Delhi High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Delhi HC Sets Aside Eviction Order After Landlord's Witness Admits Shop Is Single Hall, Not Rooms Shown in Site Plan

Suresh Kumarv.S. Esvinder Singii

Delhi HC Sets Aside Eviction Order After Landlord's Witness Admits Shop Is Single Hall, Not Rooms Shown in Site Plan. Suresh Kumar vs S. Esvinder Singii. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the learned ARC erred in failing to consider PW-1's admissions that the premises comprised a single hall without partitions, which were inconsistent with the site plan's depiction of rooms and a kitchen, and which bear on the Respondents' claim of inadequate accommodation and artificial scarcity.

The court held

The impugned judgment dated 24.03.2025 suffers from a material infirmity because the ARC failed to adequately consider PW-1's cross-examination admissions and their bearing on the Respondents' claim of inadequate accommodation.

It also directed

The revision petition is allowed, the impugned judgment is set aside, and the eviction petition (RC ARC No. 79340/2016) is remanded for de novo consideration on the material already on record, with the ARC to examine the pleadings, documents and cross-examination admissions independently and decide expeditiously, preferably within six months. The Court expressed no opinion on the merits, including the genuineness of the bona fide requirement. All pending applications stand disposed of.

01Facts

The Respondents (landlords) sought eviction of the Petitioner's predecessor-in-interest from a commercial shop of about 14.36 sq. yds. at 1584/31, Abdul Rehman Road, Karol Bagh, under Section 14(1)(e) read with Section 25-B of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 (DRC Act), on the ground of bona fide requirement for business expansion and storage.

¶ 2–4

The Respondents relied on a site plan depicting separate rooms, a kitchen, a tin shed and a bathroom in the portions in their occupation.

¶ 4, 8

Leave to defend was granted, and the matter proceeded to trial.

¶ 5–6

In cross-examination, PW-1 (Respondent No. 1) stated that the premises were "a single hall without any partition," that there was no room or kitchen in his occupation, that he could not say whether the site plan (Ex. PW-1/1) was correct, and that he did not know who prepared it.

¶ 9, 21

The learned ARC allowed the eviction petition by judgment dated 24.03.2025, finding bona fide requirement established and treating the site plan as a supporting document, while noting the Petitioner had identified the tenanted portion.

¶ 7, 33

The Petitioner challenged this in revision under the proviso to Section 25-B(8).

¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the learned ARC erred in failing to consider PW-1's admissions that the premises comprised a single hall without partitions, which were inconsistent with the site plan's depiction of rooms and a kitchen, and which bear on the Respondents' claim of inadequate accommodation and artificial scarcity.

¶ 17, 18, 34

ii.2. Whether the Petitioner's identification of the tenanted portion in cross-examination amounts to an admission of the correctness of the entire site plan.

¶ 23–24

iii.3. Whether the principle that a tenant disputing a site plan must file a counter site plan applies where the discrepancy arises from the landlord's own witness's testimony.

¶ 26–30

iv.4. Whether the impugned judgment is amenable to interference in revisional jurisdiction under the proviso to Section 25-B(8) of the DRC Act.

¶ 15–16, 36–38

03Law Applied

The proviso to Section 25-B(8) of the DRC Act confers revisional jurisdiction that is supervisory and not appellate, and interference is restricted to error apparent on the face of the record or procedural infirmity, as explained in Abid-ul-Islam v. Inder Sain Dua.

¶ 15–16

A finding arrived at without consideration of material evidence, based on misreading of evidence or no evidence, is not a finding according to law and is open to correction, as held by the Constitution Bench in Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Dilbahar Singh.

¶ 36

Omission to consider clinching evidence is a ground for revisional interference, as recognised in Mohd. Inam v. Sanjay Kumar Singhal.

¶ 37

A site plan is a supporting document whose absence or inconsequential discrepancy does not ipso facto defeat eviction.

¶ 25

The line of cases holding that a tenant contesting a site plan must file a counter site plan, including Amrit Lal, Harminder Singh Koghar and Rishal Singh, was distinguished in light of Neelam Jain v. Vandana Sachdeva and Rajender Kumar Pahuja v. Anup Narain Gaur.

¶ 26–30

Non-adjudication of material cross-examination and documents on bona fide requirement justifies remand, as in Sh. Tek Chand (Deceased) v. Smt. Meenakshi Gupta (2025 SCC OnLine Del 6417).

¶ 39

The bona fide requirement framework under Section 14(1)(e), including the presumption in favour of landlord under Baldev Singh Bajwa v. Monish Saini, is the substantive standard.

¶ 33

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

delhi rent control act, 1958 Section 14Section 19

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 115

04Reasoning

The controversy was confined to whether the Respondents' asserted inadequacy of existing accommodation was consistent with their own evidence.

¶ 17

Because the Respondents' case rested on insufficient existing space, the physical configuration of the occupied portions was a relevant circumstance.

¶ 20

PW-1's testimony of a single undivided hall, coupled with his inability to vouch for the site plan's room and kitchen depiction, created a material discrepancy arising from the landlord's own evidence.

¶ 21, 31–32

The Petitioner's identification of the tenanted shop did not equate to admitting the site plan's accuracy for the remaining portions, as identity of the tenanted premises and the nature of the remaining accommodation are distinct questions.

¶ 22–24

The counter-site-plan principle in Neelam Jain and Rajender Kumar Pahuja was held inapplicable, since those cases involved bald objections or admissions in other proceedings, whereas here the challenge arose from the landlord's own witness.

¶ 26–30

The ARC noticed the site plan dispute but did not examine PW-1's admissions against the bona fide requirement case, leaving material evidence unappreciated.

¶ 33–34

This was not a re-appreciation of evidence but a test of whether material evidence was considered, which falls within revisional scope.

¶ 35–38

05Holding

The impugned judgment dated 24.03.2025 suffers from a material infirmity because the ARC failed to adequately consider PW-1's cross-examination admissions and their bearing on the Respondents' claim of inadequate accommodation.

¶ 41

The revision petition is allowed, the impugned judgment is set aside, and the eviction petition (RC ARC No. 79340/2016) is remanded for de novo consideration on the material already on record, with the ARC to examine the pleadings, documents and cross-examination admissions independently and decide expeditiously, preferably within six months. The Court expressed no opinion on the merits, including the genuineness of the bona fide requirement. All pending applications stand disposed of.

¶ 42–45
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Suresh KumarvsS. Esvinder Singii

Delhi High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment