01Facts
On 06.05.2001, the appellant-claimant, Ved Parkash, was injured in a motor vehicle accident allegedly caused by the rash and negligent driving of truck HR-38-2711 (the offending vehicle).
¶ 1The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jhajjar, by award dated 15.02.2003, awarded Rs.38,511 (loss of future income, disability, pain and suffering: Rs.30,000; treatment: Rs.3,511; special diet, attendant charges and transportation: Rs.5,000).
¶ 3The Tribunal's finding on rash and negligent driving was not challenged, and the appeal concerns quantum only.
¶ 2The appellant suffered multiple injuries, including lacerated and incised wounds on the right elbow, forearm, and thigh, as recorded in the MLR (Ex.PW1/A).
¶ 6He was treated at Civil Hospital, Bahadurgarh, and then at PGIMS, Rohtak, and was hospitalised from 20.06.2001 to 09.07.2001.
¶ 5PW-2, Dr. Kumud Sharma, deposed to 25% permanent disability arising from a compound fracture of the right radial neck, supported by disability certificate Ex.PA2.
¶ 6Medical bills totalling Rs.3,511 were proved (Ex.P1 to Ex.P9).
¶ 6The appellant pleaded income of Rs.6,000 per month as a conductor, but failed to prove either income or vocation.
¶ 8The parties differ on age: the appellant's grounds state 49 years, whereas the Court proceeded on the unrebutted assertion that he was 40 at the time of the accident.
¶ 4 · ¶ 802Issues
i.1. Whether the appellant's loss of earning capacity should be assessed on the basis of functional disability, and at what percentage.
¶ 7 · ¶ 8ii.2. Whether the Tribunal erred in not adopting the pleaded income of Rs.6,000 per month, and what notional income should be taken in the absence of proof.
¶ 8iii.3. Whether future prospects should be added to the income in computing loss of earning capacity.
¶ 8iv.4. Whether a multiplier should be applied, and of what value.
¶ 8v.5. Whether compensation for pain and suffering, loss of future prospects and amenities, loss of income during treatment, future medical expenses, and medical, transport, diet and attendant charges should be enhanced.
¶ 4 · ¶ 9–1003Law Applied
The Court assessed functional disability by reference to the extent of permanent disability and the nature of the claimant's pre-accident work, treating the injury as impairing future earning capacity.
¶ 7Where income is not proved, the Court adopted the minimum wage payable to an unskilled worker in 1997, Rs.1,964 per month, as notional income.
¶ 8The Court added 25% future prospects, relying on National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, 2017 (16) SCC 680.
¶ 8The Court applied a multiplier of 15 by reference to the claimant's age, relying on Smt. Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, 2009 (6) SCC 121.
¶ 8The Court awarded non-pecuniary compensation under the heads of pain and suffering, and loss of future prospects and amenities, on the basis of the nature of injuries, the period of hospitalisation, and the permanent disability.
¶ 9Compensation for future medical expenses requires evidence of need for future treatment, and was denied in its absence.
¶ 904Reasoning
The Court held that the compound fracture and the resulting 25% permanent disability would impair the appellant's earning capacity, and fixed functional disability at 25% for an able-bodied labourer.
¶ 8Because the pleaded Rs.6,000 income and vocation were unproved, the Court adopted the 1997 unskilled minimum wage of Rs.1,964 per month.
¶ 8Applying the age of 40 years, the Court added 25% future prospects (Rs.491), giving Rs.2,455 per month, and then applied 25% functional disability, yielding Rs.614 per month.
¶ 8 · ¶ 10The loss of earning capacity, computed as Rs.614 × 15 × 12, is Rs.1,10,520.
¶ 10Loss of income during four months of treatment, inferred from the period of hospitalisation and the nature of injuries, is Rs.7,856.
¶ 9Non-pecuniary heads were enhanced on the basis of the severity of the injuries and the permanent disability. Pain and suffering was raised from Rs.30,000 to Rs.50,000, and loss of future prospects and amenities was fixed at Rs.75,000.
¶ 9Medical, transport, diet and attendant charges were raised to Rs.15,000. The claim for future medical expenses failed for want of evidence.
¶ 905Holding
The Court held that the appellant was entitled to enhanced compensation on the basis of 25% functional disability, notional income of Rs.1,964 per month, 25% future prospects, and a multiplier of 15.
¶ 8–10The re-worked total compensation is Rs.2,58,376, which yields an enhancement of Rs.2,19,865 over the Tribunal's award of Rs.38,511.
¶ 10The appeal is allowed in these terms, with interest at 7.5% per annum on the enhanced amount from the date of filing of the claim petition until realisation, and the respondents' liability to be discharged as per the award.
¶ 11 · ¶ 12Original Court PDF
Ved ParkashvsSatya Narain Sharma And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
