01Facts
A notification dated 24 June 2026 under Section 3A of the National Highways Act, 1956 ("NHAI Act") acquired land in District Outer North, Delhi, for the newly proposed extension of the Delhi–Amritsar–Katra Expressway
¶ 4–5The Petitioner's lands (Serial Nos. 433, 434 and 448, Village Rani Khera) were described as "Private, Agriculture"
¶ 6The Petitioner filed objections under Section 3C, which the Competent Authority (Land Acquisition), District Outer North ("CALA") disposed of by order dated 6 October 2026
¶ 7The Petitioner's principal objection was that the land is agricultural, whereas a Department of Urban Development notification dated 16 May 2017 under Section 507 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957, declared Village Rani Khera urban
¶ 9–10The Petitioner contended that the agricultural description would depress compensation below the land's current market value
¶ 11NHAI argued that compensation is to be determined under Section 3G, not at this stage, and that disputes over quantum may be referred to arbitration
¶ 13–14NHAI and CALA stated that they rely on revenue records
¶ 20–2102Issues
i.1. Whether the Petitioner's objection that the land is wrongly described as agricultural, despite the 2017 Section 507 urbanisation notification, can be adjudicated at the Section 3C stage or otherwise modifies the Section 3A notification.
¶ 8–9, 17–18, 23ii.2. Whether the Competent Authority and the Arbitrator under Section 3G have jurisdiction to determine whether the land should be classified as agricultural or urban for the purpose of compensation, and whether NHAI may object to that jurisdiction.
¶ 22–23, 27–30iii.3. Whether the High Court should adjudicate the quantum of compensation in writ jurisdiction or leave it to the statutory mechanism.
¶ 13–14, 25–26, 3803Law Applied
Section 3A and Section 3C of the NHAI Act confine objections to acquisition to the proposed use of the land, and the Section 3A description is an initial description only.
¶ 17, 31Section 3G of the NHAI Act provides that the Competent Authority determines compensation (s. 3G(1)), any dispute is referred to an arbitrator appointed by the Central Government (s. 3G(5)), the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 applies (s. 3G(6)), and the market value on the date of the Section 3A notification and other statutory factors govern compensation (s. 3G(7)).
¶ 24–25Section 507 of the DMC Act and its 16 May 2017 notification ceased rural status for specified villages including Rani Khera and deemed them urban areas.
¶ 19Mohinder Singh (Dead) through LRs v. Narain Singh (2023 SCC OnLine SC 535), as quoted, holds that once a Section 507(a) notification issues, the area ceases to be rural and forms part of urban areas.
¶ 22Anubhav Chand Kathuria v. Union of India (W.P.(C) 5822/2018, order dated 19 Feb. 2019) holds that the Competent Authority and Arbitrator have identical powers under Section 3G, including correcting factual and classification errors, and that NHAI cannot object to such jurisdiction.
¶ 27–30Manju Arora (W.P.(C) 6117/2018, order dated 30 May 2018; W.P.(C) 1179/2019, order dated 14 Aug. 2020) preserves the landowner's right to contend for commercial rather than agricultural compensation in arbitration.
¶ 28–29The alternative-remedy principle holds that writ courts generally decline to interfere where an efficacious statutory remedy exists.
¶ 26Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 Section 2Section 502Section 507Section 7Section 12
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 12Section 34Section 7
04Reasoning
The Section 3A notification could not be modified at this stage, because Section 3C objections are limited to use and the acquisition process is expedited.
¶ 17, 23The classification question must nonetheless be addressed in compensation proceedings. Because the 2017 Section 507 notification declares Rani Khera urban, the description of the land as agricultural has a major bearing on compensation, which the Court treated as the central concern.
¶ 15, 19Relying on Anubhav Chand Kathuria, the Section 3G authorities have the power to decide whether the land is agricultural or urban, and NHAI had conceded this jurisdiction in earlier matters.
¶ 22–23, 30The Court rejected NHAI's position that the revenue record is determinative, reasoning that the Section 3A description is only the initial description and does not preclude examination of its correctness.
¶ 31Urban land may fetch higher returns and classification materially affects market value.
¶ 34Because the statutory mechanism under Section 3G provides an efficacious remedy, and the Court expressed no view on merits, it declined to determine quantum in writ jurisdiction.
¶ 25–26, 38The CALA's 6 October 2026 order, which limited consideration to the revenue records and left the description question to later examination, was read as requiring a full examination of subsequent urbanisation notifications.
¶ 33–3405Holding
The Section 3A description is not conclusive and does not preclude the Competent Authority or Arbitrator from examining whether the land is agricultural or urban when determining compensation, and NHAI cannot object to that jurisdiction.
¶ 30–32, 36The petition was disposed of with the direction that CALA, before determining compensation for the subject land, must examine and decide whether the land's description is correct, in light of the 16 May 2017 Section 507 notification and any subsequent notifications, and determine compensation accordingly.
¶ 35The Arbitrator is similarly empowered, and NHAI may not object at that stage.
¶ 36All remedies available against the orders of the Competent Authority or Arbitrator are left open, the Court expressly declined to opine on the merits, and pending applications were disposed of.
¶ 37–39Original Court PDF
Arun DabasvsUnion Of India And Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
