01Facts
Two claim petitions arose from a motor accident on 29.12.1997 caused by the rash and negligent driving of a truck (PB-04-2818).
¶ 1–2The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ludhiana, by award dated 22.01.2002, awarded compensation in both petitions.
¶ 1–2Negligence was not challenged, so only quantum was in issue.
¶ 3MACT Case No. 49/1998 (FAO 3672/2002): The claimants (son and parents) sought compensation for the death of Ranjit Singh Ghuman, an advocate aged 30.
¶ 4, 7The Tribunal assessed his income at Rs. 5,000/month and awarded Rs. 5,76,000.
¶ 4The claimants pleaded income of Rs. 8,000–9,000/month, relying on PW-1's oral evidence of fee-sharing, but produced no documentary record of such payments.
¶ 6His enrolment certificate and identity card were on record.
¶ 6MACT Case No. 38/1998 (FAO 3685/2002): The claimant (son) sought compensation for the death of Inderjit Kaur, aged 26, who ran a beauty parlour.
¶ 11, 13–14The Tribunal assessed her income at Rs. 1,000/month and awarded Rs. 1,34,400.
¶ 11The claimant pleaded Rs. 6,000/month, supported only by AW-2's testimony that she had trained as a beautician.
¶ 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased advocate's income at Rs. 5,000/month where the pleaded income was Rs. 8,000–9,000/month, unsupported by documentary proof.
¶ 5–6ii.2. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased beautician's income at Rs. 1,000/month where the pleaded income was Rs. 6,000/month, and whether the notional minimum wage was the correct basis.
¶ 11, 13iii.3. Whether future prospects, the applicable multiplier, and the deduction for personal expenses were correctly applied in computing loss of dependency.
¶ 5, 7–8, 12, 14–15iv.4. Whether conventional heads (funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium) were adequately awarded under Pranay Sethi.
¶ 5, 9, 12, 1603Law Applied
Absent cogent proof of pleaded earnings, the income must be taken from an objective benchmark: the average income of an advocate with reference to income-tax limits for the advocate, and the minimum wage of a skilled worker for the beautician.
¶ 6, 13National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 mandates a 40% addition for a deceased aged below 40 in the case of a self-employed or fixed-income person.
¶ 7, 14Sarla Verma v. DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121 prescribes a multiplier of 17 for ages 26–30 and a one-third deduction where the deceased leaves three dependents, or one-half for two or fewer.
¶ 7, 14Pranay Sethi's standard of Rs. 15,000 each for funeral and loss of estate and Rs. 40,000 per claimant for consortium was applied for conventional heads.
¶ 9, 16The pending reference in Hasina Yasmin v. National Insurance Co. Ltd., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2919, on conventional-head quantum was noted.
¶ 9, 1604Reasoning
In FAO 3672/2002, the claimants' income evidence was oral and undocumented, though the deceased's status as an advocate was established by enrolment records. The court therefore rejected the pleaded Rs. 8,000–9,000 and upheld the Tribunal's Rs. 5,000/month as a reasonable figure for an advocate. It then applied 40% future prospects (Rs. 7,000), a one-third deduction for three dependents (Rs. 4,667), and a multiplier of 17, yielding loss of dependency of Rs. 9,52,068. Adding conventional heads of Rs. 1,50,000 produced a total of Rs. 11,02,068, an enhancement of Rs. 5,26,068.
¶ 6–8, 10In FAO 3685/2002, the court again found the pleaded Rs. 6,000 unproven, since AW-2 proved only training, not earnings. It applied the minimum wage of a skilled worker in 1997 (Rs. 1,729). With 40% future prospects (Rs. 2,420), a one-third deduction for a single surviving son (Rs. 1,613), and a multiplier of 17, the loss of dependency was Rs. 3,29,052. With conventional heads of Rs. 70,000, the total was Rs. 3,99,052, an enhancement of Rs. 2,64,652.
¶ 13–17Discrepancy noted: The Tribunal's tabulated computations do not match the income figures it recorded. In FAO 3672/2002, the table shows Rs. 3,000 × 16 × 12 = Rs. 5,76,000, whereas the stated income is Rs. 5,000. In FAO 3685/2002, the table shows Rs. 700 × 16 × 12 = Rs. 1,34,400, whereas the stated income is Rs. 1,000. The court's reworking does not expressly address these inconsistencies, and the appeals were decided on the court's own recomputation.
¶ 4, 1105Holding
The court held that the deceased advocate's income of Rs. 5,000/month and the deceased beautician's notional income of Rs. 1,729/month were the appropriate bases, since the pleaded incomes were unproven. Future prospects of 40%, a multiplier of 17, and a one-third personal-expense deduction apply in both cases.
¶ 6, 13 · ¶ 7–8, 14–15Both appeals are allowed in the terms stated. In FAO 3672/2002, compensation is enhanced by Rs. 5,26,068 to Rs. 11,02,068. In FAO 3685/2002, compensation is enhanced by Rs. 2,64,652 to Rs. 3,99,052.
¶ 10, 17, 19Each enhanced amount carries 7.5% interest from the date of filing of the claim petition until realisation, except conventional heads, which carry interest from August 2017 onwards. Apportionment and liability follow the original award. The claimants may seek additional conventional-head compensation if the Supreme Court in Hasina Yasmin answers the reference in their favour.
¶ 9, 16, 18Original Court PDF
Rajeshwar Ghuman (Minor) Etc.vsNarain Singh Etc.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
