Delhi High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceWills, Inheritance, and Trusts

Section 10 CPC cannot stay suits concerning distinct trusts under separate trust deeds, despite common parties and trustees.

Satish Motiani & Ors.v.T Choithram Foundation & Ors.

Section 10 CPC cannot stay suits concerning distinct trusts under separate trust deeds, despite common parties and trustees.. Satish Motiani & Ors. vs T Choithram Foundation & Ors.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether CS(OS) 609/2021 (concerning TCF) is required to be stayed under Section 10 CPC on account of the earlier-instituted suit RCS/A/1255/2021 at Indore (concerning CCT), i.e., whether the matter in issue is directly and substantially the same in both suits.

The court held

CS(OS) 609/2021 is not required to be stayed under Section 10 CPC, because the matter in issue is not directly and substantially identical to that in RCS/A/1255/2021. Commonality of parties, trustees, documents and reliefs, and the Indore rejection order, do not satisfy the statutory test.

It also directed

The learned Single Judge correctly applied Section 10 CPC and found no error warranting interference.

The appeal was dismissed and the order dated 12.05.2026 in IA No. 14834/2023 in CS(OS) 609/2021 was affirmed; pending applications were disposed of.

01Facts

The dispute concerns the trusteeship of two charitable trusts settled by the late Thakurdas Choithram Pagarani: Choithram Charitable Trust ("CCT"), under a deed dated 29.12.1970 registered in Madhya Pradesh, and T. Choithram Foundation ("TCF"), under a deed dated 24.05.1971 registered in New Delhi.

¶ 1

Both trusts are administered from Indore and are managed by members of the same family.

¶ 1

The Respondents challenged the validity of various trustee appointments in both trusts, alleging lack of notice and invalid meetings.

¶ 2

On 17.11.2021, the Respondents filed RCS/A/1255/2021 at Indore concerning CCT, seeking a declaration that Defendants 2 to 6 were not trustees.

¶ 3

Four days later, on 21.11.2021, they filed CS(OS) 609/2021 in Delhi concerning TCF, seeking similar declarations, injunctions, a challenge to the minutes of 01.02.2019, and rendition of accounts.

¶ 4

On 24.11.2021, the Delhi court recorded an undertaking from Defendants 2 to 6 not to represent themselves as TCF members or hold trust meetings pending the next hearing.

¶ 5

The Supreme Court, in Transfer Petition (C) No. 1228/2022, declined transfer but granted liberty to seek relief under Section 10 CPC.

¶ 6

The Appellants filed IA No. 14834/2023 under Section 10 CPC on 07.08.2023.

¶ 7

On 18.11.2024, the Indore court rejected the plaint in RCS/A/1255/2021 under Order VII Rule 11 CPC as time-barred and non-compliant with Section 26 of the M.P. Public Trusts Act, 1951; an appeal is pending.

¶ 8

The learned Single Judge dismissed the Section 10 application on 12.05.2026, holding that the two suits concerned different trusts under separate deeds and were not substantially identical.

¶ 9

The Appellants appealed under Section 10 of the Delhi High Court Act, 1966 read with Section 151 CPC.

¶ 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether CS(OS) 609/2021 (concerning TCF) is required to be stayed under Section 10 CPC on account of the earlier-instituted suit RCS/A/1255/2021 at Indore (concerning CCT), i.e., whether the matter in issue is directly and substantially the same in both suits.

¶ 14

ii.2. Whether commonality of parties, trustees, documents and reliefs, and the subsequent rejection of the Indore plaint (under challenge), are sufficient to attract Section 10 CPC.

¶ 19, 25, 26

03Law Applied

Section 10 CPC bars the trial of a subsequently instituted suit where the "matter in issue" is "directly and substantially in issue" in a previously instituted suit between the same parties.

¶ 15

National Institute of Mental Health & Neuro Sciences v. C. Parameshwara, (2005) 2 SCC 256, holds that the test is whether a final decision in the earlier suit would operate as res judicata in the later suit, and that Section 10 applies only where the whole subject matter of both suits is identical.

¶ 16

Aspi Jal v. Khushroo Rustom Dadyburjor, (2013) 4 SCC 333, holds that commonality of parties and some issues is insufficient; the relevant question is whether the plaintiff can obtain the same relief in the subsequent suit if the earlier suit is dismissed, and Section 10 does not apply where the entire subject matter is not the same.

¶ 17

The trust deeds, the M.P. Public Trusts Act, 1951 (which governs CCT but not TCF), and the trust-specific nature of trusteeship are determinative of the distinctness of the subject matter.

¶ 21

Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 10Section 151

Delhi High Court Act, 1966 Section 10

04Reasoning

The Court accepted that the parties, the nature of the reliefs (challenges to trusteeship), and some documents (29 common documents) overlap, but held that these similarities do not by themselves attract Section 10.

¶ 19, 22

Applying the Parameshwara and Aspi Jal tests, the Court found that the two proceedings concern two separate trusts, not different claims regarding the same trust.

¶ 20

The trust deeds differ in provisions on the Board's constitution, quorum, meetings, notice and appointment or removal of trustees, and CCT alone is governed by the M.P. Public Trusts Act.

¶ 21

A finding that a person was validly appointed to CCT would not automatically determine the same question for TCF, so a decision in the Indore suit would not operate as res judicata in the Delhi suit.

¶ 23–24

The Court rejected the argument that overlapping findings justify a stay, reasoning that the statutory requirement of identity of the matter in issue cannot be dispensed with merely because some findings may overlap.

¶ 25

The Indore plaint rejection on 18.11.2024 does not alter the position, since it concerned CCT, and the pendency of the challenge to that order does not make the subject matter identical.

¶ 26

05Holding

CS(OS) 609/2021 is not required to be stayed under Section 10 CPC, because the matter in issue is not directly and substantially identical to that in RCS/A/1255/2021. Commonality of parties, trustees, documents and reliefs, and the Indore rejection order, do not satisfy the statutory test.

¶ 27–28

The learned Single Judge correctly applied Section 10 CPC and found no error warranting interference.

¶ 29

The appeal was dismissed and the order dated 12.05.2026 in IA No. 14834/2023 in CS(OS) 609/2021 was affirmed; pending applications were disposed of.

¶ 30
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Satish Motiani & Ors.vsT Choithram Foundation & Ors.

Delhi High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment