01Facts
On 18.02.1994 at about 5:35 p.m., near the madarsa gate in Mohalla Jafrabad, the complainant Dilshad Hussain (PW-2) was with Gulfam Haider (PW-4), the appellant Nazar Abbas, and others, awaiting his brothers Hasan Abbas and Ali Abbas, who had gone to their brick kiln
¶ 4A tractor-trolley of bricks, parked in front of the appellant's house, obstructed the passage. When Hasan and Ali arrived on a motorcycle and asked for it to be moved, the appellant abused them, refused until the bricks were unloaded, and stabbed Hasan; when Ali intervened, the appellant stabbed him too
¶ 5Hasan died at the spot
¶ 5, 19The written report was lodged at 6:40 p.m. and Case Crime No. 33 of 1994 under Sections 302/307 IPC was registered at P.S. Jalalpur
¶ 5-6On 19.02.1994 the appellant was arrested and a knife was allegedly recovered, leading to Case Crime No. 35 of 1994 under Section 4/25 Arms Act
¶ 9The appellant was medically examined on 21.02.1994 and found to have 18 simple injuries; the defence medical witness (DW-1) gave conflicting estimates of their age
¶ 10, 27, 48The trial court convicted the appellant under Sections 302 and 324 IPC (life imprisonment and Rs. 5,000 fine under Section 302; one year RI under Section 324) and acquitted him under Section 4/25 Arms Act
¶ 2-3, 28The appellant pleaded private defence under Section 313 CrPC, alleging that Hasan had attacked him with a knife, which he snatched
¶ 26He appealed under Section 374(2) CrPC
¶ 202Issues
i.1. Whether the death of Hasan Abbas was homicidal and whether Ali Abbas's injuries were genuine and consistent with the prosecution case.
¶ 33-34ii.2. Whether the FIR was lodged after an unexplained delay, so as to render the prosecution version suspicious.
¶ 35iii.3. Whether the ocular evidence, particularly of the injured witness Ali Abbas and the other eyewitnesses, reliably establishes that the appellant inflicted the injuries.
¶ 36-41iv.4. Whether the absence of forensic evidence and the failure to examine material witnesses, together with the Arms Act acquittal, undermine the prosecution case.
¶ 41-44v.5. Whether the injuries on the appellant were sustained during the occurrence, so as to invoke the principle in Lakshmi Singh and support the plea of private defence.
¶ 47-50vi.6. Whether the appellant validly exercised the right of private defence under Sections 96-106 IPC.
¶ 51-53vii.7. Whether the offence is culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC, or murder under Section 302 IPC.
¶ 54-56, 58(v)viii.8. Whether the conviction under Section 324 IPC and the sentences are liable to interference.
¶ 57, 59-6003Law Applied
Section 302 IPC (murder) read with Section 300 Thirdly, which requires an act done with intention of causing bodily injury that is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, and the Virsa Singh principles on that test
¶ 56-57Section 324 IPC for voluntarily causing hurt by a dangerous weapon
¶ 57Sections 96-106 and 99 IPC on private defence, which is preventive, requires a reasonable apprehension of death or grievous hurt, and bars harm beyond what is necessary, with the burden discharged on a preponderance of probabilities under Section 105 of the Evidence Act, following Darshan Singh v. State of Punjab
¶ 51Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC (sudden fight, heat of passion, no undue advantage or cruelty) and Exception 1 (grave and sudden provocation), with the Explanation that the party giving provocation or striking first is immaterial
¶ 54-55On ocular evidence, the rule that an injured witness's testimony carries special weight, as held in Abdul Sayeed v. State of M.P., and that witnesses partly reliable require corroboration in material particulars, as held in Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras
¶ 36The principle on chance witnesses from Ravi Mandal v. State of Uttarakhand
¶ 40Sections 134 and 114 Illustration (g) of the Evidence Act on non-examination of witnesses
¶ 41Sections 25-27 of the Evidence Act, with Pulukuri Kottaya v. Emperor, to exclude the custodial admission and recovery
¶ 42Lakshmi Singh v. State of Bihar on unexplained injuries on the accused
¶ 47State of A.P. v. Rayavarapu Punnayya on inferring intention from weapon, body part, force and number of blows
¶ 56Provisions in the judgment · 22 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 207Section 313Section 374Section 428
Indian Penal Code, 1860 16 provisions
Section 96Section 97Section 98Section 99Section 100Section 101Section 102Section 103Section 104Section 105Section 106Section 300Section 302Section 304Section 307Section 324Arms Act, 1959 Section 4Section 25
04Reasoning
The Court held the death homicidal, based on the post-mortem findings of penetrating chest wounds damaging the heart and lung
¶ 33It found the FIR lodged within a reasonable time (1 hour 5 minutes), given the 1.25 km distance and the family's circumstances
¶ 35It accepted Ali Abbas (PW-3) as a reliable injured witness, because his injuries (examined within hours) corroborated his presence, and his account was consistent on material particulars
¶ 36-37His failure to see the first blow, or his fall into a drain, did not discredit his account of the preceding assault
¶ 37The Court found a discrepancy in the wound distribution (two wounds on Hasan's back, while PW-3 said all blows were from the front) but held that it did not rule out the account, since movement or struggle was possible
¶ 38It rejected PW-2 as an eyewitness to the stabbing because of material variations in his accounts, but relied on him for the antecedent events and the FIR
¶ 39PW-4 was accepted as a non-chance witness, but only for the continuation of the assault and the flight
¶ 40The non-examination of Lallan Verma and others was treated as an unexplained omission warranting caution, but not as fatal to PW-3's cogent testimony
¶ 41The recovery was excluded, so the absence of a forensic report was not fatal, since the case rested on direct evidence; the investigative lapse was noted but not treated as corroboration
¶ 42-43The Arms Act acquittal did not establish fabrication, since the charges had different ingredients and the eyewitnesses did not speak to the recovery
¶ 44The Court held that a single knife-wielding assailant could have injured both brothers, and that the appellant's own plea of snatching the knife concedes his use of it
¶ 45-46On Lakshmi Singh, the Court held that the appellant's 18 injuries were not shown to have occurred during the incident, given DW-1's conflicting estimates and PW-9's testimony that they were caused at arrest
¶ 47-49Even assuming they occurred during the incident, they were simple contusions and abrasions, which did not support the plea
¶ 50On private defence, the Court found no reasonable apprehension of death or grievous hurt, no evidence that the brothers were armed, use of four incised wounds including chest penetration, and a pursuit of PW-3 after the threat had ended
¶ 52On Exception 4, the Court held that there was no mutual exchange of blows, that the appellant had used abusive language first, that the knife was used against an unarmed man targeting vital parts, and that PW-3 was attacked after Hasan fell, so the appellant took undue advantage and acted cruelly
¶ 55Intention was inferred from the depth and location of the wounds, which were sufficient in the ordinary course to cause death, bringing the case within Section 300 Thirdly
¶ 56The Section 324 conviction stood on PW-3's testimony and the medical evidence, and a one-year sentence was held not excessive
¶ 57The death sentence was not possible under the sentencing rule, so life imprisonment was upheld
¶ 5905Holding
The death was homicidal, and the prosecution proved, through the injured eyewitness PW-3 corroborated by medical evidence and PW-4, that the appellant inflicted the injuries
¶ 58(i)-(ii)The absence of forensic evidence and the Arms Act acquittal did not undermine the prosecution case
¶ 58(iii)The private defence plea was not established on a preponderance of probabilities
¶ 52-53, 58(iv)Exception 4 was not satisfied, and the offence is murder under Section 302 IPC, with no ground to alter it to Section 304 IPC
¶ 58(v)The Section 324 conviction is upheld
¶ 57, 58(vi)The conviction under Sections 302 and 324 IPC, the life sentence, the Rs. 5,000 fine with six months' default RI, and the concurrent one-year RI under Section 324 were affirmed. The Court dismissed the appeal.
¶ 60-61The appellant's bail bonds were cancelled and he was directed to surrender before the trial court, with set-off under Section 428 CrPC
¶ 62-63The Arms Act acquittal in Sessions Trial No. 211 of 1994 was not disturbed
¶ 64The trial court record is to be returned forthwith
¶ 65Original Court PDF
Nazar AbbasvsState Of U.P.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
