01Facts
On 11.06.2018 at about 4:00 a.m., the deceased Amin, a driver by profession, was assisting Narender (PW2) in removing a tyre from a stationary vehicle near Rama School, Dujana-Beri Road, Jhajjar. A truck, HR-73-7249, driven by respondent No.1 Om Kumar, allegedly struck the vehicles and then hit Amin, who died on the spot. FIR No. 279 was registered at P.S. Beri under Sections 279, 337 and 304-A IPC.
¶ 2The claimants (widow, two minor sons and parents) sought ₹50,00,000, pleading the deceased was about 30 and earned ₹25,000 per month.
¶ 3The owner and driver denied involvement, and the Insurance Company disputed both the vehicle's involvement and liability.
¶ 4The claimants examined Sharmila (PW1), Narender (PW2) and HC Sunil Kumar (PW3, IO). The respondents led no oral evidence.
¶ 5The Tribunal dismissed the claim because the initial complaint omitted the truck's registration number and driver's identity, which first surfaced in Narender's supplementary statement dated 13.06.2018. It found contradictions between Narender and the IO and held negligence unproved, leaving the other issues undetermined.
¶ 6On appeal, the truck was seized on 20.06.2018, mechanically inspected, released on superdari on 21.06.2018, and a charge-sheet was filed against respondent No.1.
¶ 7, 14, 1502Issues
i.1. Whether the accident dated 11.06.2018 was caused by the rash and negligent driving of truck HR-73-7249 by respondent No.1, given the omission of its registration number from the initial complaint and the alleged inconsistencies in the evidence.
¶ 6, 11, 19ii.2. Whether, upon reversal of the finding on negligence, the Court should itself determine compensation or remit the matter to the Tribunal for determination of Issues 2, 3 and 4.
¶ 20–2203Law Applied
The principle that MACT proceedings are summary in nature, that the criminal standard of proof is not imported into Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and that negligence is determined on the preponderance of probabilities.
¶ 10Bimla Devi v. HRTC (2009) 13 SCC 530, Mangla Ram v. Oriental Insurance Co. (2018) 5 SCC 656, and Sunita v. RSRTC (2020) 13 SCC 486 for the requirement that the Tribunal adopt a holistic appraisal of the evidence on the occurrence.
¶ 10Section 11 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872: an inconsistency does not automatically render testimony unreliable and the court must ask whether it goes to the root of the matter.
¶ 17The initial burden of proving negligence lies on the claimants, but a driver's failure to rebut material evidence assumes relevance once an eyewitness account is supported by investigation.
¶ 16A charge-sheet is not conclusive proof of negligence but is a relevant circumstance.
¶ 15On quantum, application of Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 and National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680.
¶ 23The general appellate preference for final disposal, departing from it only where the Tribunal made no findings on the essential components of compensation.
¶ 21Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 279Section 337
04Reasoning
The Tribunal treated the omission of the registration number from the initial complaint as decisive, and the discrepancy about when Narender learned of the vehicle as sufficient to discredit the whole claim. The High Court held this approach inconsistent with the holistic appraisal required in motor accident cases.
¶ 6, 13, 17The omission was a relevant circumstance requiring examination, but it could not outweigh the subsequent evidence. Narender was the complainant and an injured eyewitness whose presence at the scene was corroborated by the occurrence itself, and he firmly identified the truck and denied false implication.
¶ 11, 12The seizure, mechanical inspection and superdari release were corroborative circumstances, and the charge-sheet against respondent No.1 flowed from the investigation. Respondent No.1, the person best placed to explain the occurrence, did not testify, and the respondents led no evidence that the truck was falsely implicated. Taken together, these circumstances satisfied the preponderance standard.
¶ 14–16, 18On remand, the Court reasoned that the Tribunal had recorded no findings on income, dependency or compensation, so these matters were better decided by the Tribunal in the first instance.
¶ 20–2105Holding
The Court answered Issue 1 in the affirmative: the accident resulted from the rash and negligent driving of HR-73-7249 by respondent No.1, and the Tribunal's contrary finding is set aside.
¶ 18–19On Issue 2, the matter is remitted to the Tribunal for fresh adjudication of Issues 2, 3 and 4 (compensation and liability), with the negligence finding binding and not reopened. The Tribunal must compute compensation under Sarla Verma and Pranay Sethi, consider the widow's, minors' and parents' entitlements, and decide expeditiously, preferably within four months of the parties' appearance. The parties are directed to appear before the Tribunal on 07.12.2026. The appeal is allowed and disposed of in these terms.
¶ 22–27Original Court PDF
Minor Ansh And OthersvsOm Kumar And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
