Delhi High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceWills, Inheritance, and Trusts

Delhi HC Upholds Partition Sale Despite Son's Unprobated Will, Leaves Its Effect to Probate Proceedings

Rakesh Sharma (Since Deceased) Thr Lrv.Smt. Vineeta Sharma & Ors.

Delhi HC Upholds Partition Sale Despite Son's Unprobated Will, Leaves Its Effect to Probate Proceedings. Rakesh Sharma (Since Deceased) Thr Lr vs Smt. Vineeta Sharma & Ors.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether execution was premature in view of the 15.05.2018 judgment in RFA No. 301/2017, which reportedly made the partition decree unenforceable until defendants chose to divide their shares

The court held

Execution was not premature because the 2018 judgment was superseded by the 12.12.2024 preliminary decree and the final decree, which is the operative decree

It also directed

The alleged concealment of the Will is a merits-based suppression, not a jurisdictional fraud, so it did not render the decrees a nullity for Section 47 purposes

The Will's effect is confined to inter se shares among the legal heirs and must be determined in PC No. 7/2024, CS SCJ No. 468/2024, and CS SCJ No. 835/2024

Counsel's alleged misconduct and hardship are not grounds to resist execution

No perversity or jurisdictional error was found. The Appeal is dismissed and the Executing Court's order dated 15.04.2026 is affirmed

The Court clarified that it expresses no opinion on the Will's validity, and the Appellant's rights in the share retained in court remain unaffected. No order as to costs

01Facts

The dispute arises from partition suit CS DJ No. 8078/2016, filed by Respondent No. 1, Vineeta Sharma, over the suit property, A-53, South Extension, Part-II, New Delhi

¶ 2

Following this Court's judgment dated 15.05.2018 in RFA No. 301/2017 and subsequent Supreme Court proceedings under Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, this Court passed a fresh preliminary decree dated 12.12.2024 declaring Respondent No. 1's share as one-third and remanding for final decree proceedings

¶ 2

The Executing Court passed an order dated 15.02.2025 and a final decree dated 27.10.2025 directing sale of the property and distribution of proceeds

¶ 3

The Appellant, son of the deceased Rakesh Sharma, claims a registered Will dated 20.04.2022 bequeathing his father's interest exclusively to him, which was not placed before the courts. Probate proceedings (PC No. 7/2024) are pending

¶ 4

The Appellant filed objections under Section 47 CPC alleging fraud/concealment, prematurity in view of the 2018 judgment, and prejudice to his occupation

¶ 5

The Executing Court dismissed the objections

¶ 6 · ¶ 24

The Appellant appealed under Order XXI Rule 58(4) CPC

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether execution was premature in view of the 15.05.2018 judgment in RFA No. 301/2017, which reportedly made the partition decree unenforceable until defendants chose to divide their shares

¶ 12 · ¶ 26–27

ii.2. Whether the alleged suppression of the registered Will amounts to fraud rendering the decrees a nullity, such that it can be raised under Section 47 CPC in execution

¶ 23 · ¶ 28–29

iii.3. Whether the Appellant's testamentary claim under the Will can be adjudicated within execution proceedings, or whether it must be determined in independent proceedings and does not bar sale

¶ 33–35

iv.4. Whether the alleged misconduct of the Appellant's earlier counsel, or the hardship of residential occupation, justifies interference with execution

¶ 37–38

03Law Applied

The court applied the settled principle that an executing court cannot go behind the decree, sit in appeal over it, or examine its merits, save where the decree is a nullity for want of inherent jurisdiction, as drawn from Vasudev Dhanjibhai Modi v. Rajabhai Abdul Rehman and Rafique Bibi v. Sayed Waliuddin, and reaffirmed in Periyammal v. V. Rajamani

¶ 21 · ¶ 22

Under Section 47 CPC, the Executing Court's reasoning, endorsed by this Court, holds that fraud renders a decree a nullity only if it is "fraud on the court" of a jurisdictional character (e.g., suing a fictitious person or suppressing the institution of the suit). Suppression of evidence or documents going to the merits is a defence to be raised during trial or appeal, not in execution

¶ 24, Executing Court ¶8.1 · ¶ 28

A later decree supersedes an earlier one, and the later decree is the one to be executed

¶ 24, Executing Court ¶7.2 · ¶ 26–27

The inter se shares of legal heirs under a Will are to be determined in appropriate proceedings and cannot be adjudicated collaterally in execution

¶ 24, Executing Court ¶9.1 · ¶ 33–35

Hardship to a judgment debtor does not bar execution of a decree for sale

¶ 38

Relevant authority includes Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma, (2020) 9 SCC 1

¶ 26

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 47Section 151

Hindu Succession Act, 1956 Section 6

04Reasoning

The Court held that the 2018 judgment could not defeat execution. The Supreme Court had remanded the matter for reconsideration in light of Vineeta Sharma, and this Court's fresh preliminary decree of 12.12.2024 set aside the trial court's 2016 decree, so the 2018 judgment had been displaced

¶ 26–27 · ¶ 24, Executing Court ¶7

On fraud, the Court reasoned that even accepting the alleged concealment, the Will concerns testamentary interest in the suit property and does not show that the courts lacked jurisdiction to decide the partition

¶ 28–29

The Appellant's own averments undermined his position: the Will took effect on the father's death in 2023, probate was instituted in February 2024, the Will was read out in mediation on 11.11.2024 before the preliminary decree, and it was annexed to an application before the trial court before the final decree. These facts showed that the Appellant had the opportunity to place the Will on record at the appropriate stage

¶ 30–31

The Appellant had also pursued a separate remedy by filing RFA No. 763/2025 against the final decree, which remained pending without stay

¶ 32

On the merits of the Will, the Court held that it could at most affect the inter se shares of Rakesh Sharma's legal heirs. The collective one-third share of the legal heirs was fixed by the preliminary decree, with inter se shares left to independent proceedings, so the Will could not defeat the decree-holder's one-third share

¶ 33–36

The alleged negligence of prior counsel did not create nullity or enlarge the executing court's jurisdiction, and hardship from residential occupation did not authorise refusal of a decree for sale

¶ 37 · ¶ 38

05Holding

Execution was not premature because the 2018 judgment was superseded by the 12.12.2024 preliminary decree and the final decree, which is the operative decree

¶ 26–27

The alleged concealment of the Will is a merits-based suppression, not a jurisdictional fraud, so it did not render the decrees a nullity for Section 47 purposes

¶ 28–31

The Will's effect is confined to inter se shares among the legal heirs and must be determined in PC No. 7/2024, CS SCJ No. 468/2024, and CS SCJ No. 835/2024

¶ 34–35 · ¶ 42

Counsel's alleged misconduct and hardship are not grounds to resist execution

¶ 37–38

No perversity or jurisdictional error was found. The Appeal is dismissed and the Executing Court's order dated 15.04.2026 is affirmed

¶ 39–41

The Court clarified that it expresses no opinion on the Will's validity, and the Appellant's rights in the share retained in court remain unaffected. No order as to costs

¶ 42 · ¶ 43
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Rakesh Sharma (Since Deceased) Thr LrvsSmt. Vineeta Sharma & Ors.

Delhi High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment