01Facts
The Plaintiff, Bharat Lal, sued for a mandatory injunction directing removal of the Defendants' belongings and handover of Shop No. 48, Than Singh Nagar, Anand Parbat, New Delhi (the "suit property"), along with a permanent injunction and mesne profits at Rs. 4,000 per month.
¶ 2, 16The Plaintiff claimed that the property was licensed by Ramjas Foundation to Smt. Kundania Devi, passed to his brother Late Shri Ram Singh, was mutated in Ram Singh's name by MCD letter dated 19.09.2003, and devolved on the Plaintiff as sole Class II heir after Ram Singh died intestate on 05.12.2007.
¶ 3, 5–6, 85–86The Plaintiff pleaded that Late Babu Lal, the Defendants' predecessor, was merely permitted by Ram Singh to park a rehri outside and store goods inside at night, a gratuitous and revocable licence that ended on Babu Lal's death on 14.11.2007.
¶ 7–10The Defendants broke the locks, retained the keys and goods, and refused to vacate despite a legal notice dated 01.03.2008.
¶ 11–14The Defendants pleaded that the property was occupied by Babu Lal in his own right for over 50 years, that Babu Lal paid licence fees through Ram Singh to Ramjas Foundation, and that the Defendants had acquired title by adverse possession. They also objected to locus standi, valuation, and the Slum Areas Act.
¶ 17–31The Trial Court (Civil Judge, 31.01.2013) dismissed the suit on three grounds: the Plaintiff lacked locus standi, the relief was under-valued (possession sought under the guise of mandatory injunction), and the suit was not maintainable without Slum Act permission.
The Plaintiff admitted in cross-examination that the property belonged to Ramjas Foundation, that no sale deed or mutation existed, and that he held no document of title. The Defendants led no evidence.
¶ 36–42The First Appellate Court (RCA 328/2016, 19.05.2017) affirmed, relying on Anathula Sudhakar to hold that the Plaintiff should have sought a declaration of title and possession.
¶ 44–47During the appeal, Ramjas Foundation executed a licence deed in the Plaintiff's favour dated 24.12.2019, which was taken on record.
¶ 62–63Respondent No. 3 died in 2021, Respondent No. 1 died in 2024 (appeal abated against him), and Respondent No. 2 was proceeded ex parte. A police report recorded that the premises were locked, dilapidated, and abandoned.
¶ 64–6902Issues
i.1. Whether prior permission of the Competent Authority under Section 19(1) of the Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956 was required for instituting a suit for possession against unauthorised occupants of the suit property.
¶ 70 (SQ 3.1), 72–83ii.2. Whether the Plaintiff, who has not established absolute title, is entitled to relief on the basis of a better possessory title where the Defendants have led no evidence of title.
¶ 70 (SQ 3.2), 84–103iii.3. Whether a suit for possession may be dismissed for want of locus standi solely because the Plaintiff has no proven right, title or interest, where the Defendant also cannot prove title.
¶ 70 (SQ 3.3), 84–103iv.4. Whether the Defendants acquired ownership of the suit property by adverse possession.
¶ 104–115v.5. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to mesne profits.
¶ 11603Law Applied
Section 19(1) of the Slum Areas Act, 1956 bars eviction proceedings against a "tenant" in a slum area without the Competent Authority's prior permission.
¶ 76Following the Full Bench in Punnu Ram v. Chiranji Lal Gupta, AIR 1982 Delhi 431, "tenant" means a tenant-in-law, not a mere occupier, trespasser, or licensee, a view reaffirmed in Giri Raj (RSA 151/2012) and Satender Jain (RSA 139/2019).
¶ 77–79Whether a property lies in a slum area turns on a notification under the Act, not common parlance.
¶ 74Under Nair Service Society v. K.C. Alexander, AIR 1968 SC 1165, prior possession gives good title against all but the true owner.
¶ 99Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy, (2008) 4 SCC 594 governs when an injunction suit may decide title.
¶ 100Under Poona Ram v. Moti Ram, (2019) 11 SCC 309, a plaintiff must prove a better title than the defendant.
¶ 101Where neither party proves absolute title, the court must decide which party has the better possessory title and may not non-suit the plaintiff merely for lack of a sale deed.
¶ 102On adverse possession, S.M. Karim v. Mst. Bibi Sakina, AIR 1964 SC 1254, and Karnataka Board of Wakf v. Government of India, (2004) 10 SCC 779 require pleading and proof of the commencement and hostile character of possession.
¶ 105–106Under Bhag Singh v. Basant Kaur, 2026 INSC 983, permissive possession does not become adverse by mere lapse of time.
¶ 107–108Under Maria Margarida Sequeira Fernandes v. Erasmo Jack de Sequeira, (2012) 5 SCC 370, gratuitous occupation, however long, confers no title.
¶ 110–111Under Order XX Rule 12 CPC, mesne profits require evidence.
¶ 116Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956 Section 19
04Reasoning
The property's slum status could not rest on the Plaintiff's admission in cross-examination. The Court relied on the Government Notification dated 02.04.1987, of which judicial notice was taken, to conclude that the property is not in a slum area.
¶ 74–75Even if the property were in a slum area, the Defendants pleaded no tenancy and led no evidence of a tenancy recognised in law. Their occupation, even if prolonged, did not attract Section 19(1). The concurrent findings on Issue 3 were therefore set aside.
¶ 81–83The Court treated the dispute as one of possessory rights rather than ownership.
¶ 96The Mutation Letter and House Tax Receipts, though not documents of title, showed that Ram Singh dealt with the property as owner. Read with the Plaintiff's unrebutted testimony, these established a better possessory title than the Defendants', who produced no document.
¶ 88, 92, 95The 2019 licence deed from the admitted owner, Ramjas Foundation, recognised the Plaintiff as licensee and negated any possessory right in Babu Lal or his heirs.
¶ 89The Defendants' own pleading that Babu Lal paid licence fees through Ram Singh was treated as acknowledging Ram Singh's superior position.
¶ 94, 109The Trial and First Appellate Courts erred in non-suiting the Plaintiff for lack of a sale deed while leaving a title-less occupant in possession.
¶ 102–103The Court did not expressly reconcile the Plaintiff's cross-examination admissions (no mutation, no sale deed, no title document) with its finding of better possessory title, though it relied on the unrebutted testimony and the subsequent licence deed.
¶ 37The adverse possession plea failed for want of pleading and proof of the commencement and hostile character of possession. Possession was permissive from inception, and the Defendants' admission of paying licence fees through Ram Singh was self-contradictory.
¶ 109–113No evidence was led on the rate or benefit derived from use and occupation, so the mesne profits claim failed under Order XX Rule 12 CPC.
¶ 11605Holding
Section 19(1) of the Slum Areas Act does not bar the suit, since the property is not shown to be in a notified slum area and the Defendants are not tenants-in-law.
¶ 83The Plaintiff, having established a better possessory title against title-less occupants, is entitled to relief.
¶ 102–103The suit cannot be dismissed for want of locus standi on that basis.
¶ 95–103The adverse possession plea fails.
¶ 114No mesne profits are payable.
¶ 116The Regular Second Appeal is allowed, and the judgments of the Civil Judge dated 31.01.2013 and the First Appellate Court dated 19.05.2017 are set aside. The Mandatory Injunction is decreed: the Defendants' belongings are to be removed and possession of the suit property handed over to the Plaintiff. The Permanent Injunction is decreed, restraining the Defendants, their legal representatives, assigns, and persons claiming through them from creating third-party rights in the suit property.
¶ 117–118The claim for mesne profits stands dismissed.
¶ 118Original Court PDF
Bharat LalvsSurender & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
