01Facts
On 24.05.1997, Sukhdev Singh (deceased) died in a collision involving Bus No. PB-02-B-9916 (owner: Mukhtiar Singh) and Tempo No. PB-06-2112 (driver: Rakesh Kumar).
¶ 3The claimants alleged rash and negligent driving by the bus driver, who overtook a truck, lost control, and struck the tempo and then a petrol pump wall.
¶ 3The bus driver and owner alleged that the tempo driver was at fault.
¶ 5The tempo driver and owner alleged that the bus driver, overtaking at high speed, struck the tempo parked on the kachcha path.
¶ 6The bus was admittedly uninsured.
¶ 4The Tribunal relied on the FIR lodged by the tempo driver, the criminal conviction of the bus driver arising from it, and the tempo driver's testimony (RW1) to find the bus driver solely negligent.
¶ 9, 15The Tribunal held the bus driver and owner solely liable and awarded Rs. 2,30,400/- on the basis of a monthly income of Rs. 2,400/- (minimum wages), a 1/3 deduction, and a multiplier of 12.
¶ 9, 15The claimants appealed for enhancement of compensation, and the bus owner appealed against liability.
¶ 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in holding the bus driver and owner solely negligent, given the conflicting accounts and the testimony of AW2 attributing fault to the tempo.
¶ 10–13ii.2. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased's income, applying the multiplier, deducting personal expenses, and omitting future prospects and conventional heads, warranting enhancement of compensation.
¶ 16–2103Law Applied
A tribunal may assess negligence from the totality of pleadings, FIR contents, unrebutted testimony, and surrounding circumstances, and may discount eyewitness evidence found unreliable.
¶ 11–13National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 was relied upon for a 25% addition to future prospects.
¶ 19Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 was relied upon for the multiplier of 14 for age 42.
¶ 19The settled practice of deducting a proportion of income for personal expenses based on the number of dependants was applied, here 1/4 for six dependants.
¶ 19Where direct proof of income is absent, income from agricultural holdings may be assessed through managerial contribution, following the approach of the Tribunal and the Court.
¶ 17–18Conventional heads (funeral expenses, loss of estate, consortium) were awarded subject to the pending reference in Hasina Yasmin (2025 SCC OnLine SC 2919).
¶ 2104Reasoning
On Issue 1, the Court found that AW2's testimony was doubtful: his presence was questionable, he had no ticket, he did not testify before police or in the criminal case, and his account itself placed fault on the bus driver for overtaking.
¶ 12The Court treated AW2's evidence as an attempt to shift liability to the insurer of the tempo, since the bus was uninsured.
¶ 11, 13The Court relied on the FIR, the unrebutted testimony of RW1, the bus driver's failure to enter the witness box, and the criminal conviction arising from the FIR, and held that the bus was on the wrong side of the road and its driver was at fault.
¶ 12–13On Issue 2, the Tribunal's income figure was rejected because it was based on minimum wages.
¶ 18The claimants' oral evidence of dairy income was unsupported by documentary proof, and the son admitted that the land was still cultivated by the family. Jamabandis (Ex. A4, A5) showed about five acres self-cultivated and a further holding leased to tenants.
¶ 17The Court assessed income at Rs. 4,000/- per month as managerial contribution and agricultural earnings, then applied a 25% future prospects addition, a 1/4 personal deduction, and a multiplier of 14.
¶ 17–20Conventional heads were awarded at Rs. 15,000 each for funeral expenses and loss of estate, Rs. 40,000 for spousal consortium, and Rs. 40,000 for each of five dependants for parental consortium.
¶ 21The recalculated loss of dependency is Rs. 6,30,000/- (Rs. 3,750 × 12 × 14), and the total award is Rs. 9,00,000/-, an enhancement of Rs. 6,69,600/- over the Tribunal's award.
¶ 2205Holding
The bus driver and owner were held solely liable for the accident, and the Tribunal correctly disregarded AW2's account.
¶ 13–14FAO No. 1010 of 2003 is dismissed.
¶ 14, 24The deceased's income is assessed at Rs. 4,000/- per month, with 25% future prospects, a multiplier of 14, and a 1/4 deduction.
¶ 18–20FAO No. 5223 of 2002 is allowed, and the total compensation is enhanced to Rs. 9,00,000/-. Interest is payable at 7.5% from the date of filing the claim on the non-conventional heads, and on the conventional heads from August 2017. Liability apportionment remains as per the original award. The claimants may seek further conventional-head relief if Hasina Yasmin is decided in their favour.
¶ 21–24Original Court PDF
Mukhtiar SinghvsRajinder Singh & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
