01Facts
The appellant, Ram Raj @ Lala, was convicted under Section 376 IPC by the III Additional Sessions Judge, Fatehpur, in S.T. No. 39 of 1983, and sentenced to four years' rigorous imprisonment (trial judgment dated 07.01.1984).
¶ 2The prosecution case is that on 10.07.1982, at about 4:00 p.m., in a forest area while grazing cattle, the appellant pushed the minor victim to the ground, attempted to insert his penis, failed, and then inserted his finger into her urethra, causing bleeding.
¶ 3Witnesses Shiv Pyare, Ramesur/Rameshwar and Buddhu allegedly reached the spot on hearing her cries, and the appellant fled.
¶ 3, 5–6The FIR was lodged on 11.07.1982 through the village Pradhan, after the father's report was delayed by one day; the blood-stained underwear was seized.
¶ 4, 18–20The victim's age was assessed by radiological evidence at not more than 14 years (P.W.-1), and as about 14 years by the medical officer (P.W.-7).
¶ 8–10, 38The victim's testimony (P.W.-2) describes attempted penile penetration, digital insertion, and bleeding.
¶ 11Her statements varied in describing the body part involved (buttock, urethra, vagina) and the manner of occurrence.
¶ 6, 11, 13–14P.W.-4 (Rameshwar) deposed that he saw the appellant fleeing.
¶ 22P.W.-7 found a ruptured hymen, slight bleeding at the 7 o'clock position, and admission of one finger with difficulty; no external injury was found; he opined rape within 12–24 hours.
¶ 35–39On cross-examination, P.W.-7 accepted that the injury could also have been caused by a fall onto a hard object or a pigeon pea stalk.
¶ 40–41The appellant's Section 313 statement pleaded enmity and a fall while fleeing.
¶ 4202Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution established "penetration" sufficient to constitute rape under Section 375 IPC, given that complete penetration was not proved and the hymen was ruptured with a possible alternative cause.
¶ 47, 50–66ii.2. Whether variations in the victim's testimony, the absence of external injuries, and the doctor's admission of an alternative cause for the injury render the prosecution case unreliable.
¶ 40–41, 73–75iii.3. Whether the sole testimony of the prosecutrix, supported by the medical and circumstantial evidence, is sufficient to sustain conviction without independent corroboration.
¶ 69–72iv.4. Whether the alleged enmity, the delay in lodging the FIR, and the investigating officer's lapses vitiate the prosecution case.
¶ 43–46, 76–7703Law Applied
Section 375 IPC defines rape and contains the explanation that "penetration is sufficient"; Section 376 IPC is the punishment provision.
¶ 47, 48State of Kerala v. Kundumkara Govindam, 1969 Cri LJ 818, holds that rupture of the hymen is not essential and that medical evidence of penetration suffices, even if the hymen remains intact.
¶ 52, 54Rajendra Datta Jarekar v. State, 2008 CrLJ 710 (SC), holds that hymen rupture is not necessary and that false implication is improbable.
¶ 53Ghanashyam Misra v. State, AIR 1957 Ori 78, and Bhudanlal Sharma v. State of Orissa, 1961 (1) Cri LJ 689, hold that the depth of penetration is immaterial and that partial penetration or even an attempt suffices.
¶ 57–59Vijay v. State of U.P., 2010 (3) SCC (Cri) 639, and State of U.P. v. Chhotey Lal, (2011) 2 SCC (Cri) 674, are relied upon on the sufficiency of the prosecutrix's sole testimony.
¶ 69, 70Takdir Shamsuddin Sheikh v. State of Gujarat, AIR 2012 SC 37, applies Section 134 of the Evidence Act on the sufficiency of a single reliable witness.
¶ 72Iqbal Moosa Patel v. State of Gujarat, 2011 (2) ACR 1897 (SC), holds that "beyond reasonable doubt" does not mean "beyond shadow of doubt."
¶ 78Yogesh Singh v. Mahabir Singh, (2017) 11 SCC 195, Prabhu Dayal v. State of Rajasthan, (2018) 8 SCC 127, and Ramayan Singh v. State, 2011 (2) ACR 1930 (All HC), are noted on minor discrepancies and corroborative medical evidence.
¶ 45–46Provisions in the judgment · 8 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 376Section 511Section 375Section 377
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 161Section 82Section 83Section 313
04Reasoning
The three-stage process (intention, preparation, execution) was held to be made out, as the appellant repeatedly attempted penile penetration, failed, and then digitally penetrated the victim, causing bleeding.
¶ 50–51Applying the "slightest penetration" principle, the court found the ruptured hymen, bleeding at the 7 o'clock position, and admission of one finger with difficulty consistent with penetration, and treated the absence of complete penetration as immaterial.
¶ 36, 51, 57The court acknowledged variations in the victim's description of the body part and manner of assault, but held that they did not "demolish the substratum" of the case, as the core allegation of forcible sexual assault with bleeding was consistently maintained.
¶ 73The medical opinion of a possible alternative cause (a fall) was treated as insufficient to displace the ocular testimony, medical evidence being "corroborative in nature."
¶ 74The absence of external injuries was held not fatal in view of the internal findings.
¶ 75The victim's account was found corroborated by her prompt disclosure to her father, by P.W.-4's account of seeing the appellant fleeing, and by the radiological evidence of minority.
¶ 71, 22The delay of one day was accepted as explained by the father's evening return and the village Pradhan's involvement.
¶ 77The enmity plea was rejected as unsubstantiated by independent material, and the Section 313 explanation was found not to account for the medical findings.
¶ 7605Holding
The court held that the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant committed rape, and that the victim's sole testimony, corroborated by medical and circumstantial evidence, is sufficient for conviction.
¶ 67, 69, 79–80The appeal was dismissed and the conviction and four-year sentence under Section 376 IPC were affirmed.
¶ 82–83The appellant, on bail, was directed to surrender before the trial court within fifteen days, failing which the trial court may take coercive steps; the remaining sentence is to be undergone with adjustment for any period already served.
¶ 84–86The trial court record and a copy of the order are to be transmitted to the concerned court, and the District and Sessions Judge, Fatehpur, is to be informed by e-mail.
¶ 87–88Original Court PDF
Ram Raj @LalavsState of U.P.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
