Delhi High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Delhi HC Upholds Eviction Of Connaught Place Tenants For Landlord's Golf Store, Says Co-Owner's Letter Didn't Oppose It

Ashok Goyalv.Ajay Gupta & Ors.

Delhi HC Upholds Eviction Of Connaught Place Tenants For Landlord's Golf Store, Says Co-Owner's Letter Didn't Oppose It. Ashok Goyal vs Ajay Gupta & Ors.. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Letter of Attornment dated 05.04.2019 issued by co-owner Anjali Vaid, and the pendency of the Partition Suit, displaced the presumption of consent of co-owners and rendered the Eviction Petition non-maintainable.

The court held

No triable issue arises on maintainability, non-disclosure, alternative accommodation, bona fide requirement or the RC ARC 10/2022 stand. No jurisdictional error, material irregularity, perversity or error apparent on the record was found in the Impugned Order dated 24.03.2026 or the Review Order dated 11.07.2026.

It also directed

Both Revision Petitions (RC.REV. 357/2026 and RC.REV. 361/2026) are dismissed, and both orders are upheld. Pending applications stand disposed of, with no order as to costs.

01Facts

The Tenanted Premises (E-18, Connaught Place, Ground and Mezzanine floors) were let to M/s Om Prakash Surendra Kumar, a partnership firm, decades ago.

After the original partners' demise, the Tenants, Ashok Goyal (son of Surendra Kumar Goyal) and Rahul and Gaurav Goyal (sons of Vinod Kumar Goyal), occupied the premises and run separate businesses from them.

¶ 6–7

The Landlords, Ajay and Sanjay Gupta, claim title through a 1926 perpetual lease, a 1964 partition decree, and the Will of their father Y.N. Gupta dated 28.01.2016.

¶ 8

A sister, Anjali Vaid, has filed CS(OS) 231/2019 seeking partition and challenging the Will, and in a letter dated 05.04.2019 claimed a one-fifth share and asked the Tenants not to alter the premises' nature, possession or title without her consent.

¶ 9, 26

In September 2021 the Landlords filed an eviction petition under s.14(1)(e) DRC Act for Respondent No. 1's bona fide requirement to set up a golf retail superstore, pursuant to an offer to be formalised by 30.09.2021.

¶ 10–11

The petition disclosed the Landlords' other Connaught Place properties (E-15 to E-48) and why each was unavailable or unsuitable.

¶ 12–15

Leave to defend (LTD) was initially rejected, but this Court set aside that order by consent and remanded the matter.

¶ 16–19

On 24.03.2026 the ARC dismissed both LTD applications and passed an eviction order.

¶ 21

The Review Application under s.25-B(9) was dismissed on 11.07.2026.

¶ 22–23

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Letter of Attornment dated 05.04.2019 issued by co-owner Anjali Vaid, and the pendency of the Partition Suit, displaced the presumption of consent of co-owners and rendered the Eviction Petition non-maintainable.

¶ 65–75

ii.2. Whether non-disclosure of CS(OS) 231/2019 and CS No. 124/2015 disclosed a triable issue warranting leave to defend.

¶ 76–82

iii.3. Whether the Landlords had reasonably suitable alternative accommodation, particularly E-16, Connaught Place, available to them.

¶ 83–96

iv.4. Whether the bona fide requirement pleaded by Respondent No. 1 was genuine, given the expiry of the offer and the later-dated medical record.

¶ 97–103

v.5. Whether the Landlords' stand in RC ARC 10/2022 (Order dated 05.07.2024) was inconsistent with the present claim, and whether the ARC's failure to advert to that order vitiated the Impugned Order.

¶ 104–114

vi.6. Whether the Review Order dated 11.07.2026 warrants interference.

¶ 115–117

03Law Applied

The Court applied s.14(1)(e) DRC Act, which governs eviction for bona fide requirement, and s.25-B, which governs LTD applications, and noted that the High Court's revisional power under the proviso to s.25-B(8) is supervisory, not appellate.

¶ 58–63

Under India Umbrella Manufacturing Co. v. Bhagabandei Agarwalla (2004) 3 SCC 178, one co-owner may sue for eviction as agent of the others, and their consent is presumed unless shown to be disagreeing.

¶ 67–68

A landlord need only show a better title than the tenant, not absolute ownership, as stated in Bharat Bhushan v. Arti Teckchandani (2008) 153 DLT 247.

¶ 71, 75

The burden on alternative accommodation rests on the tenant, who must plead and prove that the premises were vacant, available and suitable, as laid down in Lalta Prasad Gupta v. Sita Ram (2017 SCC OnLine Del 13026).

¶ 84

A bona fide need is presumed under Baldev Singh Bajwa v. Monish Saini (2005) 12 SCC 778, and the landlord need not disclose the precise nature of the proposed business, as stated in Raj Kumar Khaitan v. Bibi Zubaid Khatun (AIR 1995 SC 576).

¶ 97

The omission to consider a plea vitiates an LTD order only if the plea, taken at its highest, would disentitle the landlord from eviction.

¶ 109

Ved Prakash v. Gay Dry Cleaners (2026 SCC OnLine Del 1528) and Renu Mehta v. Pritam Singh (2026:DHC:6503) were relied on by the Tenants and distinguished.

¶ 96, 100, 120

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

delhi rent control act, 1958 Section 14Section 19

04Reasoning

The Letter of Attornment does not displace the presumption of consent. It asserts a one-fifth share, demands rent, and bars alteration of the premises without the sender's consent, but it contains no express objection to eviction. It was also addressed to the occupants, not the co-owners, and was issued more than two years before the petition.

¶ 70, 73

Even if the Will were ignored, the Landlords, as Class-I heirs, would remain co-owners entitled to sue, and co-owners need not all be joined. The pending partition suit does not displace the Landlords' title for eviction purposes, and entitlement is fixed on the date of institution under India Umbrella.

¶ 74, 49, 78–79

Non-disclosure of the suits was no ground for LTD. The Partition Suit and Letter were already before the ARC, the modification suit was raised only in written submissions, and the Tenants showed no concealed vacant suitable accommodation or prejudice.

¶ 80–82

On alternative accommodation, the Tenants did not show that E-15, E-17, E-19, E-20, E-21 or E-22 to E-27 and E-44 to E-48 were vacant and available. The Landlords had disclosed all of them and explained them. E-40 and E-41 were rejected as unsuitable, since the choice of premises is for the landlord.

¶ 86–89

E-16 was let to Westwind Retails in November 2020, before the petition was filed, and was not vacant or available when the present requirement arose. The subsequent letting was explained by the legal heirs' accounting under the partition suit, and the s.19 plea was raised for the first time in written submissions and does not affect availability.

¶ 90–95, 101

On bona fide requirement, the expiry of the offer did not extinguish the underlying requirement to run a business. The medical record, though later-dated, was pleaded and supported by affidavit at the time of filing.

¶ 98–99

Ved Prakash was distinguished because it arose from a post-trial revision in which the landlord had concealed properties and failed to explain their disposal.

¶ 100

The ARC's failure to advert to the 05.07.2024 order in RC ARC 10/2022 is immaterial. That order addressed a different requirement, Respondent No. 2's, and held that jointly owned properties were unavailable to him. Holding that E-18 was not available to him is consistent with the present claim, since E-18 is occupied by the Tenants. The doctrine of approbation and reprobation does not apply.

¶ 110–113

The Review Order merely reiterated the objections and sought re-appreciation, which is outside s.25-B(9) read with Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC.

¶ 116–117

05Holding

No triable issue arises on maintainability, non-disclosure, alternative accommodation, bona fide requirement or the RC ARC 10/2022 stand. No jurisdictional error, material irregularity, perversity or error apparent on the record was found in the Impugned Order dated 24.03.2026 or the Review Order dated 11.07.2026.

¶ 119–122

Both Revision Petitions (RC.REV. 357/2026 and RC.REV. 361/2026) are dismissed, and both orders are upheld. Pending applications stand disposed of, with no order as to costs.

¶ 123–125
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Ashok GoyalvsAjay Gupta & Ors.

Delhi High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment