01Facts
The respondent (plaintiff) filed a 2018 suit for declaration, mandatory and permanent injunction concerning 10980, East Park Road, Doriwalan, Karol Bagh, New Delhi (the "suit property").
¶ 2–3The respondent relies on a will dated 08.01.1994 executed by Late Sujan Singh in favour of his wife, Late Prakash Kaur, a later will dated 31.05.2002 and a registered sale deed dated 21.06.2007 in her favour. The petitioners (sons of Late Kuldip Singh) rely on a will dated 09.04.1994 executed by Late Sujan Singh in favour of their father and Gurmit Singh. The dispute thus turns on the rival wills.
¶ 4The petitioners' written statement and counter-claim (both dated 04.08.2018) pleaded scientific examination of the disputed signatures against rent deeds. Issues were framed on 01.10.2019. The petitioners' list of witnesses dated 09.10.2019 (serial nos. 5–13) cited DDA records, Transport and Passport Office officials, and an FSL/handwriting expert.
¶ 6, 23Plaintiff's evidence concluded on 24.10.2024. Defendant's evidence commenced on 31.01.2025.
¶ 7, 9, 23On 16.04.2025, the petitioners applied under Order XVI r/w s.151 CPC to: (i) summon the driving licence and passport of Late Kuldip Singh and send them, with the rival wills, DDA records and rent deeds (1973–1981), to the FSL/handwriting expert; (ii) summon SBI Karol Bagh records; and (iii) summon oath commissioner records from Tis Hazari Courts.
¶ 7By order dated 18.09.2026, the Trial Court dismissed prayer (i). Prayers (ii) and (iii) were unopposed.
¶ 7, 21The petitioners challenged the order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 8, 3502Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioners' application for scientific examination of signatures was belated, given it was filed about 2.5 months after defendant's evidence commenced.
¶ 9, 22(i), 23–25ii.2. Whether the opinion of a handwriting expert on the identity of a testator's signature is a "relevant fact" under s.39 BSA.
¶ 13, 22(ii), 26–27iii.3. Whether the petitioners' earlier reliance on the handwriting expert report dated 02.08.2018 bars fresh scientific examination.
¶ 19, 22(iii), 32iv.4. Whether the proposed comparative documents (passport, driving licence, rent deeds) were non-contemporaneous and lacked foundational proof.
¶ 22(iv), 3303Law Applied
The Court applied Order XVI r/w s.151 CPC and Order XXVI Rule 10A CPC, which govern the summoning of documents and the appointment of expert examination.
¶ 21Section 39 BSA (corresponding to s.45 IEA) provides that the opinion of persons skilled in the identity of handwriting is a relevant fact.
¶ 26Rama Avatar Soni v. Mahanta Laxmidhar Das permits sending a disputed will to a handwriting expert at a later stage where this ascertains the truth in the interest of justice.
¶ 27Pazhanathal v. Alamathal holds that suspicious circumstances, including doubtful signatures, must be considered in determining due execution of a will.
¶ 28Rohit Manchanda v. Mohit Manchanda holds that wills must meet the statutory requirements of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 and the BSA, and that expert examination is not ordered merely on a party's request.
¶ 16, 29, 31Sugandhi v. P. Rajkumar holds that courts must take necessary steps to reach the underlying truth.
¶ 31Ajay Kumar Parmar v. State of Rajasthan and O. Bharathan v. K. Sudhakaran hold that courts should not compare disputed signatures without expert assistance and that expert opinion is fallible but not useless.
¶ 14, 34Jyoti v. Anand Kishore and Shashi Kant Dixit v. Renuka Sharma were distinguished on delay and prior expert evidence.
¶ 17, 25, 32Article 227 of the Constitution provided the basis for interference.
¶ 35Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 Section 39Section 67Section 68
Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 63
04Reasoning
The first ground was held unsustainable. The petitioners had pleaded scientific examination in their 2018 pleadings and listed the FSL expert in 2019. They moved the application within about 2.5 months of defendant's evidence opening, so it was not belated. Jyoti (fag-end application after evidence closed and reopened) and Shashi Kant Dixit (prior notice but failure to move at the proper stage) were distinguished.
¶ 23–25On the second ground, the Trial Court was held to have erred. Section 39 BSA expressly makes expert opinion on the identity of handwriting a relevant fact. Where both parties allege forgery of the testator's signature, excluding expert opinion closed the door on the scientific examination needed to test genuineness.
¶ 26–28On the third ground, the 2018 report was not a bar. Its author had not been examined, and it did not address the 08.01.1994 will or the DDA record of 01.08.1994. The Shashi Kant Dixit position did not apply, as no expert had been examined there.
¶ 32On the fourth ground, Late Kuldip Singh's passport and driving licence are official records bearing genuine signatures, and the 1973–1981 rent deeds are already on record. Whether signatures vary over time is a technical question for the expert. The objection was therefore unfounded, and the application itself sought to supply the foundational proof.
¶ 33, 35The examination was limited to genuineness of signatures. Due execution and attestation of the wills under s.63 ISA and ss.67–68 BSA, and the validity of the DDA mutation, remain to be proved on evidence.
¶ 30, 34Relying on Ajay Kumar Parmar, the Court directed that the expert, rather than the Court itself, should undertake the comparison. The Trial Court's fourfold reasoning was found unsustainable and warranted interference under Article 227.
¶ 34–3505Holding
The application was held timely, expert opinion on handwriting identity is a relevant fact under s.39 BSA, the 2018 report does not bar fresh examination, and the comparative documents are adequate. The impugned order dated 18.09.2026 was held unsustainable insofar as it rejected prayer (i).
¶ 35The impugned order is set aside to that extent and prayer (i) is allowed. The Trial Court is directed to issue necessary directions to the handwriting expert/FSL to obtain the documents from the Court for comparison of the signatures of Late Sujan Singh and Late Kuldip Singh, and to submit its report preferably within three months. The Trial Court is to proceed with the suit expeditiously thereafter. The Court has not addressed the merits of the rival wills, and the petition is disposed of accordingly.
¶ 36–38Original Court PDF
Harpreet Singh & Anr.vsSarabjit Kaur
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
