01Facts
The deceased, Ram Kishan, was an ad-hoc forest watcher in Dudhwa National Park. He had earlier caught the accused cutting forest timber, which led to an altercation. The accused were taken to the Range Office and released after apologising, but they harboured enmity against him.
¶ 5, 40On 04.10.1986, at about 6:00 P.M., while returning from Belrayan market, the deceased was allegedly ambushed in the forest by Ram Bharosey (armed with a country-made pistol) and Chugna and Guddu (armed with knives). Ram Bharosey fired one shot, striking the deceased in the left chest. The other two then allegedly stabbed him after he fell.
¶ 6–7The deceased died on the way to hospital.
¶ 8The FIR was lodged at 23:15 hours the same night by the informant, PW-4 Ram Sahay, who named all three accused.
¶ 8The post-mortem by PW-5 Dr. S.K. Tewari recorded ten ante-mortem injuries: multiple firearm entry wounds on the left upper chest (Injury No. 10), with 56 pellets and 2 heart-wall pellets recovered, and nine incised wounds on the forehead, face, lips, chin and jaw. The doctor opined that death resulted from shock and haemorrhage due to the firearm injury. The incised wounds were not penetrating, and the skull, brain and major vessels were intact.
¶ 22–23, 43The knife was not recovered. A 12-bore spent cartridge was recovered from the scene.
¶ 11, 35Eyewitnesses PW-1 (brother-in-law) and PW-4 (informant) supported the prosecution. PW-2 and PW-3, the independent witnesses, were declared hostile. Their evidence was limited to hearing the gunshot, seeing the accused fleeing, and, in part, seeing Chugna with a knife.
¶ 17–19, 73–75PW-1's statement under Section 161 CrPC was recorded about 14–15 days late.
¶ 16, 26Chugna was defended by a court-appointed amicus, who conducted nil cross-examination of several witnesses.
¶ 18–19, 30The trial court convicted Chugna, Ram Bharosey and Guddu under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and acquitted them under Section 504 IPC. Guddu's appeal abated on his death.
¶ 3, 402Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt the charge under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC against the appellants.
¶ 37(I), 39–78ii.2. Whether the amicus curiae's failure to cross-examine material prosecution witnesses (PW-2, PW-3, PW-5, PW-6) caused grave prejudice to Chugna and vitiated the trial.
¶ 37(II), 76iii.3. Whether the findings and conviction recorded by the trial court are sustainable in law.
¶ 37(III), 7803Law Applied
The court applied Section 302 IPC (murder) and Section 34 IPC (common intention), which requires both common intention and participation in furtherance of it.
¶ 47Common intention presupposes a prior meeting of minds or pre-arranged plan, as laid down in Pandurang v. State of Hyderabad and Mahbub Shah v. King Emperor.
¶ 48, 50Common intention may be inferred from circumstances, as held in Jai Bhagwan v. State of Haryana.
¶ 49Common intention may be inferred from the weapons used, the site of injuries, and the conduct of the accused before, during and after the occurrence, as held in Krishnamurthy @ Gunodu v. State of Karnataka.
¶ 51Motive is not essential where direct ocular evidence is credible.
¶ 41–42Normal and non-material contradictions do not affect the core of the case (Ramesh Harijan; C. Muniappan).
¶ 58–61Natural reactions of witnesses vary, and failure to intervene does not discredit them (Rana Pratap v. State of Haryana).
¶ 65Delay in recording Section 161 statements is not fatal by itself if explained (Firoz Khan Akbarkhan v. State of Maharashtra).
¶ 67–68Hostile witnesses' testimony may be relied on in so far as it supports the prosecution (Siddhartha Vashisht; Veer Singh; Shyamal Ghosh).
¶ 70–71Non-recovery of the weapon is not fatal where ocular evidence is corroborated by medical evidence (Mrityunjoy Biswas).
¶ 77Relationship alone does not discredit a witness (Gulab v. State of U.P.).
¶ 33, 54Cases on exoneration of co-accused for spur-of-the-moment acts (Sovaran Singh Prajapati; Tarun Sharma; Raj Kumar @ Suman) apply only on their facts.
¶ 32, 52Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 374Section 82Section 83Section 161Section 313Section 164
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302Section 34Section 504
04Reasoning
The court first held that the death was homicidal. The firearm injury was the cause of death, and the incised wounds corroborated the ocular account.
¶ 43–44On Section 34, the court reasoned that all three accused came armed with a firearm and knives, and that the knife-armed accused inflicted repeated blows on the fallen victim, on upper body parts including the face and jaw.
¶ 56Repeated blows after collapse, in the court's view, showed a shared intention to kill that could not arise by chance.
¶ 56The court distinguished Sovaran Singh Prajapati, Tarun Sharma and Raj Kumar because there the co-accused had no shared intention and the fatal act was spontaneous. Here, the accused were found to have arrived together, acted together and fled together.
¶ 52, 78The court accepted PW-1 and PW-4 as credible despite their relationship to the deceased and PW-4's deviation from the FIR on whether Ram Bharosey used a knife. The court treated these as minor contradictions that did not affect the core role of each accused: firing by Ram Bharosey and knife assaults by Chugna and Guddu.
¶ 53–63, 66The delay in PW-1's statement was not held fatal because the informant promptly lodged the FIR and named the witnesses.
¶ 67The court treated the hostile witnesses' evidence as admissible in part. PW-2 and PW-3 corroborated the gunshot, the presence of the accused at the spot, the carrying of weapons and their flight.
¶ 73–75Non-recovery of the knife was not fatal, given the ocular evidence and its corroboration by the medical findings.
¶ 77On the amicus's conduct, the court held that co-accused Ram Bharosey's counsel had tested the witnesses on identical points. No specific prejudice to Chugna was shown, so brevity in cross-examination did not vitiate the trial.
¶ 7605Holding
The court held that the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the accused shared a common intention to kill and jointly committed the murder under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC.
¶ 78The court held that the amicus's limited cross-examination caused no prejudice and did not vitiate the trial.
¶ 76The court held the trial court's conviction free from illegality, infirmity or perversity.
¶ 78The appeal was dismissed. The conviction and life sentence of Chugna and Ram Bharosey were upheld. Chugna was directed to remain in custody. Ram Bharosey's bail bonds were cancelled and he was directed to surrender to serve his sentence. The appeal against Guddu had already abated on his death. The trial record was ordered returned to the trial court.
¶ 79, 80, 81, 82, 84Original Court PDF
Chagna And OthersvsState Of U.P.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
