01Facts
The plaintiffs sued for permanent and mandatory injunction, declaration and damages over allegedly defamatory media interviews given by defendant no. 1 concerning matters pending before the NCLT, NCLAT and the Supreme Court.
¶ 2Defendant no. 1 filed his Written Statement on 02.09.2023 but it remained under objections.
¶ 2, 10On 02.04.2024 the Joint Registrar granted a last opportunity, subject to ₹5,000 costs, which was not complied with; on 16.07.2024 the right to file the Written Statement was forfeited.
¶ 10In O.A. 63/2025, the Court on 27.08.2025 allowed the appeal and directed the Written Statement to be taken on record subject to cumulative costs of ₹30,000, of which ₹25,000 was payable to the plaintiffs and ₹5,000 to the DHCLSC, within seven working days.
¶ 3, 12Defendant no. 1 deposited ₹5,000 with the DHCLSC on 03.09.2025 and handed over two cheques of ₹12,500 each (dated 02.09.2025) to the plaintiffs' counsel.
¶ 13The Joint Registrar's order of 13.10.2025 recorded that proof of costs was on record.
¶ 13The cheques were dishonoured on presentation on 07.11.2025.
¶ 4, 14On 23.01.2026 the dishonour was brought to the Joint Registrar's notice and defendant no. 1, through counsel, was directed to pay before the next hearing; no payment followed.
¶ 14, 16On 29.04.2026 defendant no. 1's counsel offered to pay ₹25,000 by fresh cheque that day, but the plaintiffs' counsel declined.
¶ 4, 5 (order ¶¶ 6–8)The Joint Registrar struck off the Written Statement and the Affidavit of Admission/Denial of Documents.
¶ 4, 5 (order ¶¶ 6–8)02Issues
i.1. Whether the failure of defendant no. 1 to ensure encashment of the cheques tendered towards the ₹25,000 costs justified striking off his Written Statement and Affidavit of Admission/Denial of Documents.
¶ 9ii.2. Whether striking off the defence was a proportionate consequence where the default was capable of remedy by further costs and conditions.
¶ 17, 27–2803Law Applied
Order XI Rule 21 CPC, as construed in Babbar Sewing Machine Co. v. Trilok Nath Mahajan (1978) 4 SCC 188, holds that striking out a defence is a highly penal measure to be used only in extreme cases, on obstinacy, contumacy or wilful disregard of a court order, and as a last resort.
¶ 18The Order XI Rule 21 principle is relevant to proportionality, though the provision does not directly govern the case.
¶ 19Uday Shankar Triyar v. Ram Kalewar Prasad Singh (2006) 1 SCC 75 holds that curable procedural defaults should not defeat substantive rights or cause injustice, and that the consequence must be proportionate to the default.
¶ 20–21Manohar Singh v. D.S. Sharma (2010) 1 SCC 53 holds that non-payment of costs under Section 35B CPC does not automatically entail dismissal or striking off of defence, and that the Court may, in exceptional circumstances and subject to further terms, extend time for payment under Section 148 CPC.
¶ 22Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 148
04Reasoning
The Court held that defendant no. 1 could not escape responsibility for the dishonour, as he was aware of it from 23.01.2026 and paid nothing for over three months.
¶ 23The record did not establish that the cheques were issued to defeat the Court's order, as defendant no. 1 had deposited the DHCLSC amount and tendered cheques within the stipulated period, and his counsel offered payment on 29.04.2026.
¶ 15, 24Applying Babbar Sewing Machine, the Court found no obstinacy or contumacy.
¶ 24Applying Uday Shankar Triyar, the Court held that the defect was curable by payment and further costs.
¶ 24, 26Given that the Written Statement had been permitted on record by the 27.08.2025 order, and that the suit involved defamation-related reliefs in which the defendant's defence was material, striking off was disproportionate.
¶ 26–27The impugned order failed to consider the steps taken, the offer to pay, or whether a further-costs remedy was available.
¶ 2705Holding
Striking off the Written Statement and Affidavit of Admission/Denial was disproportionate to the default.
¶ 28The appeal was allowed and the impugned order dated 29.04.2026 was set aside, subject to payment of the outstanding ₹25,000 to the plaintiffs by demand draft or electronic transfer, not cheque, within two weeks, with receipt furnished, and deposit of further costs of ₹10,000 with the DHCLSC within two weeks, with receipt furnished. Upon compliance, the Written Statement dated 02.09.2023 and the Affidavit of Admission/Denial stand restored, and the plaintiffs may file a replication if any. Non-compliance will withdraw the restoration without further reference to the Court. No further opportunity for payment will be granted. The appeal stands disposed of.
¶ 28(ii)–(vi), 29, 30Original Court PDF
Mr. Sahil Virmani & Anr.vsMr. Karan Gambhir & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
