01Facts
Plaintiffs 1 to 6 each hold a 1/8th share in 8 Rajpur Road, Civil Lines, Delhi, acquired by separate sale deeds, giving them 6/8ths of the property. Defendants 1 and 2 hold the remaining 2/8ths
¶ 1Defendant 2 agreed to sell his 1/8th share to Defendant 3 by agreement dated 03.08.2016, but did not execute the sale deed. Defendant 3 sued for specific performance in CS (OS) 237/2020, which is pending
¶ 2In CS (OS) 3369/2015, Defendant 1 claimed exclusive possession of the ground and first floors on the North-East side, along with the front and side lawns, driveway, garage and store rooms, shown in red in the site plan
¶ 3An ex parte status quo order dated 18.11.2015, clarified on 29.02.2016, governs that red-marked portion
¶ 4Plaintiffs say the rest of the property is in their possession and the portion they occupy (marked green) is dilapidated and needs repair. They seek leave to repair, whitewash and develop it
¶ 6, 8Defendant 1's legal representatives oppose the application. They rely on a registered partition agreement dated 15.06.1986, under which Defendant 1 was allotted the North-East block, and argue that partition has not been effected in fact, so Defendant 1 holds a share in every inch of the property
¶ 9–1002Issues
i.1. Whether, pending partition of a jointly owned property, co-owners in possession of a portion may be permitted to carry out repairs and whitewashing of the property, despite objection from another co-owner who claims exclusive possession of a separate portion.
¶ 10–12ii.2. Whether the plaintiffs may be permitted to redevelop the property at the interim stage.
¶ 1203Law Applied
The application is brought under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
¶ 1A dilapidated structure that endangers human life requires proper maintenance, and "even if the suit has not been partitioned, someone must make it habitable"
¶ 11A decree of permanent injunction in CS (OS) 3369/2015, dated 03.11.2026, protects Defendant 1's possession of the red-marked portion, so the plaintiffs must not encroach on it
¶ 12Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The court accepted that the entire property, including the portion in plaintiffs' possession, is in highly dilapidated condition and dangerous to life. It found that the property required maintenance regardless of the unresolved partition
¶ 11On that basis, it permitted repairs to the portion under the plaintiffs' possession and whitewashing of the entire property. It did not accept Defendant 1's contention that partition-in-fact required the plaintiffs to halt all work. It withheld permission to redevelop, which it treated as a materially different step affecting title and possession that should await the suit
¶ 12To guard against prejudice, the court required photographs of the whole property before work began, placed on the judicial file and served on all defendants, and cautioned the plaintiffs against encroaching on Defendant 1's protected portion
¶ 1205Holding
Co-owners in possession may carry out repairs to the portion they occupy and whitewash the entire property, but may not redevelop it at this stage
¶ 12–13The court allowed I.A. 2073/2026. Directions: (i) photographs of the entire property to be taken before repairs begin and placed on the judicial file, with copies to all defendants; (ii) plaintiffs must not encroach on the portion in possession of Defendant 1 or his LRs, which is protected by the permanent injunction decree in CS (OS) 3369/2015
¶ 12The matter is listed before the Joint Registrar on 18.01.2027 for recording of evidence
¶ 14Original Court PDF
M/S Apple Build Homes Llp & Ors.vsShri Kailash Nath Khanna & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
