01Facts
The petitioners challenged the Trial Court’s rejection of their application under Order XI Rule 14 CPC, which sought production of original documents said to be in the records of another suit.
pp. 3–4They submitted that certified copies were already on record, but that defendants 2 and 3 had undertaken during cross-examination to obtain and produce the originals and had not done so.
pp. 3–4The Trial Court rejected the application because certified copies were available and the originals formed part of records connected with a pending appeal.
p. 5The High Court disposed of the writ petition without setting aside the order, while reserving liberty to seek summons for the originals through an appropriate application.
pp. 6–702Issues
i.1. Whether the availability of certified copies and the location of original documents in another court’s records justified refusing their production.
p. 5ii.2. Whether the Trial Court could seek the original documents from records then before the High Court in a pending appeal.
pp. 5–603Law Applied
Order XI Rule 14 CPC provides the procedural basis for seeking production of documents in a party’s possession or power.
The Court held that a Trial Court may, on an appropriate application, summon documents forming part of another judicial proceeding where they are required to adjudicate the dispute; the availability of certified copies does not, by itself, bar such a request when specific grounds establish the need for the originals.
p. 5The Court also held that the pendency of an appeal, and the fact that the records are before the appellate court, do not constitute a legal impediment to making the documents available to the Trial Court upon request.
pp. 5–604Reasoning
The Court considered the Trial Court’s two stated grounds for rejecting the application: the presence of certified copies on the record and the location of the originals in records associated with a pending appeal.
p. 5It held that neither ground categorically precluded production of the originals, particularly where the petitioners asserted a specific need for them.
p. 5However, rather than quashing the rejection, the Court left the petitioners to pursue the appropriate procedure by applying to the Trial Court to summon the documents.
p. 605Holding
The writ petition was disposed of, and the impugned order was not set aside.
pp. 6–7The petitioners were granted liberty to file an appropriate application before the Trial Court seeking summons of the original documents.
pp. 6–7The Court directed that, if the Trial Court requests them, the Registry must take the necessary steps to make the documents available, notwithstanding their presence before the High Court in the pending appeal.
pp. 6–7Original Court PDF
SRI SUNIL KvsSRI N KUMAR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
