01Facts
During a dacoity at the complainant’s home on the night of 21–22 June 1985, two persons were killed and others injured.
¶ 3–10, 14–16The FIR named six or seven unknown offenders; the appellant was later arrested and identified by witnesses at a test identification parade (TIP).
¶ 3–10, 14–16The Sessions Court convicted him under Section 396 IPC and sentenced him to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine.
¶ 3–10, 14–16He appealed, challenging the reliability of his identification and the evidence connecting him to the crime
¶ 3–10, 14–1602Issues
i.Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant was one of the participants in the dacoity, given that he was previously unknown to the witnesses and his identification evidence was disputed
¶ 17, 24–30, 48ii.Whether the alleged arrest and recovery of a country-made pistol, in the absence of looted property or forensic evidence linking the weapon to the incident, provided reliable corroboration of the appellant’s participation
¶ 19–23, 44–45iii.Whether the conviction under Section 396 IPC could be sustained when the prosecution had not reliably established the appellant’s participation in the dacoity
¶ 46–5003Law Applied
Section 396 IPC applies where five or more persons conjointly commit dacoity and murder is committed in the course of that dacoity; the prosecution must prove the accused’s participation in the dacoity, not merely that a murder occurred
¶ 47Under Sections 25 and 26 of the Evidence Act, a confession to a police officer is inadmissible, subject to the limited discovery exception under Section 27
¶ 18Identification evidence is relevant under Section 9 of the Evidence Act; in-court identification is substantive evidence, while a TIP is investigative and corroborative, intended to test a witness’s capacity to identify a previously unknown person. First-time in-court identification of a stranger is inherently weak and ordinarily calls for corroboration
¶ 29, 32–34 · Malkhansingh v. State of M.P., (2003) 5 SCC 746 · State of H.P. v. Lekh Raj, (2000) 1 SCC 247The court also relied on Iqbal v. State of U.P., (2015) 6 SCC 623, for the need to scrutinise identification in darkness and for connecting evidence in a dacoity case
¶ 40Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 396
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 313Section 162
04Reasoning
The appellant was not named in the FIR and was a stranger to the identifying witnesses. The prosecution did not satisfactorily establish the sources, location, or adequacy of the alleged torch and electric lighting; the torch was not produced, and the alleged electric source was omitted from the site plan
¶ 24–28, 39The witnesses’ accounts also contained material inconsistencies, while the TIP occurred more than a month after the incident and could not independently cure doubts about their opportunity to identify the appellant
¶ 35–43, 49No looted property was recovered, and the pistol recovery was unsupported by independent corroboration or forensic evidence linking it to the crime
¶ 19–23, 44–45Considered cumulatively, these deficiencies left reasonable doubt about the appellant’s identity and participation
¶ 48–5005Holding
The High Court held that the prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant participated in the dacoity and that his conviction under Section 396 IPC could not stand.
¶ 50–55It allowed the appeal, set aside the conviction and sentence, and acquitted the appellant by extending the benefit of doubt. The Court directed his release forthwith if he was not required in another case and discharged and cancelled any bail bonds and sureties
¶ 50–55Original Court PDF
RohtashvsState Of U.P.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
