01Facts
The batch comprises ten intellectual property suits decided together, lead matter První Brněnská Strojírna Velká Bíteš a.s. & Anr. v. Deep Aviation Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. (CS(COMM) 973/2026), with Gebr Schmid GmbH v. Waaree Energies Ltd. (CS(COMM) 350/2026), HLE Glascoat Ltd. v. Sachin Industries Ltd. (CS(COMM) 1054/2024), Mold-Tek Packaging Ltd. v. Ideal Technoplast Industries Ltd. (CS(COMM) 609/2024), Sotkon SP SLU v. Western Imaginary Transcon Pvt. Ltd. (CS(COMM) 484/2021), Novartis AG v. Lucius Pharmaceuticals Co. Ltd. (CS(COMM) 1060/2026), Global Music Junction Pvt. Ltd. v. Songbird Digital India Pvt. Ltd. (CS(COMM) 1208/2026), Nyra Chocolates Pvt. Ltd. v. Dolphin Foods India Ltd. (CS(COMM) 785/2026), Dr. Reddy's Laboratories Ltd. v. Razenta Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd. (CS(COMM) 1176/2026), and Plusplus Lifescience LLP v. Myown Healthcare Pvt. Ltd. (CS(COMM) 251/2026).
The ten suits concern patent, design, copyright, trademark, passing off and trade secret claims. In each, the plaintiff pleaded Delhi jurisdiction under s.20 CPC and, where applicable, s.134(2) of the Trade Marks Act or s.62(2) of the Copyright Act.
¶ 2, 5První Brněnská (973/2026): Czech plaintiff; defendant no. 1 registered in Punjab. Alleged copyright, passing off and trade secret misuse concerning TJ100/TJ150 turbojet engines. Delhi nexus was pleaded through exports from Delhi port and an IndiaMart listing. The goods were manufactured in Punjab.
¶ 6–6.4, 6.14Gebr Schmid (350/2026): German plaintiff; patent IN'508. Defendant registered in Mumbai with a branch in Surat, where manufacturing occurs. Delhi sales were pleaded through an invoice and an investigator's affidavit.
¶ 7.1–7.3, 7.8HLE Glascoat (1054/2024): Both parties in Gujarat; patent IN 428407. Delhi nexus rested on website and IndiaMart accessibility.
¶ 8–8.2Mold-Tek (609/2024): Hyderabad plaintiff; five Surat defendants; patent and design claims. Delhi nexus rested on e-marketplace listings and delivery claims.
¶ 9–9.2Sotkon (484/2021): Spanish plaintiff; patent IN'620 and copyright. Tender in Gandhinagar. Defendants 1 and 2 are in Mumbai and Delhi; defendants 1, 3 and 4 are outside Delhi and no leave was obtained.
¶ 10.1–10.6Novartis (1060/2026): Swiss plaintiff; patent IN'655 (Dabrafenib). Defendants in Laos, West Bengal and Bengaluru. An investigator purchased the drug in Delhi on 25.07.2026. Plaintiff no. 2 is in Mumbai and holds the marketing licence.
¶ 11–11.4Global Music (1208/2026): Mumbai plaintiff; content licensing dispute. Agreements contain Mumbai exclusive jurisdiction clauses. Delhi nexus rested on streaming accessibility and impact.
¶ 12–12.5, 12.7Nyra Chocolates (785/2026): Indore plaintiff; registered design and passing off. Delhi nexus rested on a trap purchase at Badarpur, where the bill stated "All disputes subject to Siwan Jurisdiction only".
¶ 13.2–13.5Dr. Reddy's (1176/2026): Hyderabad plaintiff with a Delhi branch; trademark infringement and passing off (DAPLO / DAPLOGIN). Delhi nexus rested on one e-pharmacy purchase.
¶ 14.1, 14.4, 14.6Plusplus (251/2026): Noida plaintiffs; quia timet patent and trademark suit. Defendants in Mumbai and Dehradun. Delhi nexus rested on doctor-sourced samples. Defendant no. 2 moved under O.VII R.10 CPC.
¶ 15–15.402Issues
i.1. Whether this Court has territorial jurisdiction under s.20 CPC (and, where pleaded, s.134(2) TM Act or s.62(2) Copyright Act) where the pleaded acts occurred outside Delhi and Delhi is linked only through exports, offers, website access, e-marketplace listings, investigator purchases or the effects of infringement.
¶ 2, 3(F)–(H), 6.5, 7.8–7.10, 10.5, 13.3–13.6, 15.7–15.9ii.2. Whether, even if a part of the cause of action arose in Delhi, the Court should decline to entertain the suit on the doctrine of forum non conveniens.
¶ 3(I), 4, 6.13–6.15, 7.11, 8.3, 9.7, 10.11, 11.4–11.5, 12.10, 13.10, 16–17iii.3. Whether leave under s.20(b) CPC can be granted against non-resident defendants where the agreements or circumstances point to another forum.
¶ 10.6–10.7, 12.1003Law Applied
The Court applied s.20 CPC, read with the principles in ABD Maestro (2026:DHC:9844).
¶ 2–3Under ABD Maestro, a cause of action arises in Delhi for infringement only where the defendant's infringing use occurs within the forum (offline), and for online activity only where the defendant purposefully targets the forum and commercial transactions are concluded there, subject to a relaxation where no Indian presence exists.
¶ 3(E)–(F)Sales are relevant only where they are made at a commercial scale to distributors, wholesalers or retailers; mere availability of goods does not confer jurisdiction.
¶ 3(D)Impact or effect of infringement felt in the forum, and the "dynamic effect" theory, do not confer jurisdiction, and investigator-based evidence is generally unreliable unless exceptions apply.
¶ 3(G)–(H)Under the doctrine of forum non conveniens, the court assesses whether the Delhi part of the cause of action is "material, integral and essential" or merely slender, applying the pleaded facts, as affirmed in Sai Maghalakshmi Traders (SC, 2026) and Smith Kline & French v. Block.
¶ 3(I), 4, 17Bald averments are pierced under Manjula (2026 INSC 465).
¶ 3(J), 13.6Also relied upon: ss.134(2) TM Act and 62(2) Copyright Act; s.29(6) TM Act; s.48 Patents Act; s.39 Sale of Goods Act (delivery to carrier); Banyan Tree on transactions with the defendant; Burger King on forms of trademark "use"; Sanjay Dalia and Ultra Home on sub-ordinate offices; Sameer Wankhede (merger rule); and Patel Roadways/New Moga on exclusive jurisdiction clauses.
¶ 2, 3(D)(iii), 6.6, 6.7, 7.4, 7.5, 13.5, 14.2, 14.6, 14.7Leave under s.20(b) is governed by the same forum conveniens considerations.
¶ 10.7Provisions in the judgment · 12 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Trade Marks Act, 1999 Section 28Section 29Section 56Section 134
Copyright Act, 1957 Section 62
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 19Section 20Section 151
Sale of Goods Act, 1930 Section 39
Patents Act, 1970 Section 47Section 48Section 104
04Reasoning
In První Brněnská, export from Delhi port and the sale of infringing goods were acknowledged as Delhi acts, but the Court held they were not the "dominant" part of the dispute because the goods were manufactured and the trade secret breach occurred in Punjab.
¶ 6.5, 6.8–6.14Where the Delhi element was limited to exports or sales, the Court observed that a narrow suit might be entertained, but a suit seeking to restrain the entire infringing activity must be filed where the infringement originates.
¶ 6.13In Gebr Schmid, HLE, Mold-Tek and Sotkon, the manufacture, tender and principal activity lay in Gujarat, and Delhi links rested on website access, IndiaMart listings or a single invoice; the Court held that such accessibility does not amount to carrying on business in Delhi.
¶ 7.8–7.10, 8.2–8.3, 9.4–9.7, 10.10In Novartis, the single investigator purchase was treated as a slender connection, and Mumbai, where plaintiff no. 2 holds the licence, was the natural forum.
¶ 11.3–11.4In Global Music, the Court rejected impact on the plaintiff in Delhi and Delhi streaming access as a cause of action, and noted the exclusive Mumbai jurisdiction clauses.
¶ 12.8–12.10In Nyra, the trap purchase was not supported by adequate pleadings on fairness, delivery was made at Indore, and the bill's "Siwan jurisdiction" clause pointed elsewhere.
¶ 13.3–13.5In Dr. Reddy's, the Delhi pleadings relied on distributors and a single transaction that was not with the defendant, and the defendant's principal office was in Madhya Pradesh.
¶ 14.4, 14.6In Plusplus, Delhi links were limited to third-party averments that the Court found deliberately vague, while the defendants operated from Mumbai and Dehradun.
¶ 15.6–15.9In Sotkon and Global Music, leave under s.20(b) was not given because the non-resident defendants had not acquiesced, and the Court found the Delhi connection too slender to justify leave.
¶ 10.6–10.11, 12.10Across the batch, the Court's reasoning was that permitting a Delhi suit on such connections would make jurisdiction available in every locality where the product could be accessed, which the Court held would defeat certainty and predictability.
¶ 6.9, 7.1105Holding
The Court held that territorial jurisdiction under s.20 CPC is not made out in the batch, and, even where a part of the cause of action could be said to have arisen in Delhi, the material, integral and essential part lay elsewhere.
¶ 6.15, 7.12, 8.4, 9.8, 10.11, 11.5, 12.11, 13.9–13.10, 14.8The Court declined to entertain the suits on forum non conveniens grounds. In Plusplus, the Court also found no territorial jurisdiction under s.20(c).
¶ 15.10Accordingly, the Court returned all ten plaints under Order VII Rule 10 read with s.151 CPC for presentation before the appropriate court, if so advised. Pending applications stand disposed of, and liberty is granted to the plaintiffs to seek directions under Order VII Rule 10A CPC.
¶ 20–21Original Court PDF
Mold-Tek Packaging LimitedvsIdeal Technoplast Industries Limited & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
