Allahabad High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Allahabad HC Commutes Death Sentence For Man Who Raped, Killed Minor Girl; Trial Court Skipped Balance Sheet

Ashokv.State of U.P.

Allahabad HC Commutes Death Sentence For Man Who Raped, Killed Minor Girl; Trial Court Skipped Balance Sheet. Ashok vs State of U.P.. Allahabad High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the chain of circumstances (last-seen evidence of PW-3, prompt disclosure, recovery of the body on the accused's disclosure, medical evidence, and the accused's failure to explain under Section 313 Cr.P.C.) conclusively establishes the accused's guilt under Sections 302, 201, 363, 376AB IPC and Section 5m/6 POCSO Act.

The court held

The court affirmed the convictions and findings recorded by the Trial Court for the other offences, which remain unchanged.

It also directed

The court held that the case does not fall within the rarest of rare category, set aside the death sentence, and substituted life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC.

The operative paragraph refers to sentencing under "Sections 302 read with Sections 201, 363, 376 IPC" rather than Section 376AB, which the Trial Court applied. This discrepancy should be verified against the formal order before reliance.

The Reference for confirmation of death sentence (Reference No. 11 of 2021) was rejected.

Capital Case No. 14 of 2021 was partly allowed.

The Trial Court record was ordered to be returned for compliance.

The learned Amicus Curiae, Sri Rajrshi Gupta, was held entitled to a fee of Rs. 21,000/-.

01Facts

On 04.08.2020, the minor victim (aged about 8-9) and her younger sister Kanak (PW-3, aged 6) went to collect jamun near a cooperative godown in village Sikri, P.S. Khurja Nagar, District Bulandshahr.

¶ 3, 20

Kanak returned alone and told the family that the accused, Ashok, a frequent visitor to the house, had taken the victim away on the pretext of getting her corn cob.

¶ 3, 21

After an extensive search, the family located the accused in the village, and his answers were evasive. They dialled 112.

¶ 3, 20, 22

Police arrived, and the accused allegedly confessed to raping and strangulating the victim and concealing her body in a plastic sack in a sugarcane field.

¶ 3, 20, 22, 23

The body was recovered on his indication and identified by the parents.

¶ 3, 20, 23

An FIR was registered at 00:13 hours on 05.08.2020 under Sections 302, 201, 376, 511 IPC and Sections 6 and 18 POCSO Act.

¶ 4

The post-mortem found asphyxia due to strangulation, a fractured hyoid bone, neck injuries, thigh contusions, and genital injuries.

¶ 15, 32

The Trial Court (Special Judge, POCSO, Bulandshahr) convicted the accused under Sections 363, 376AB, 302, 201 IPC and Section 5m/6 POCSO Act on 02.09.2021 and imposed death under Section 302 IPC on 03.09.2021.

¶ 2

The death reference under Section 366 Cr.P.C. was registered as Reference No. 11 of 2021 and the accused filed Capital Case No. 14 of 2021.

¶ 1-2

The accused's Section 313 Cr.P.C. statement was a bare denial alleging false implication over a prior gambling dispute.

¶ 24

02Issues

i.1. Whether the chain of circumstances (last-seen evidence of PW-3, prompt disclosure, recovery of the body on the accused's disclosure, medical evidence, and the accused's failure to explain under Section 313 Cr.P.C.) conclusively establishes the accused's guilt under Sections 302, 201, 363, 376AB IPC and Section 5m/6 POCSO Act.

¶ 30-33

ii.2. Whether the objections raised by the appellant (delay in recording PW-3's statement, prejudice from compound questions under Section 313 Cr.P.C., and reliance on the post-mortem report alone) are sustainable.

¶ 25-27, 35

iii.3. Whether the present case falls within the "rarest of rare" category warranting the death penalty.

¶ 34-40

03Law Applied

The court applied Section 302 IPC (murder), Sections 201, 363 and 376AB IPC, Section 5m/6 POCSO Act, and Section 27 of the Evidence Act (admissibility of information leading to recovery, to the extent it discloses the fact discovered).

¶ 32-33

The court applied Section 106 of the Evidence Act and Section 29 POCSO Act (presumption and burden in aggravated sexual offences), and Section 313 Cr.P.C. (the accused's duty to explain incriminating circumstances).

¶ 30, 33

On sentencing, the court relied on Jagmohan Singh v. State of U.P.

¶ 34

On sentencing, the court relied on Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (death penalty is an exception; life imprisonment is the rule).

¶ 34, 36

On sentencing, the court relied on Machhi Singh v. State of Punjab (rarest of rare test, requiring the "balance sheet" of aggravating and mitigating circumstances).

¶ 34, 36

On sentencing, the court relied on Swami Shraddananda v. State of Karnataka (life imprisonment without remission as an alternative).

¶ 34

On sentencing, the court relied on Santosh Kumar Satishbhushan Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra (the collective conscience and mitigating factors must be weighed).

¶ 34, 36

The appellant's authorities, Vandana v. State of Maharashtra (fairness of Section 313 questioning), Shahid Khan v. State of Rajasthan (delay in recording statements), Chotkau v. State of U.P. (immaterial omissions where witness is untrustworthy), and Balaji Gunthu Dhule v. State of Maharashtra (post-mortem alone is insufficient), were considered but found inapplicable.

¶ 25, 26, 27, 35

Provisions in the judgment · 12 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 201Section 302Section 363Section 376Section 511

Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Section 5Section 6Section 18Section 29

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 164Section 207Section 313

04Reasoning

On guilt, the court held that the prosecution established a complete, unbroken chain of circumstances pointing only to the accused.

¶ 30

PW-3's testimony was found consistent on material particulars despite lengthy cross-examination, and minor discrepancies were treated as natural in a child witness.

¶ 31

This was corroborated by her Section 164 Cr.P.C. statement, the recovery of the body on the accused's disclosure, the medical evidence, and PW-4 Neeraj's evidence.

¶ 31, 35

The court rejected the delay objection on PW-3's statement because the appellant identified no specific prejudice and the objection was not linked to any doubt on her core account.

¶ 35

The court treated the accused's bare denial and failure to offer any explanation under Section 313 Cr.P.C. as additional support for the prosecution, given that his evasiveness after the disappearance was itself relevant.

¶ 33

On sentencing, the court found that the Trial Court had not prepared any balance sheet of aggravating and mitigating circumstances. It had relied merely on the nature of the injuries and the rape-murder of a minor.

¶ 36-37

The record contained no evidence that the accused was a habitual or hardened offender, a hired killer, or a menace to society, and no criminal history was produced.

¶ 38

The death sentence was held unjustified, because the case was not shown to fall within the rarest of rare category.

¶ 39-41

05Holding

The court affirmed the convictions and findings recorded by the Trial Court for the other offences, which remain unchanged.

¶ 44

The court held that the case does not fall within the rarest of rare category, set aside the death sentence, and substituted life imprisonment under Section 302 IPC.

¶ 40-42, 44

The operative paragraph refers to sentencing under "Sections 302 read with Sections 201, 363, 376 IPC" rather than Section 376AB, which the Trial Court applied. This discrepancy should be verified against the formal order before reliance.

¶ 42

The Reference for confirmation of death sentence (Reference No. 11 of 2021) was rejected.

¶ 43

Capital Case No. 14 of 2021 was partly allowed.

¶ 44

The Trial Court record was ordered to be returned for compliance.

¶ 45

The learned Amicus Curiae, Sri Rajrshi Gupta, was held entitled to a fee of Rs. 21,000/-.

¶ 46
Allahabad High Court

Original Court PDF

AshokvsState of U.P.

Allahabad High Court · November 17, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment