01Facts
The Airports Authority of India (AAI) recommended expanding Kangra (Gaggal) Airport's runway to 3010 m in two phases: Phase I for ATR-72/Q-400 and Phase II for A-320 aircraft.
¶ 9The State decided to acquire land for the full plan in one phase.
¶ 10The Ministry of Civil Aviation's safety committee listed Kangra among nine airports needing additional safety measures, and AAI sought land near Runway End 33 for a Runway End Safety Area.
¶ 12–13A Social Impact Assessment (SIA) was carried out by SR Asia under the Himachal Pradesh SIA Rules, 2015, following a Section 4 notification dated 28.02.2023.
¶ 20–24The SIA report, dated 03.05.2023, recommended acquisition but also proposed alternatives, namely a north-westward expansion and greenfield sites at Lanj and Bodkwalu.
¶ 25A Multi-Disciplinary Expert Group under Section 7 found the project served public purpose, that its benefits outweighed social costs, and that no less displacing option existed.
¶ 26–27A Section 11(1) preliminary notification issued on 07.07.2023.
¶ 28The Techno-Economic Feasibility Report (TEFR) was then found deficient, and AAI sought re-examination and a second technical opinion.
¶ 30–31, 33The Court's interim orders of 06.12.2023, 07.12.2023, 26.12.2023 and 09.01.2024 restrained dispossession, demolition and R&R steps.
¶ 34–37The Supreme Court vacated the 09.01.2024 order on 07.03.2024 on the State's undertaking, with liberty to proceed on merits.
¶ 38–39Acquisition continued during pendency: Section 15 objections were heard, the R&R scheme was approved, a Section 19 declaration issued on 16.08.2024, and awards worth over ₹460 crore were disbursed.
¶ 41–46The petitioner alleged defective SIA methodology, violation of LARR Act ss. 4, 5, 7, 10, 15 and 99, lack of environmental and forest clearances, colourable exercise of power, and violation of Arts. 14, 21 and 300-A.
¶ 47–70The State and AAI contended that the petition was not maintainable, the petitioner lacked locus, and that the acquisition complied with the Act.
¶ 72–106, 116–122The Deputy Solicitor General and NHAI raised locus and non-joinder objections.
¶ 123–135The petitioner Committee was found to be an unregistered body with no resolution authorising it to sue, and the only Gram Panchayat resolution was defective.
¶ 145–15802Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioner, an unregistered "Committee," is competent to file and maintain the writ petition under Article 226, given that it is not a juristic person, lacks a proper authorisation, and is not an aggrieved person or a public interest petitioner.
¶ 143–160ii.2. Whether the acquisition process violated mandatory provisions of the LARR Act, 2013 and the SIA Rules, 2015, including the SIA study, public hearing, Section 7 composition of the Expert Group, Section 10 (irrigated multi-cropped land) and Section 15, and the bar on change of purpose under Section 99.
¶ 161–175, 183iii.3. Whether the project lacks genuine public purpose, and whether alternative sites and less displacing options were arbitrarily rejected.
¶ 167–174iv.4. Whether the acquisition is invalid for want of prior environmental clearance, TEFR, forest clearance or DGCA approval.
¶ 186–187, 191–193v.5. Whether the acquisition violates Articles 14 and 21 by depriving affected persons of livelihood and residence.
¶ 184–18503Law Applied
Article 226 relief is available only to an aggrieved person, a person acting on behalf of one incapable of approaching the court, or a petitioner in public interest, and an unregistered association is not a juristic person and cannot sue in its own name.
¶ 157–159LARR Act, 2013 framework: Section 4 (SIA), Section 7 (Expert Group), Section 10 (protection of irrigated multi-cropped land, which may be acquired only as a last resort), Section 11 (preliminary notification), Section 15 (objections), and Section 99 (no change of purpose).
¶ 49, 66–67, 163–167, 175, 183EIA Notification dated 14.09.2006, para. 2, which exempts "securing the land" from the requirement of prior environmental clearance.
¶ 110–111, 187Courts cannot substitute their view on project feasibility for that of expert bodies, following Vivek Sharma v. Union of India, 2022 (1) HLR 575.
¶ 114, 170Loss of livelihood does not by itself halt a necessary public acquisition, following Estate Officer, HUDA v. Nirmala Devi, 2025 INSC 843.
¶ 113, 184–185Acquisition is not defeated merely by the petitioner's objections, as relied on by the State from Kolkata Municipal Corporation v. Bimal Kumar Shah, AIR 2024 SC 2819.
¶ 111, 115Non-joinder principle: challenges to SIA methodology must be made against the agency and the Expert Group, who are necessary parties.
¶ 166Provisions in the judgment · 20 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 19 provisions
Section 3Section 4Section 5Section 7Section 8Section 10Section 11Section 15Section 16Section 17Section 19Section 21Section 23Section 30Section 31Section 38Section 43Section 45Section 99Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980 Section 2
04Reasoning
No Committee resolution, registration, constitution or memorandum was produced, and the only Panchayat resolution (Gram Panchayat Nandehar) authorised named office-bearers, not the Committee, and named the President differently from the memo of parties.
¶ 145–153Since the Committee owned no land and was not a juristic person, and the petition was not framed as a PIL, the Court found no legal injury or public interest standing.
¶ 157–158The petitioner was in substance a self-styled group of four persons pursuing personal interests.
¶ 158Despite this finding, the Court addressed the merits "for completeness"; pre-notification SIA site visits on 27–28.02.2023 showed no violation, because the record did not establish such visits and the petitioner showed no prejudice, and the non-joinder of SR Asia and the Expert Group was treated as fatal to challenges to their methodology and competence.
¶ 161–166The Lanj and Bodkwalu sites were not expansions of an existing airport but a new airport, which was outside the scope of the Centre-approved expansion plan, and AAI's technical reasons for rejecting the north-west reorientation, namely river bridges, operational disruption and cost, were accepted.
¶ 167–172Public purpose was established because the expansion benefits the travelling public, tourism and defence operations, and the IAF's 2018 letter did not negate the strategic use shown by 2019 and 2023 records.
¶ 173–180Under s. 10 of the LARR Act, the adjacency requirement left no alternative to acquiring the adjacent land, so the exceptional-circumstances test was met.
¶ 175On seismic and environmental objections, the airport already operates and expansion of an existing facility cannot be barred on seismic grounds.
¶ 182Individual loss of livelihood must yield to the larger public interest under Articles 14 and 21.
¶ 184–185, 190Acquisition is "securing the land" under the 2006 EIA Notification and so does not require prior environmental clearance, although public money of thousands of crores is at stake and a public authority cannot safely acquire land before the TEFR and clearances are in place.
¶ 187, 191–19205Holding
The petitioner-Committee lacks competence and locus standi, and the petition is liable to be dismissed on that ground alone.
¶ 160On merits, the Court found "no ground for interference" with the acquisition at this stage, and held the SIA, the Expert Group's appraisal, the alternatives analysis, public purpose, the s. 10 challenge, and the Article 14/21 challenges all unsustainable.
¶ 161–190Prior clearance was not held necessary for acquisition, but the clearances were made a pre-condition for execution.
¶ 187, 191–192The State is directed to complete the TEFR at the earliest and obtain environmental clearance under the 2006 EIA Notification without waiting for completion of acquisition, and to ensure all clearances for timely completion of the expansion.
¶ 192–193The writ petition was disposed of, along with all pending applications.
¶ 194Original Court PDF
GAGGAL AIRPORT EXPANSION AFFECTED SOCIAL WELFARE COMMITTEEvsTHE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY (TOURISM AND CA) AND OTHERS
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
