01Facts
The accused, a JBT teacher at Government Primary School, Kummi, was prosecuted under s. 376 IPC, s. 3(1)(xii) (read as s. 3(2) in the FIR) of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, and s. 67 of the IT Act, 2000.
¶ 2The prosecutrix ('G', PW-1), a member of the Scheduled Caste (Lohar) and a variety-store operator, alleged forcible intercourse between 2004 and 2006 at the accused's house in Dadour and at Room No. 204, Hotel Shringar, Sauli-Khad.
¶ 3(a)–(b)The prosecutrix further alleged that the accused recorded the acts without consent and circulated them electronically in 2008.
¶ 3(c)FIR No. 310 of 2008 was registered on 16.09.2008 at P.S. Balh, and the accused was arrested on 20.09.2008.
¶ 3(c)The prosecutrix was major (aged 25) at the relevant time, and the parties were acquainted before the alleged incidents.
¶ 40The medical officer (PW-2, Dr. Richa) opined that the prosecutrix was an adult, sexually active female, habitual to intercourse, and that no physical evidence could confirm or negate forced assault during 2004–2006.
¶ 37The Special Judge, Mandi, acquitted the accused on 28.03.2013 in Sessions Trial No. 47 of 2009.
¶ 1, 4The State filed the present appeal.
¶ 502Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution proved that the sexual relationship between the accused and the prosecutrix was without her consent and amounted to "rape" under s. 375 (Clause Secondly) read with s. 90 IPC.
¶ 18 · ¶ 20, 40–42ii.2. Whether the offence under s. 3(1)(xii) of the SC/ST Act, 1989 was made out, i.e., whether the offence was committed on the ground of the victim's caste membership.
¶ 44–47iii.3. Whether the offence under s. 67 of the IT Act, 2000 was established, having regard to the requirements of s. 65B of the Indian Evidence Act.
¶ 49–60iv.4. Whether the trial court's acquittal is perverse or otherwise warrants interference in appeal.
¶ 11–16, 6103Law Applied
The court applied s. 375 IPC (Clause Secondly, i.e., lack of consent) read with s. 90 IPC, holding that consent obtained under fear or misconception is not valid consent, and that the Thirdly, Fourthly and Fifthly clauses inform the meaning of "misconception of fact".
¶ 19–20The court applied s. 3(1)(xii) SC/ST Act, under which the offence requires that the act be committed on the ground of the victim's SC/ST status, with reference to Khuman Singh, Dinesh @ Buddha and Patan Jamal Vali.
¶ 45–48The court applied s. 67 IT Act and s. 65B Evidence Act, relying on Anvar P.V. and Arjun Panditrao Khotkar that secondary electronic evidence requires a s. 65B(4) certificate.
¶ 52–58On appellate powers, the court followed Sheo Swarup, Tulsiram Kanu, Balbir Singh, M.G. Agarwal, Muralidhar, Rajesh Prasad, H.D. Sundara, Jafarudheen, Geeta Devi and Surendra Singh, under which an acquittal is not disturbed where the trial court's view is a possible one or the judgment is not perverse.
¶ 12–16On the prosecutrix's testimony, the court relied on Mohd. Imran Khan, Chandraprakash Kewalchand Jain, Pappu, Gurmit Singh, Raghubir Singh, Ved Parkash, Aman Kumar and Narender Kumar, under which a sole, reliable and confidence-inspiring testimony may suffice, but the court may seek corroboration where it hesitates to accept the testimony at face value, and the prosecution must prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.
¶ 17, 23–33Santosh Prasad was cited for the proposition that sole testimony is not gospel truth without supporting evidence.
¶ 43Provisions in the judgment · 5 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 376Section 375Section 90
Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 Section 3
Information Technology Act, 2000 Section 67
04Reasoning
The court held that the prosecutrix's account lacked specificity regarding the intervening incidents and the Hotel Shringar episode, and no hotel record was produced.
¶ 22The medical evidence did not corroborate forced intercourse.
¶ 37–38Treating the relationship as consensual, the court found no material showing consent was obtained by misconception or threat to life.
¶ 40The court discounted the prosecutrix's claim of non-consent on the first occasion, reasoning that she continued the relationship voluntarily, had a clear choice to refuse and to complain, and gave no reasonable explanation for not approaching the police earlier.
¶ 41On that basis, the court held her evidence did not inspire confidence.
¶ 42On the SC/ST Act, the court held that caste membership was undisputed but no evidence showed the act was committed because of caste, so s. 3(1)(xii) was not established.
¶ 44, 46–47On s. 67, the explicit material was never produced; the VCD never formed part of the trial record, and no s. 65B certificate was shown, so the electronic evidence could not be proved.
¶ 58, 60On appeal, the court found the trial court's view to be a possible one on the record. Since the trial court's appreciation was neither perverse nor unreasonable, the appellate court declined to interfere.
¶ 15–16, 6105Holding
The court held that the allegations of rape, caste-based offence under s. 3(1)(xii) SC/ST Act, and s. 67 IT Act were not established beyond reasonable doubt on the record.
¶ 61The trial court's acquittal was not perverse and two views were possible, so no interference was warranted.
¶ 15–16, 61The appeal was dismissed and the acquittal of Harish Kumar was upheld.
¶ 62Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, were disposed of.
¶ 63Original Court PDF
STATE OF HPvsHARISH KUMAR
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
