Delhi High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceContract Law

Even pre-trial, amendment setting up a materially different factual case on consideration is impermissible under Order VI Rule 17.

Karan Kapoorv.Madhuri Kumar And Ors

Even pre-trial, amendment setting up a materially different factual case on consideration is impermissible under Order VI Rule 17.. Karan Kapoor vs Madhuri Kumar And Ors. Delhi High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the proposed amendments to the plaint, taken as a whole, merely particularise the original case or introduce a materially different factual foundation and new case, such that they must be disallowed under Order VI Rule 17 CPC.

The court held

The Division Bench held that the proposed amendments, read together, introduce a materially different factual case regarding consideration, payment and adjustment, and therefore cannot be permitted despite the pre-trial stage.

It also directed

No ground warranted interference with the impugned order.

The appeal is dismissed, the order dated 22.01.2024 in I.A. No. 11430/2021 is affirmed, there is no order as to costs, and pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

01Facts

The Appellant (Plaintiff) instituted CS(OS) 397/2019 seeking specific performance of three Agreements to Sell dated 22.04.2017 (ATS-I), 25.05.2017 (ATS-II) and 30.12.2017 (ATS-III) in respect of B-228, Greater Kailash-I, New Delhi ("Suit Property-I").

¶ 2

Respondent No. 1 is the owner; Respondent No. 2, her son and holder of a general power of attorney, and Respondent No. 3, allegedly associated with him, acted in the transaction.

¶ 2

The Appellant alleges he was a tenant under leases dated 07.08.2011 and 07.08.2013 and that the property was offered for sale on expiry of the lease.

¶ 3

ATS-I fixed consideration at Rs. 3,60,00,000/-. The Appellant agreed to transfer Suit Property-II (1 bigha 10 biswas at Gobindgarh, Punjab) as part consideration, documented in ATS-II.

¶ 3

ATS-III reduced consideration due to difficulty in transferring a portion of Suit Property-I.

¶ 3

During pendency, the Appellant filed I.A. No. 11430/2021 under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend paragraphs 2, 4, 5, 6, 9, 13, 14, 15, 21 and 33 and the prayer clause.

¶ 4

The proposed amendments concern alleged cash payments of Rs. 60,00,000/-, valuation and adjustment of Suit Property-II (Rs. 1,50,00,000/-), computation of balance consideration, and the roles of Respondents 2 and 3.

¶ 4

The learned Single Judge dismissed the application on 22.01.2024, holding that the core amendments were not part of the foundational pleadings and altered the original cause of action, while the amendments to paragraphs 2 and 4 were clarificatory.

¶ 5

The Appellant challenged this order under Section 10 of the Delhi High Court Act, 1966.

¶ 1

The Respondents contended the amendments introduced a new factual case aimed at overcoming difficulties in connected possession and rent proceedings.

¶ 7

02Issues

i.1. Whether the proposed amendments to the plaint, taken as a whole, merely particularise the original case or introduce a materially different factual foundation and new case, such that they must be disallowed under Order VI Rule 17 CPC.

¶ 12 · ¶ 20

ii.2. Whether the pre-trial stage of the suit compels a liberal grant of the amendment notwithstanding that the amendments alter the factual account of consideration.

¶ 12

iii.3. Whether the proposed amendments to paragraphs 2 and 4 (clarificatory in nature) can be allowed independently of the remaining amendments.

¶ 13

03Law Applied

Order VI Rule 17 CPC permits amendments liberally where necessary for determining the real controversy without causing injustice, but amendments are refused where they change the nature of the suit, introduce a fundamentally different case, are mala fide, or cause incurable prejudice.

¶ 9

Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Sanjeev Builders Pvt. Ltd., (2022) 16 SCC 1 holds that amendments must be refused where they set up "an entirely new case, foreign to the case set up in the plaint," although amendments merely particularising facts already pleaded are ordinarily allowed, and pre-trial amendments should be approached liberally.

¶ 10 · ¶ 71.10, 71.11

Ganesh Prasad v. Rajeshwar Prasad, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 256 reiterates the twin test from North Eastern Railway Administration v. Bhagwan Das, (2008) 8 SCC 511, namely no injustice and necessity for determining the real controversy, and holds that amendments must not alter or substitute a new cause of action.

¶ 11 · ¶ 37 of Ganesh Prasad as quoted

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Delhi High Court Act, 1966 Section 10

04Reasoning

The stage of proceedings, though favouring liberality, is not determinative.

¶ 12

Paragraphs 2 and 4 were explanatory and, viewed alone, introduced no new cause of action, but their significance derived from the larger revised account of payments and consideration, so they could not be severed in isolation.

¶ 13

The amendment to paragraph 5 introduced a specific case of cash payments aggregating Rs. 60,00,000/- over an estimated period (07.07.2014 to 22.04.2017), within the Appellant's personal knowledge but absent from the original plaint. This was not mere quantification of a pleaded amount.

¶ 14

The amendment to paragraph 6 relied on the receipt dated 22.04.2017 and emails to assert that the alleged Rs. 60,00,000/- was adjusted against ATS-I, though ATS-I records no such adjustment, and the documents were not originally filed or pleaded.

¶ 15

The amendment to paragraph 9 introduced a new valuation of Suit Property-II at Rs. 1,50,00,000/-. Consideration under ATS-I (Rs. 3,60,00,000/-) was replaced by Rs. 4,27,00,000/-, leaving an unexplained difference of Rs. 67,00,000/-. The reduction explanation also shifted from the inability to transfer a portion of Suit Property-I (original para. 12) to the valuation of Suit Property-II. The court found this factually sets up a new case.

¶ 16

The amendments to paragraphs 13 to 15 and 21 elaborated on balance consideration, the Rs. 7,00,000/- payment, loan arrangements and alleged fraud, and were intertwined with the revised accounts of payment and adjustment.

¶ 17 · ¶ 18

The consequential amendment to paragraph 33 showed an unreconciled valuation discrepancy (Rs. 3,67,00,000/- in figures versus Rs. 2,17,00,000/- in words). The court did not treat this as decisive alone, but as indicative that the revised case could not be reconciled with the original pleadings.

¶ 19

Taken together, the amendments travelled beyond elaboration and sought a materially different factual account of consideration and its discharge, which is impermissible under Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Sanjeev Builders and Ganesh Prasad.

¶ 20

The court did not base its decision on the observations of the Additional District Judge; the reasoning rests on the amendments' inconsistency with the original plaint.

05Holding

The Division Bench held that the proposed amendments, read together, introduce a materially different factual case regarding consideration, payment and adjustment, and therefore cannot be permitted despite the pre-trial stage.

¶ 12 · ¶ 20

No ground warranted interference with the impugned order.

¶ 21

The appeal is dismissed, the order dated 22.01.2024 in I.A. No. 11430/2021 is affirmed, there is no order as to costs, and pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

¶ 21
Delhi High Court

Original Court PDF

Karan KapoorvsMadhuri Kumar And Ors

Delhi High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment