01Facts
The landlady filed a release application under Section 21(1)(b) of the U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act, 1972 ("Act, 1972") on 24.11.2018, relying on a 2012 sale deed for a ground-floor shop (approx. 18 × 5.87 ft, rent Rs. 100/month) in a building said to be 90–100 years old and dilapidated.
¶ 7–8The tenant, who held an allotment dated 15.04.1993, disputed the dilapidation and the need for reconstruction.
¶ 9The Prescribed Authority rejected the application on 21.02.2023 for non-compliance with Rule 17 of the U.P. Urban Buildings Rules, 1972 ("Rules, 1972") regarding the estimate, plan, and financial capacity.
¶ 10The landlady appealed under Section 22 (Appeal No. 38 of 2023) and, on 17.11.2025, sought to bring on record an engineer's estimate and income-tax material, attributing non-production to her previous counsel's oversight.
¶ 11The tenant objected that the documents were already available and that the application sought to fill gaps in the case.
¶ 12On 26.11.2025 the Appellate Court allowed the application, citing Section 34.
¶ 12The tenant's writ (Writ-A No. 1227 of 2026) was pending, but no stay was granted; the Appellate Court decided the appeal on 18.03.2026, allowing release and directing vacant possession within 30 days.
¶ 13The tenant was later evicted, the building was demolished, and possession was taken by the landlady.
¶ 19, 2402Issues
i.1. Whether the Appellate Court was justified in admitting additional evidence under Section 34 of the Act, 1972, and whether such admission had to satisfy Order XLI Rule 27 CPC, and if so, whether those conditions were met.
¶ 25(i) · ¶ 36–50ii.2. Whether the Appellate Court, while allowing release under Section 21(1)(b), was required to examine whether the proposed demolition and reconstruction would frustrate or render ineffective the original tenant's right under Section 24(2).
¶ 25(ii) · ¶ 73, 79–84iii.3. Whether the Section 24(2) right is merely a subsequent remedy to be pursued before the District Magistrate after reconstruction, or whether its effective preservation is also relevant at the release stage.
¶ 25(iii) · ¶ 65–68, 85–8703Law Applied
The Court relied on Section 22 of the Act, 1972, read with Section 10(2), which permits the Appellate Authority to take additional evidence.
¶ 27Section 34(1)(b) allows receipt of evidence on affidavit, but it is a separate power and does not itself confer authority to admit additional evidence.
¶ 28, 36Order XLI Rule 27 CPC governs additional evidence in appeals, though it applies only by analogy to statutory appellate powers.
¶ 30, 38Under Section 21(1)(b), release may be ordered where a building is dilapidated and required for demolition and new construction.
¶ 31Section 24(2) gives the original tenant a right to apply to the District Magistrate, within the period in Rule 20, for allotment of the new building, subject to rent at 1% per month of construction cost.
¶ 32, 34Rule 17 requires the Prescribed Authority to be satisfied on four matters: the need for demolition, a proper estimate, a plan conforming to bye-laws, and the landlord's financial capacity.
¶ 33Additional evidence under Section 10(2) must be supplementary and not a substitute for the court of first instance (Rajkumar v. Nasir Ahmad).
¶ 39Additional evidence is not admitted merely to fill gaps (Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin; Gobind Singh v. Union of India).
¶ 42Section 21(1)(b) and 24(2) must be read conjointly so the tenant's statutory right is not rendered illusory (Karamat Ullah; Sanjay Bhardwaj @ Bablu).
¶ 57–59, 64–65Appropriate undertakings or time-bound conditions may be imposed to protect the tenant (Riazur Rahman Khan; Rafeeq Ahmad).
¶ 61–63Provisions in the judgment · 7
U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act, 1972 Section 2Section 10Section 21Section 22Section 24Section 34Section 38
04Reasoning
On Issue 1, the Court held that the explanation of counsel's oversight did not satisfy the due-diligence requirement of Order XLI Rule 27(aa), since the documents were not shown to have come into existence later.
¶ 44However, Section 10(2) is an independent statutory power, and the engineer's estimate and income-tax material bore directly on Rule 17(ii) and (iv).
¶ 45The Appellate Court had considered relevance, granted the tenant rebuttal, and recorded reasons, so the order could not be called without jurisdiction.
¶ 46–47, 50Admission did not establish the documents' truth; their evidentiary weight remained to be assessed in the final appeal.
¶ 48–49On Issue 2, the Court held that Section 24(2) is a consequence of a Section 21(1)(b) release and must be read with Rule 17, so the Appellate Court should examine whether the proposed plan forecloses any meaningful re-entry.
¶ 57, 66–68, 73The Court nevertheless held that the actual allotment is for the District Magistrate, and that undertakings or conditions are case-specific rather than mandatory preconditions to release.
¶ 67, 79, 87The Court found that the Appellate Court had examined Rule 17 requirements and that no perversity or error of law was shown in the absence of a separate 24(2) finding.
¶ 80–83, 88–89On Issue 3, the Court held that the Section 24(2) right is a continuation of the Section 21(1)(b) proceedings and is not wholly detached from them. Its effective preservation is a relevant consideration at the release stage, but the claim itself is for the District Magistrate after construction.
¶ 65, 73, 78–7905Holding
The Court answered that the Appellate Court's admission of additional evidence was within its jurisdiction under Section 10(2), though not justified by the oversight explanation alone, and that no interference was warranted.
¶ 50It held that release under Section 21(1)(b) must consider the preservation of the Section 24(2) right, but the absence of an express finding or undertaking does not by itself invalidate release.
¶ 73, 87–89The Court held that the Section 24(2) right remains a subsequent statutory remedy for determination by the District Magistrate.
¶ 85, 93Both writ petitions were dismissed; the order dated 26.11.2025 and the judgment dated 18.03.2026 were upheld, with no costs. The tenant was free to invoke Section 24(2) at the appropriate stage, to be decided independently by the competent authority.
¶ 90–94Original Court PDF
Anees AhmadvsSmt Rukaiya Begum And 3 Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
