01Facts
The Appellant's land (25 bighas 13 biswas, Village Tikri Kalan) was acquired under the LA Act. Possession was taken on 13.11.1997.
¶ 4The LAC's Award dated 15.09.1998 fixed market value at ₹2,08,333/- per bigha (Category A) and ₹1,83,333/- per bigha (Category B).
¶ 5The awarded amount was not paid until a cheque of about ₹72.12 lakh was handed over in the High Court on 20.02.2002 in W.P.(C) 5463/1999.
¶ 6, 10The LAC paid ₹3,84,295/- (interest for part of the delay) and ₹1,27,538/- (interest on solatium and additional amount, following Sunder) in February 2005.
¶ 7The Writ Petition was disposed of on 05.05.2005, remitting the delay question to the Reference Court.
¶ 8In the Reference Judgment dated 10.05.2016 (corrected 07.03.2017), the Reference Court directed interest at 15% p.a. under Section 34 on the Collector's compensation for 15.09.1998 to 20.02.2002.
¶ 10, Ref. J. para 35The Reference Court enhanced the rates, granted solatium, additional amount, and interest under Section 28 at 9% then 15% p.a. "till the entire payment of the compensation is made".
¶ 11, Ref. J. paras 43–46The Reference Court extended "statutory benefits" per Sunder.
¶ 12, Ref. J. para 47The Reference Court denied 15% interest for 18.02.2010 to 30.03.2016 due to the Appellant's delay.
¶ 13, Ref. J. para 48The additional amount period was later confined to 12.08.1997–13.11.1997 by order dated 16.07.2023.
¶ 14In execution (Ex. 202/2017), ₹28,85,895/- was paid on 28.11.2018 towards the Para 35 interest.
¶ 16The Appellant claimed ₹1,59,86,263/- on the basis that the Para 35 interest was itself a "statutory benefit" bearing further interest.
¶ 17, 19The Civil Nazir rejected this as "interest upon interest" and computed a balance of ₹88,681/-.
¶ 18, 21–22By order dated 17.12.2025, the Executing Court accepted the Civil Nazir's computation.
¶ 23The Appellant appealed under Section 104 CPC.
¶ 1, 2502Issues
i.1. Whether the interest awarded under Para 35 of the Reference Judgment (Section 34, LA Act) is "interest on the compensation" that can attract further interest under Para 46 (Section 28, "till the entire payment of the compensation is made").
¶ 59–67ii.2. Whether the Para 35 interest is a "statutory benefit" under Para 47 read with Sunder, forming part of "compensation" and bearing further interest.
¶ 69–80iii.3. Whether the Respondent's failure to challenge Para 35 and its lack of objection in execution bars the Executing Court from declining the claim for interest on that interest.
¶ 81–87iv.4. Whether the Appellant's computation (₹1,59,86,263/-) or the Civil Nazir's computation (₹88,681/-) correctly reflects the amount payable under the Reference Judgment.
¶ 88–9303Law Applied
The Court relied on Sections 34 and 28 of the LA Act, which both prescribe 9% then 15% p.a. interest but operate on different sums: Section 34 on the Collector's awarded amount for delayed payment, and Section 28 on the excess compensation determined by the Court. The two are mutually exclusive, so each rupee of compensation carries interest once only, and interest is not compounded.
¶ 60–63The Court relied on Sunder v. Union of India, (2001) 7 SCC 211, which holds that "compensation" under Section 23 includes solatium and the additional amount, so interest under Sections 28 and 34 runs on the aggregate, but does not make interest itself a component of compensation.
¶ 73–75, 78CIT v. Ghanshyam (HUF), (2009) 8 SCC 412, distinguishes Section 28 interest (part of enhanced compensation) from Section 34 interest (compensation for delay only).
¶ 76–77An executing court must enforce a decree in accordance with its terms, may construe the judgment to ascertain its true import, but cannot enlarge it.
¶ 87Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 104Section 151
04Reasoning
On Issue 1, the Court rejected the premise that Para 35 granted "excess compensation." Para 35 expressly rests on Section 34, while Para 46 rests on Section 28, so reading Para 46 to cover Para 35 interest would collapse two separate heads and produce interest on interest.
¶ 60, 66The phrase "till the entire payment of the compensation is made" in Para 46 refers only to the enhanced compensation under Section 28.
¶ 65On Issue 2, Sunder addresses the base on which interest runs. It does not make accrued interest part of that base. Para 47 extends the Sunder benefit only to the compensation base, so reliance on "statutory benefits" cannot create an independent entitlement to interest on Para 35 interest.
¶ 74–75, 79–80On Issue 3, the Court held that the Reference Judgment was final and the Appellant could have sought clarification or appellate relief but did not. The Respondent's silence or the Civil Nazir's later objection does not expand the decree, and the Executing Court was entitled to examine the computation.
¶ 85–87On Issue 4, the Court found the Appellant's three computations inconsistent and overstated. They applied an incorrect differential rate (₹52,482/- instead of ₹27,482/-), wrong areas, an overstated solatium period, and interest on interest. They also gave no credit for the February 2005 payments.
¶ 90–92The Civil Nazir's computation, which excluded 18.02.2010–30.03.2016, used the correct additional-amount period, and applied interest to the solatium-inclusive base, was found to accord with the Reference Judgment. The Court also expressed strong disapproval of the Appellant's overstated claims.
¶ 88–89, 9305Holding
The Court answered all four issues against the Appellant. Para 35 interest is referable only to Section 34 and does not attract further interest under Para 46 (Section 28) or Para 47/Sunder.
¶ 67, 80The Respondent's non-challenge does not enlarge the decree, and the Executing Court properly examined the computation.
¶ 85–87The Civil Nazir's computation of ₹88,681/- correctly reflects the amount payable.
¶ 94, 96The Appeal is dismissed and the Impugned Order dated 17.12.2025 in Ex. 202/2017 is upheld. The LAC (West) is directed to pay ₹88,681/- within two weeks, if not already paid. The Executing Court is then to dispose of Ex. 202/2017 in accordance with law. No order as to costs.
¶ 95–96, 98Original Court PDF
Deepjot Singh AnandvsUnion Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
