Himachal Pradesh High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

Police Cannot Investigate Defamation by Adding Other Charges, HP High Court Quashes AI-Video FIR

SURESH KUMAR AND ANOTHERv.STATE OF HP AND ANOTHER

Police Cannot Investigate Defamation by Adding Other Charges, HP High Court Quashes AI-Video FIR. SURESH KUMAR AND ANOTHER vs STATE OF HP AND ANOTHER. Himachal Pradesh High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the allegations in the FIR disclose the offence of forgery under Section 336(4) BNS, so as to justify police investigation.

The court held

The Court held that the FIR does not disclose the commission of any cognizable offence and that its registration for offences under Sections 351(2), 356(2) and 336(4) BNS, used to investigate a private defamation dispute, is impermissible.

It also directed

The petition was allowed. FIR No. 178 of 2026, dated 02.09.2026, registered at Police Station Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur, and all consequential proceedings arising from it were quashed. The petition was disposed of, with pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also disposed of. Parties were permitted to produce a downloaded copy of the judgment before the authorities, which may verify the order on the High Court website.

01Facts

The informant lodged a complaint alleging that he and his family were defamed on Facebook through an AI-generated video claiming that he was publicising a "Our Family, a Happy Family" scheme and had made his wife, nephew, relatives and friends its beneficiaries. The complaint further alleged AI-generated photographs showing him collecting and running away with money, and false claims that his sister-in-law had been given government employment and his brother made a Director.

¶ 2

On this basis, FIR No. 178 of 2026 (dated 02.09.2026) was registered at Police Station Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur, under Sections 351(2), 356(2) and 336(4) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).

¶ 2

The petitioners contended that the dispute was a private defamation matter, that cognizance of defamation requires a private complaint under Section 222 of the BNSS, and that the FIR was motivated by political rivalry.

¶ 3

The State's status report stated that the petitioners' phones were seized, the pen drive containing the AI material was sent to SFSL, and Facebook was asked to identify the account holder. It also stated that Section 351(2) had been dropped, Section 353(1)(b) added, and that Section 356(2) is non-cognizable.

¶ 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether the allegations in the FIR disclose the offence of forgery under Section 336(4) BNS, so as to justify police investigation.

¶ 13, 16–17

ii.2. Whether the allegations disclose the offence under Section 353(1)(b) BNS (statements causing fear or alarm to the public).

¶ 18–19

iii.3. Whether the police can investigate the non-cognizable offence of defamation under Section 356(2) BNS, even when other sections are added.

¶ 20–23

iv.4. Whether the FIR is an abuse of the legal process warranting quashing under the principles in Bhajan Lal.

¶ 9–12, 24–25

03Law Applied

The Court applied the State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal categories, as restated in B.N. John and Ajay Malik, under which an FIR may be quashed where the allegations, taken at face value, disclose no offence; where only a non-cognizable offence is made out without a Magistrate's order under Section 155(2) CrPC; where a specific legal bar exists; or where the proceeding is mala fide or an abuse of process.

¶ 9–10

Forgery under Section 336(4) BNS (Section 469 IPC) requires a "false document" as defined in Section 464 IPC, meaning that a document must be made or executed by a person falsely claiming to be another or authorised by another, altered without lawful authority, or obtained by deception or from a person of unsound mind; both definitions are read together, as explained in Mohammed Ibrahim, Mir Nagvi Askari, Sheila Sebastian and Bandekar Bros.

¶ 13–17

Section 353(1)(b) BNS (Section 505 IPC) requires statements made or circulated with intent to, or likely to, cause fear or alarm to the public or a section of the public inducing an offence against the State or public tranquillity, as explained in Kedar Nath Singh.

¶ 18

Defamation under Section 356(2) BNS is non-cognizable, and Section 222 BNSS bars cognizance except on a private complaint before a competent Magistrate. Police cannot investigate non-cognizable offences without a Magistrate's order, and the registration of an FIR for unmade-out cognizable offences as a subterfuge to investigate a private, non-cognizable dispute is impermissible, as held in Niranjana, Om Prakash Ambadkar and P.C. Mohan.

¶ 3, 20–24

Provisions in the judgment · 24 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 Section 351Section 356Section 336Section 353

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 222

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 156Section 155Section 199

Indian Penal Code, 1860 15 provisionsSection 469Section 467Section 471Section 470Section 463Section 464Section 465Section 505Section 500Section 177Section 181Section 191Section 193Section 199Section 200

04Reasoning

On forgery, the Court held that the FIR did not allege that the AI videos or photographs were attributed to a person who did not make them, altered after creation without authority, or executed through a person lacking understanding. The mere falsity of content, as alleged by the informant, does not make the material a "false document" in law, so Section 336(4) was not made out.

¶ 17

On Section 353(1)(b), the Court found no explanation in the FIR or status report of how the allegations about the informant's family benefits or the photographs would cause fear or alarm to the public or any section of it, and no averment that any person was induced to offend against the State or public tranquillity.

¶ 19

Regarding defamation, the Court accepted that Section 356(2) is non-cognizable and that Section 222 BNSS requires a private complaint. Adding cognizable sections does not confer jurisdiction on the police to investigate a private defamation dispute.

¶ 20, 23

Because the cognizable offences were not made out on the FIR's face, their registration was a subterfuge to investigate a non-cognizable private dispute, which the legislature did not intend to permit.

¶ 24

The Court's reasoning rests on the FIR's allegations as they stand. It did not decide the veracity of the AI material, the political motive, or the State's contention that the videos may spread hatred.

¶ 7, 19–24

05Holding

The Court held that the FIR does not disclose the commission of any cognizable offence and that its registration for offences under Sections 351(2), 356(2) and 336(4) BNS, used to investigate a private defamation dispute, is impermissible.

¶ 24

The petition was allowed. FIR No. 178 of 2026, dated 02.09.2026, registered at Police Station Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur, and all consequential proceedings arising from it were quashed. The petition was disposed of, with pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also disposed of. Parties were permitted to produce a downloaded copy of the judgment before the authorities, which may verify the order on the High Court website.

¶ 25–27
Himachal Pradesh High Court

Original Court PDF

SURESH KUMAR AND ANOTHERvsSTATE OF HP AND ANOTHER

Himachal Pradesh High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment