01Facts
The Respondent (Raymonds) operates factories, divisions, subsidiaries, and a school at Panchpakhadi, Thane, collectively the "said structures".
¶ 4The Petitioner Municipal Corporation revised the assessment books for 1984-85 through 1987-88.
¶ 5Before fixing the Rateable Value (RV) for 1987-88, the Corporation served a special notice of proposed RV on 13.04.1987. The Respondent objected on 24.04.1987 and appeared through counsel before the Deputy Municipal Commissioner.
¶ 18The Deputy Commissioner rejected the objections on 19.06.1987.
¶ 7The Respondent's appeals under Section 406 of the BPMC Act were allowed by the Trial Court on 22.12.1989, which set aside the assessments for 1987-88 and 1988-89.
¶ 1, 7The First Appellate Court dismissed the Corporation's appeals on 29.01.2000.
¶ 1, 8The writ petition was admitted on 13.03.2001 without interim relief.
¶ 9The Corporation's case is that it adopted a "hypothetical rent" for the area, as a reasonable letting value under Rule 7(1), and then multiplied it by the carpet area.
¶ 10.1, 17The Respondent contended that the Corporation applied a flat per-square-foot rate, did not determine standard rent, gave no reasons, and that the structures had not materially changed.
¶ 11.4-11.12Both lower courts had found the enhancement illegal.
¶ 11.102Issues
i.1. Whether the Corporation's RV, computed as hypothetical rent multiplied by carpet area, constitutes an impermissible flat-rate/area-wise method.
¶ 17, 23, 26-27ii.2. Whether the burden of proving that the proposed RV is excessive or exorbitant lies on the assessee where the Corporation has disclosed its basis.
¶ 19.5, 20, 24-25iii.3. Whether the assessee was obliged under Rule 5 to notify additional new area for assessment.
¶ 15iv.4. Whether the Corporation was obliged to fix standard rent before determining RV.
¶ 22v.5. Whether the impugned judgments are perverse, warranting interference under Articles 226 and 227, and whether remand is warranted.
¶ 30-3103Law Applied
Rule 7(1) of Chapter VIII of the BPMC Taxation Rules deducts 10% from the annual rent "for which such land or building might reasonably be expected to let from year to year" to fix RV.
¶ 13Rule 5 requires the owner to give notice within fifteen days of the erection, enlargement, or change of user of a building.
¶ 13-14Rule 8 empowers the Commissioner to call for information and imposes a duty of true disclosure only when so requisitioned.
¶ 13, 15In Dewan Daulat Rai Kapoor v. NDMC, (1980) 1 SCC 685, an assessing authority may arrive at its own estimate of standard rent for determining annual value without usurping the Controller's function.
¶ 27In New Manek Chowk Spg. Wvg. Mills v. Municipal Corporation, Ahmedabad, AIR 1967 SC 1801, the flat-rate method is deprecated.
¶ 26On burden of proof, PMC v. Vimal Joshi (Bom. HC, 29.04.2015) and later Bombay High Court decisions hold that the assessee must lead evidence and show the RV is excessive, and that a challenger must show procedural violation and prejudice.
¶ 19.1-19.5Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution confer supervisory jurisdiction on the High Court.
¶ 2, 31Provisions in the judgment · 2
Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations Act, 1949 Section 406Section 411
04Reasoning
The lower courts misread the Corporation's case. The written statement and evidence showed that the Corporation assumed a hypothetical rent as the basis and then applied areas as multipliers.
¶ 17, 26-27That is the method contemplated by Rule 7(1), and it is not a flat-rate method simpliciter.
¶ 17, 26-27The Appellate Court's reliance on New Manek Chowk was misplaced because it ignored that the hypothetical-rent basis had been pleaded and was not addressed.
¶ 26Because the Corporation disclosed its basis, the burden shifted to the Respondent to show that the hypothetical rent was excessive. The Respondent led no evidence before the Deputy Commissioner or the Trial Court on standard rent or comparable letting values.
¶ 20-21, 24It was not the Corporation's duty to fix standard rent, since it is neither owner nor tenant. That duty lay with the owner, who could have sought fixation or produced material.
¶ 22The Respondent had a statutory duty to notify additional area under Rule 5, while Rule 8 creates a duty only when the Commissioner calls for information.
¶ 15The argument that no change had occurred since the structures were old was rejected, as the Respondent had to show the proposed RV was excessive. The Appellate Court's finding that none of the premises was let out did not address the burden of proof.
¶ 25The Court declined remand because the assessment years, 1987-88 and 1988-89, were nearly forty years old, and decided the matter on merits.
¶ 30The deposit issue under the Appellate Court's reasoning was not before the Court and was not decided.
¶ 2805Holding
The Trial Court and Appellate Court judgments were perverse because they proceeded on an incorrect understanding of the burden of proof and ignored the hypothetical-rent basis.
¶ 31The Corporation's method was not a flat-rate method, and the burden of proving the RV was excessive lay on the Respondent.
¶ 23, 29The writ petitions were allowed. The Appellate Court judgment dated 29.01.2000 and the Trial Court judgment dated 22.12.1989 were set aside, and the appeals before the Appellate Court were allowed. No order as to costs was made.
¶ 32The Corporation may withdraw the amount deposited by the Respondent, with accrued interest. The Respondent's prayer for a refund or adjustment of property tax paid under protest is effectively left unresolved, since the Court granted liberty to withdraw the deposit only.
¶ 32The holding is confined to the RV for the concerned assessment years and does not affect later years.
¶ 33Original Court PDF
The Municipal Corporation Of ThanevsThe Raymonds Woollen Mills Ltd.,
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
