliance on subsequent assessments accepting the claim, and the Revenue's non-rejection of the books under Section 145(3) supported the factual conclusion.
¶ 7–8, 14The Court did not separately analyse Tuticorin Alkali or Virtual Soft Systems in detail, resting its reasoning on the Section 260A threshold and the factual character of the findings.
¶ 22–2605Holding
The Court held that the proposed questions do not give rise to a substantial question of law warranting interference under Section 260A.
¶ 27The appeal is dismissed, and any pending applications are closed.
¶ 28The ITAT's deletion of the Rs. 8,73,10,314 disallowance stands, and the expenditure remains allowable as revenue expenditure for AY 2012-13.
¶ 8, 27–28Original Court PDF
Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central, GurugramvsM/S Experion Developers Pvt. Ltd.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
