Karnataka High CourtCivil Procedure and EvidenceCivil Law

After Plaintiff Declined Repeated Chances To Lead Evidence, Karnataka HC Upholds Refusal To Reopen Linked Property Suits

SURESHAv.S SATHISHA

After Plaintiff Declined Repeated Chances To Lead Evidence, Karnataka HC Upholds Refusal To Reopen Linked Property Suits. SURESHA vs S SATHISHA. Karnataka High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Trial Court’s refusal to reopen the evidence and permit the requested further evidence warranted interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.

The court held

The High Court held that no error or infirmity in the Trial Court’s order justified interference under Article 227.

It also directed

It dismissed the writ petition and declined to permit withdrawal of the impugned applications with liberty to file another application.

01Facts

Suresha had instituted O.S. No. 189/2002 seeking declaration and permanent injunction. Defendant No. 3(c) in that suit later instituted O.S. No. 57/2013 for partition and separate possession; the two suits were clubbed in 2021, although their schedules differed.

p. 5, 8

By then, Suresha had completed his evidence in O.S. No. 189/2002 and had filed a written statement in O.S. No. 57/2013. The Trial Court directed him to lead further evidence, but he filed a memo stating that he had already adduced evidence and reserved a right to lead rebuttal evidence.

pp. 8–9

His request to record separate evidence was rejected, and that rejection was upheld by the High Court in W.P. No. 2644/2022.

pp. 8–9

Suresha later challenged the Trial Court’s rejection of applications seeking reopening of evidence and permission for cross-examination, and sought leave to withdraw those applications to file a different application.

p. 5, 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Trial Court’s refusal to reopen the evidence and permit the requested further evidence warranted interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.

p. 5, 11

ii.2. Whether Suresha should be permitted to withdraw the impugned applications and pursue a fresh application, given the earlier proceedings and orders concerning his opportunity to lead evidence.

pp. 10–11

03Law Applied

The petition invoked the High Court’s supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution; the Court considered whether the impugned order disclosed an error or infirmity warranting its intervention.

p. 4, 11

The order cites no specific provision of the Code of Civil Procedure or general precedent.

The Court relied on its earlier decision in W.P. No. 2644/2022, which had rejected the request to record separate evidence but left Suresha entitled to urge contentions regarding self-acquisition in light of his written statement in O.S. No. 57/2013.

p. 10

The Court also considered that Suresha had been afforded opportunities to lead further evidence but had declined them.

pp. 8–9

04Reasoning

The Court found that Suresha had been directed to lead further evidence after the suits were clubbed but had chosen not to do so, instead seeking separate evidence—a request already rejected and reviewed in W.P. No. 2644/2022.

pp. 8–9

The impugned applications, although presented as seeking reopening and further evidence, sought to allow defendant No. 3 to adduce evidence and were inconsistent with the earlier orders.

pp. 9–11

The Court considered that entertaining them would indirectly revive the claim for separate evidence already rejected; it also noted the circumstances supporting the respondents’ concern that the applications could delay the proceedings.

pp. 9–11

Because Suresha remained entitled to urge the relevant contentions at trial, the Court found no justification or bona fides for permitting withdrawal of the applications to pursue a further opportunity.

p. 10

05Holding

The High Court held that no error or infirmity in the Trial Court’s order justified interference under Article 227.

p. 11

It dismissed the writ petition and declined to permit withdrawal of the impugned applications with liberty to file another application.

p. 11
Karnataka High Court

Original Court PDF

SURESHAvsS SATHISHA

Karnataka High Court · October 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment