01Facts
The Plaintiff/Appellant, Smt. Radha Aggarwal, claimed ownership of the suit property (MCD No. 2158, Ward No. II, Chah Indara, Delhi) and sued for possession and mesne profits at Rs. 5,000 per month, alleging the Defendant, Mohalla Samiti (Regd.), was a licensee whose licence was terminated by a legal notice dated 18.08.2008.
¶ 2, 3, 7Her title chain ran from Smt. Bimla Devi (Partition Deed, 06.07.1962) through GPA holder Sunil Mohan to Dinesh Kumar (Sale Deed, 03.03.2000), then through GPA to Anoop Kumar Aggarwal and by Sale Deed dated 12.06.2008 to the Plaintiff.
¶ 4, 6, 47–49The 2000 Sale Deed described the property as occupied by "unauthorised occupants" for several years.
¶ 31, 48The Defendant pleaded that it had been in possession since 1957, that it paid no rent, that its possession was open and hostile to the true owner, and that the property lies in a notified slum area, so suit was barred under Section 19 of the Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956.
¶ 9–12The Survey Reports (1956–1971) recorded the Defendant as rent-free, save for one 1970–71 entry of Rs. 21/-.
¶ 30, 56The trial court (ADJ) dismissed the suit, holding the Defendant had acquired title by adverse possession and that the Slum Act barred the suit.
¶ 28–35The Plaintiff appealed under Section 96 CPC.
¶ 1, 36–4102Issues
i.1. Whether the Plaintiff proved her title to the suit property through a valid chain of registered documents.
¶ 47–54ii.2. Whether the Defendant acquired ownership by adverse possession.
¶ 16 (Issue 3) · ¶ 58–64iii.3. Whether the Defendant's occupation was that of a "tenant" such that Section 19 of the Slum Areas Act bars the suit without the Competent Authority's permission.
¶ 16 (Issue 2) · ¶ 73–81iv.4. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to a decree for possession.
¶ 16 (Issue 4) · ¶ 70–72, 82v.5. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to mesne profits.
¶ 16 (Issue 5) · ¶ 8303Law Applied
Section 27 of the Limitation Act, 1963 (extinguishment of title on expiry of the limitation period for possession suits).
¶ 52Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963 (12 years from when the defendant's possession becomes adverse).
¶ 70Ravinder Kaur Grewal v. Manjit Kaur, (2019) 8 SCC 729, requiring possession that is nec vi, nec clam, nec precario, open, continuous, hostile and with animus possidendi for 12 years.
¶ 61Narasamma v. A. Krishnappa, AIR 2020 SC 4178, holding that a claimant under an independent title cannot simultaneously claim adverse possession from the same date and must plead and prove when hostility began.
¶ 62Bhag Singh (D) v. Basant Kaur (D), 2026 INSC 983, holding that possession of permissive origin does not become adverse by mere lapse of time without clear evidence of hostility, and that failure to plead the commencement of hostile possession is fatal.
¶ 63Section 19(1) of the Slum Areas Act, which bars eviction proceedings against a "tenant" without the Competent Authority's permission.
¶ 75–77Punnu Ram v. Chiranji Lal Gupta, AIR 1982 Delhi 431 (Full Bench), holding that "tenant" means tenant-in-law and that a mere occupier, trespasser or licensee is not protected.
¶ 75–77Giri Raj v. Deepak Gupta, RSA 151/2012 (Del HC, 12.09.2013) and Satender Jain v. Satya Narain Sanjiv Gupta HUF, RSA 139/2019 (Del HC, 09.09.2021), following Punnu Ram.
¶ 79–80Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 96
Slum Areas (Improvement and Clearance) Act, 1956 Section 19Section 2
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 27Section 65
04Reasoning
The 2000 Sale Deed was unchallenged in its operative effect, and the Defendant's admission of the original ownership of Bimla Devi and Sunil Mohan, coupled with the registered documents, established the Plaintiff's title.
¶ 51, 54The Defendant's own pleaded case, that it occupied from 1957 without paying rent, and the Survey Reports, which record no rent, showed occupation "without any right or title".
¶ 55–58The single Rs. 21/- entry in the 1970–71 report did not establish a tenancy, and no induction as tenant was pleaded.
¶ 57On adverse possession, the Defendant's occupation, which was of unauthorised and permissive origin, was never shown to have become hostile at any identified date, as required by Narasamma and Bhag Singh; mere length of possession was insufficient.
¶ 60–64The Defendant's reliance on the 1957–2001 litigation was rejected, as the MCD's statement and the disposal of Suit No. 118/2001 did not benefit an unauthorised occupant.
¶ 65–67The Plaintiff's inconsistent case on the licence did not defeat her title, since she was a subsequent purchaser and the Defendant admitted it was not a tenant.
¶ 68–69Because the Defendant was an unauthorised occupant and not a "tenant", the Section 19 bar did not apply and the suit was maintainable.
¶ 76, 78, 81The Defendant's pending challenge to the title documents was dismissed on 26.09.2018 and remained under appeal, but this did not disturb the title findings.
¶ 38, 53As to mesne profits, the Plaintiff led no evidence on the claimed Rs. 5,000 per month despite Issue 5, so the dismissal of that relief was upheld.
¶ 8305Holding
The Plaintiff is the registered owner and the Defendant is an unauthorised occupant with no right, title or adverse possession, so the suit is maintainable and not barred by Section 19 of the Slum Areas Act, since that bar protects only tenants-in-law.
¶ 72, 76, 81The impugned judgment dated 26.08.2023 is set aside insofar as it dismissed the suit for possession, and a decree for possession is granted in the Plaintiff's favour.
¶ 82The dismissal of the claim for mesne profits is upheld for want of evidence.
¶ 83The appeal is partly allowed (possession) and dismissed (mesne profits), and pending applications are disposed of.
¶ 84–85Original Court PDF
Smt. Radha AggarwalvsMohalla Samiti (Regd.)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
