Karnataka High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Acquittal upheld where the sole injured witness's testimony omitted the accused's role from the FIR and identification parade was defective

SMT.SAVITA W/O MALLIKARJUN @ MALLAYYA SWAMYv.VIVEKANAND @ ISHWAR S/O RUDRAYYA AND ORS

Acquittal upheld where the sole injured witness's testimony omitted the accused's role from the FIR and identification parade was defective. SMT.SAVITA W/O MALLIKARJUN @ MALLAYYA SWAMY vs VIVEKANAND @ ISHWAR S/O RUDRAYYA AND ORS. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the defacto complainant proves that the Sessions Court's judgment of acquittal is arbitrary, erroneous, and without appreciation of evidence, warranting interference under Section 372 CrPC.

The court held

The Court answered Point (i) in the negative, holding that the appellant failed to show that the Sessions Court's judgment was arbitrary, erroneous, or without appreciation of evidence.

It also directed

The prosecution failed to prove the accused's guilt beyond reasonable doubt on any charge.

The Court declined to interfere with the acquittal of Respondent Nos. 1 to 3.

The criminal appeal is dismissed, and the acquittal dated 28.10.2014 in S.C. No. 89 of 2012 stands.

01Facts

On 14.01.2012, the complainant, Smt. Savita (PW.1), lodged a complaint alleging that on the night of 13/14.01.2012 at Hedgapur village, unknown persons, after tying a wire around her neck, assaulted her, murdered her husband Mallikarjun @ Mallayya Swamy, and robbed gold and cash worth about Rs. 5.17 lakhs.

¶ 3–4

The police filed a charge sheet against four accused, and the case was committed to the Principal District Judge, Bidar, as S.C. No. 89 of 2012.

¶ 5

The prosecution examined 26 witnesses and marked 30 exhibits and M.Os. 1–58.

¶ 7

The accused denied the incriminating circumstances under Section 313 CrPC and led no defence evidence.

¶ 8

On 28.10.2014, the Sessions Court answered all charge-related points in the negative and acquitted the accused.

¶ 10

The defacto complainant appealed under Section 372 CrPC against the acquittal of Accused Nos. 1 to 3.

¶ 1, 11

PW.1 admitted she was unconscious from about 01:30 a.m. until about 09:00 a.m. the next day.

¶ 14, 19

Her complaint (Ex.P1) did not name Accused No. 1 or attribute the acts of wire-tying, murder, or threats to him.

¶ 19, 48

Witnesses PW.6 to PW.8 supported an account not in her Section 161 statement.

¶ 58

PWs. 9 to 12 turned hostile.

¶ 32–34

The identification parade (PW.14) identified only Accused No. 1, with procedural lapses.

¶ 38, 59

02Issues

i.1. Whether the defacto complainant proves that the Sessions Court's judgment of acquittal is arbitrary, erroneous, and without appreciation of evidence, warranting interference under Section 372 CrPC.

¶ 17(i)

ii.2. Whether the evidence of PW.1, the sole eyewitness, is sufficient to sustain the conviction of the accused beyond reasonable doubt, given the omissions in Ex.P1 and the identification parade defects.

¶ 56, 59–60

03Law Applied

Section 372 CrPC permits a victim to appeal against acquittal.

¶ 1

Sections 302, 307, 394, and 397 read with Section 34 IPC define the charged offences of murder, attempt to murder, robbery, and robbery with grievous hurt in furtherance of common intention.

¶ 1, 9

The scope of appellate interference with an order of acquittal is very narrow, so that an acquittal will be disturbed only where the trial court's findings are perverse or unsupported by the evidence, as drawn from Jafarudheen & Ors. v. State of Kerala (2022 SCC OnLine SC 495).

¶ 15

Sections 161, 209, and 313 CrPC govern prior police statements, committal, and the examination of the accused.

¶ 8, 10

The prosecution must establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

¶ 60

Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 372Section 209Section 313Section 161

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 307Section 394Section 397Section 34Section 396

04Reasoning

The entire prosecution case rested on PW.1's testimony, and the Court held her evidence unreliable on several grounds.

¶ 56

Her unconsciousness for over seven hours after the incident undermined her ability to give a contemporaneous account.

¶ 56–57

Ex.P1 did not name Accused No. 1, attribute the wire-tying or murder to him, or describe him as the person on the roof.

¶ 48, 57

Witnesses Ashok, Ramayya, Siddanna, and Subhash, to whom she allegedly narrated the incident, did not depose to any such narration.

¶ 57

Independent witnesses were hostile or did not support the prosecution's version of events, and PW.6 to PW.8's account of PW.1 gesturing toward the roof was absent from her Section 161 statement and her evidence. PW.5 was a hearsay witness.

¶ 58

The identification parade was further compromised: PW.1 did not identify Accused Nos. 2 to 4, the identifying officer did not verify identities or obtain the jailer's permission certificate, and the parade was conducted in an open space without masking the accused.

¶ 38, 59

The medical evidence (PW.21, PW.25) established injuries but did not link the accused to them.

¶ 45–46, 52–53

Applying the narrow scope of interference under Jafarudheen, the Court found that the Sessions Court had considered the entire evidence and that its reasoning was not perverse.

¶ 15, 60–61

The appellant's argument that PW.1 is an injured witness whose testimony should suffice was not accepted, because the omissions and the defective identification undermined that testimony.

¶ 13

05Holding

The Court answered Point (i) in the negative, holding that the appellant failed to show that the Sessions Court's judgment was arbitrary, erroneous, or without appreciation of evidence.

¶ 61

The prosecution failed to prove the accused's guilt beyond reasonable doubt on any charge.

¶ 60

The Court declined to interfere with the acquittal of Respondent Nos. 1 to 3.

¶ 61

The criminal appeal is dismissed, and the acquittal dated 28.10.2014 in S.C. No. 89 of 2012 stands.

¶ 62
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SMT.SAVITA W/O MALLIKARJUN @ MALLAYYA SWAMYvsVIVEKANAND @ ISHWAR S/O RUDRAYYA AND ORS

Karnataka High Court · November 13, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment