Jammu and Kashmir High CourtCriminal LawCriminal Procedure and Evidence

Awarding a contract without tenders to confer pecuniary advantage on a third party prima facie constitutes criminal misconduct under Section 5(1)(d)

ASHOK KUMAR GANDOTRA AND OTHERSv.UT OF J AND K TH INCHARGE POLICE STATION ANTI CORRUPTION BUREAU JAMMU

Awarding a contract without tenders to confer pecuniary advantage on a third party prima facie constitutes criminal misconduct under Section 5(1)(d). ASHOK KUMAR GANDOTRA AND OTHERS vs UT OF J AND K TH INCHARGE POLICE STATION ANTI CORRUPTION BUREAU JAMMU. Jammu and Kashmir High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the High Court, while exercising its power under s. 528 BNSS against an order framing charges, may re-evaluate the rival loss calculations and the applicable CPWD rates.

The court held

The rate dispute and the quantum of loss are matters for trial, and the material, taken at face value, prima facie establishes that the award to Petitioner No. 3 without codal formalities was an abuse of official position.

It also directed

The High Court dismissed the petition and upheld the charge sheet and the order framing charges under s. 5(1)(d) r/w s. 5(2) of the J&K PC Act and s. 120-B RPC against all three petitioners. The trial is to proceed; no separate relief was granted.

01Facts

The petitioners challenged a charge sheet arising from FIR No. 10 of 2020, registered by the Anti-Corruption Bureau, Jammu, under s. 5(1)(d) r/w s. 5(2) of the J&K Prevention of Corruption Act, 2006 and s. 120-B RPC, and the trial court's order framing charges.

¶ 1

Petitioner No. 2 was Vice Chairman, JDA; Petitioner No. 1 was Executive Engineer, JDA; Petitioner No. 3 was a contracting firm.

¶ 2

Tenders were floated for installation of ten two-ton ACs and allied electrical works. M/s Lumen Engineers was L1. Instead of awarding the work to L1, the tender was cancelled on 08.04.2011 on verbal directions of Petitioner No. 2.

¶ 3

The scope was then enlarged to renovation/interior works, and the work (Rs. 40.83 lakh) was awarded to Petitioner No. 3 without tenders, at J&K Bank's Shalimar Branch rates, under an agreement dated 03.06.2011.

¶ 2–3

The investigating agency's Engineering Wing assessed a net loss of Rs. 1,46,828/- after spot inspection and a deduction of Rs. 9,600/-.

¶ 4

The petitioners contend that no loss occurred, since the CPWD 2010 Analysis of Rates (a reprint of 2007 rates) was wrongly used instead of the 2012 rates, and the labour component for floor tiling was omitted.

¶ 7–9

The petitioners further argue that the specialised nature of the work justified nomination, and that at most departmental action, not prosecution, was warranted.

¶ 7–9

The respondent maintains that the loss computation is sound and that the rate issue is a matter for trial.

¶ 10–11

The date of the trial court's framing order is stated inconsistently in the judgment: 29.03.2025 at para. 6 and 09.04.2025 at para. 1.

¶ 6 · ¶ 1

02Issues

i.1. Whether the High Court, while exercising its power under s. 528 BNSS against an order framing charges, may re-evaluate the rival loss calculations and the applicable CPWD rates.

¶ 17 · ¶ 24

ii.2. Whether the award of contract without tendering, after cancelling a completed tender process, prima facie attracts s. 5(1)(d) of the J&K PC Act despite the petitioners' claim of no pecuniary loss to the State.

¶ 18–22, 26

03Law Applied

Section 251-A of the J&K Cr.P.C. provides that a court discharges an accused only if the charge is groundless, and otherwise frames charges if there is ground for presuming the offence was committed.

¶ 14

In Sajjan Kumar v. CBI, (2010) 9 SCC 368, the court may sift material only to determine a prima facie case, must not conduct a mini-trial, and may discharge only where the suspicion is mere suspicion rather than grave suspicion.

¶ 15

In Amit Kapoor v. Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460, interference with charge framing is limited to cases where the allegations are patently absurd or the basic ingredients are not made out, and examination of external defence material is barred.

¶ 16–17

Section 5(1)(d) of the J&K PC Act criminalises obtaining a pecuniary advantage for any person, including a third party, by abusing public office; loss to the State is not an express element.

¶ 20

In Neera Yadav v. CBI, (2017) 8 SCC 757, interpreting the pari materia s. 13(1)(d) of the Central Act, the three limbs of the provision are disjunctive and nepotism falls within its ambit.

¶ 21

Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482Section 227Section 228Section 397Section 173

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 528

Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 Section 13

04Reasoning

The petitioners' challenge turned on rival rate computations, which can be resolved only after the investigating engineers depose and are cross-examined at trial. The court declined to act as an expert on the applicable rates or to assess the petitioners' own calculations, as this would amount to a mini-trial.

¶ 23–25

The work was not so specialised that only Petitioner No. 3 could execute it, since any licensed and experienced contractor could do renovation and AC installation. Petitioners 1 and 2, as public servants, were therefore under a legal duty to seek open competition, and their nomination of a single firm prima facie reflected abuse of position and favouritism.

¶ 19

Because the tender was cancelled after the L1 process was complete and the work was then awarded to a favoured third party, a dishonest intention to confer undue benefit could be inferred at the charge stage.

¶ 22

Applying the Neera Yadav principle that a pecuniary advantage to a third party suffices, the existence of a quantified loss, although disputed, was not needed to defeat the charge at this stage.

¶ 20–21, 26

05Holding

The rate dispute and the quantum of loss are matters for trial, and the material, taken at face value, prima facie establishes that the award to Petitioner No. 3 without codal formalities was an abuse of official position.

¶ 24–26

The High Court dismissed the petition and upheld the charge sheet and the order framing charges under s. 5(1)(d) r/w s. 5(2) of the J&K PC Act and s. 120-B RPC against all three petitioners. The trial is to proceed; no separate relief was granted.

¶ 26–27
Jammu and Kashmir High Court

Original Court PDF

ASHOK KUMAR GANDOTRA AND OTHERSvsUT OF J AND K TH INCHARGE POLICE STATION ANTI CORRUPTION BUREAU JAMMU

Jammu and Kashmir High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment