Jammu and Kashmir High CourtConstitutional LawEmployment and Labour Law

Service disputes with a non-State BSF school are not amenable to writ jurisdiction absent statutory service conditions.

SONI RAM DHAKAv.U.O.I.MIN.OF HOME AND AFFAIRS

Service disputes with a non-State BSF school are not amenable to writ jurisdiction absent statutory service conditions.. SONI RAM DHAKA vs U.O.I.MIN.OF HOME AND AFFAIRS. Jammu and Kashmir High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the BSF Senior Secondary School, being run by a registered society, qualifies as "State" under Article 12 of the Constitution so as to be amenable to writ jurisdiction.

The court held

The writ petitions are not maintainable against BSF Senior Secondary School, Paloura, because the school is not a State or instrumentality of the State, and the service grievances concern private law contractual rights with no statutory basis or public law element.

It also directed

Both SWP No. 1477/2014 and SWP No. 2650/2015 are dismissed, with liberty to the petitioners to pursue appropriate remedies, including approaching CBSE or another legal forum as provided under St. Mary's.

01Facts

SWP No. 1477/2014 was filed by Soni Ram Dhaka seeking a direction to adopt service rules conforming to the CBSE affiliation bye-laws and to promote him to the senior and selection scales.

¶ 2

SWP No. 2650/2015 was filed by 42 teaching and non-teaching staff of BSF Senior Secondary School, Paloura, Jammu, seeking pay scales and service benefits at par with Central Government and Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan (KVS) employees, implementation of the 5th and 6th Central Pay Commission recommendations, arrears, and protection from vindictive or indiscriminate transfers.

¶ 3

Petitioners contended that the school is run on the KVS pattern, is affiliated to CBSE, is funded through a BSF society and Government grant-in-aid, and is pervasively controlled by the Union, making it an instrumentality of the State.

¶ 4–5

Petitioners relied on CBSE circulars requiring affiliated schools to pay Government-equivalent scales.

¶ 6

The respondent school, run by the BSF Education Fund Society, a registered society, objected to maintainability, asserting that it is not a State under Article 12, receives no grant-in-aid, is financed by voluntary BSF contributions and student fees, and is audited by a Chartered Accountant.

¶ 8, 17

On merits, the respondent school stated that pay is governed by the BSF Education Code and that employees accepted their appointment terms.

¶ 9

The Court had admitted both petitions but deferred maintainability to final hearing, noting reliance on Santosh Kak (SWP No. 1819/2014), which had held a writ maintainable, and the Division Bench's disposal of LPASW No. 76/2015 on 18.11.2025 with the issue left open.

¶ 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the BSF Senior Secondary School, being run by a registered society, qualifies as "State" under Article 12 of the Constitution so as to be amenable to writ jurisdiction.

¶ 14, 17

ii.2. Whether a writ petition under Article 226 is maintainable against a non-State school in respect of service and pay disputes that are not governed by statutory provisions and lack a public law element.

¶ 18–22

iii.3. Whether CBSE affiliation bye-laws, which the petitioners invoked for pay parity, have statutory force so as to confer enforceable rights through writ jurisdiction.

¶ 23

03Law Applied

Article 12 of the Constitution, which defines "State," was applied to hold that the respondent school is not a State or instrumentality of the State, relying on the absence of pervasive governmental financial or administrative control.

¶ 17–18

Article 226 permits writs against any person or body performing a public duty, but only where the act complained of has a direct nexus with a public duty or a statutory right is sought.

¶ 17–18

St. Mary's Education Society v. Rajendra Prasad Bhargava (2023) 4 SCC 498 holds that service disputes arising from contracts without statutory governance are not amenable to Article 226, even where the institution performs a public function, and that non-teaching and teaching staff must seek remedies elsewhere.

¶ 19(b)–(d)

Army Welfare Education Society v. Sunil Kumar Sharma, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1683, and Dileep Kumar Pandey v. Union of India, 2025 INSC 749, reaffirmed the position in St. Mary's.

¶ 20

CBSE is a society, not a statutory body, and its bye-laws and regulations have no statutory force, so they confer no enforceable right against a school management.

¶ 23–24

Persuasive authorities D.N. Sharma v. Union of India (MP HC, 2025) and Omprakaash Chhabra v. DG, BSF (Raj. HC, 2025) were cited in support.

¶ 17, 25

04Reasoning

The Court first held that the school is not a State. BSF officers sit on the society only ex officio, which does not amount to pervasive control, and the school's funds derive from compulsory deductions from BSF personnel and student fees, with no regular Government grants shown on record.

¶ 17

Having found that the school is not a State, the Court considered whether a public law element existed. It held that the petitioners' demand for pay parity with KVS and Central Government staff was a private contractual matter, and that even assuming the school performs a public duty of education, the grievance lacked a direct nexus with that duty.

¶ 22

The CBSE bye-laws relied upon were non-statutory, so the petitioners could not enforce them as statutory rights.

¶ 23

The Court relied on St. Mary's to hold that the appropriate remedy for a service-contract violation of affiliation bye-laws lies before CBSE or another legal forum, not under Article 226.

¶ 24

The Court did not separately analyse Santosh Kak, and its reasoning rests instead on binding Supreme Court authority and consistent High Court views.

¶ 13, 25

The merits, including pay scales, arrears, promotions, and transfers, were therefore not examined.

¶ 9–11

05Holding

The writ petitions are not maintainable against BSF Senior Secondary School, Paloura, because the school is not a State or instrumentality of the State, and the service grievances concern private law contractual rights with no statutory basis or public law element.

¶ 17, 22, 26

Both SWP No. 1477/2014 and SWP No. 2650/2015 are dismissed, with liberty to the petitioners to pursue appropriate remedies, including approaching CBSE or another legal forum as provided under St. Mary's.

¶ 24, 26
Jammu and Kashmir High Court

Original Court PDF

SONI RAM DHAKAvsU.O.I.MIN.OF HOME AND AFFAIRS

Jammu and Kashmir High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment