01Facts
On 18.04.2022, indiscriminate firing at Kakapora railway station killed Head Constable Surinder Singh and injured SI Dev Raj and others.
FIR No. 29/2022 was registered at PS Kakapora under Sections 302 IPC, 7/25 and 7/27 Arms Act, and Sections 16, 18, 20, 38 and 39 UA(P) Act.
¶ 5SI Dev Raj later died on 23.04.2022.
¶ 5CCTV footage from railway authorities identified the appellant as a suspect.
¶ 5He initially denied involvement but admitted it when confronted with the footage, and was arrested on 23.04.2022.
¶ 5, 20His disclosure before an Executive Magistrate allegedly described a pillion ride with co-accused Mukhtar Ahmad Bhat, who was said to have carried out the firing.
¶ 5Witnesses PW 5, PW 31 and PW 34 (a Section 164A CrPC statement recorded before a Magistrate) were relied upon to corroborate the disclosure.
¶ 5, 21The charge-sheet named four accused. Two were proceeded against under Section 299 CrPC after being found to have joined terrorists.
¶ 5The trial court framed charges under Sections 18 and 39 UA(P) Act against the appellant on 27.12.2022.
¶ 6, 14Seventeen of 42 prosecution witnesses had been examined when the bail order was passed.
¶ 6The trial court rejected bail on 17.11.2025, and the appellant challenged that order under Section 21(3) NIA Act.
¶ 1The appellant's counsel argued that co-accused Tawheed Bashir Bhat was discharged under Sections 18 and 39 and later bailed under Section 13.
¶ 2The appellant had been in custody for about three years and eight months, and later for more than four and a half years.
¶ 2, 1602Issues
i.1. Whether the statutory bar under Section 43D(5) of the UA(P) Act applies to the appellant, such that bail is barred because there are reasonable grounds to believe the accusation is prima facie true.
¶ 8–11, 23ii.2. Whether the trial court's refusal of bail, based on the material collected during investigation and adduced at trial, is legally sustainable at this stage.
¶ 7, 28iii.3. Whether prolonged pre-trial detention and the right to speedy trial under Article 21 justify bail notwithstanding the Section 43D(5) bar.
¶ 16, 3203Law Applied
The court applied Section 43D(5) of the UA(P) Act, which bars bail for offences under Chapters IV and VI where the court, on the case diary or Section 173 report, finds reasonable grounds to believe the accusation is prima facie true.
¶ 10, 13Section 43D(6) makes this bar additional to ordinary bail restrictions.
¶ 10, 13"Prima facie true" means more than suspicion and less than "proved," and is assessed case by case.
¶ 11Following Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali (2019) 5 SCC 1, as reaffirmed in Gurwinder Singh and Jalaluddin Khan v. Union of India (2024 INSC 604), the court must examine the charge-sheet material as a whole, take it as it is, and record a broad-probabilities finding without a mini-trial or detailed evaluation of evidence.
¶ 29–30Thwaha Fasal v. Union of India was cited for the same scope of inquiry.
¶ 30Grave offences warrant bail as an exception, citing State of Rajasthan v. Balchand, AIR 1977 SC 2447.
¶ 25(iv)(i), 27Under Article 21, the right to speedy trial must be balanced against State and societal interests.
¶ 32Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb (2021) 3 SCC 713 was considered on the prolonged-detention argument and distinguished.
¶ 31Under Section 479 BNSS, read with Section 6 BNS, eligibility depends on completion of one-half or two-thirds of the maximum punishment, and Section 18 UA(P) Act carries life imprisonment.
¶ 14, 33Provisions in the judgment · 20 · Linked ones open on LawLens
National Investigation Agency Act, 2008 Section 21
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 302
Arms Act, 1959 Section 7Section 25Section 27
Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 Section 13Section 16Section 18Section 19Section 20Section 38Section 39
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 173Section 299Section 437Section 439
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 Section 6
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 479Section 480Section 483
04Reasoning
The court treated the charge under Sections 18 and 39 as falling within Chapters IV and VI, so Section 43D(5) was engaged.
¶ 8It held that the Section 43D(5) bar was justifiably attracted. This rested on the statements of PWs 5, 31 and 34, which the court found gave reason to believe at this stage that the accusation was prima facie true.
¶ 21, 23It also relied on the CCTV identification, the appellant's admission on being confronted with the footage, and the framing of charges.
¶ 14, 20, 22The court rejected the defence contention that the extra-judicial confession lacked recovery or a new fact, noting that this was a merits question for trial and not for a bail court.
¶ 15, 28The court did not weigh the evidence in detail, which the Watali framework forbids.
¶ 28The co-accused's discharge and later bail were not treated as decisive, because the appellant's position and the charges differed.
¶ 2, 31On prolonged detention, the court distinguished Najeeb and held that the appellant had not served one-half or two-thirds of the maximum punishment, so the Section 479 BNSS entitlement was not made out.
¶ 33The Article 21 argument did not override the statutory bar at this stage.
The court also noted that the bail observations were confined to this appeal and would not prejudge the trial.
¶ 3505Holding
The bar under Section 43D(5) of the UA(P) Act applies to the appellant because the court found reasonable grounds to believe the accusation is prima facie true.
¶ 23, 8The trial court's rejection of bail did not suffer from any illegality in the appreciation of facts or law.
¶ 7Prolonged detention, at over four and a half years with 17 of 42 witnesses examined, did not warrant bail under Article 21 or Section 479 BNSS.
¶ 16, 33The appeal is dismissed.
¶ 34The observations are limited to this appeal and do not prejudge the merits.
¶ 35The trial court is requested to expedite the trial.
¶ 36Original Court PDF
YOUNUS MUSHTAQ BHATvsUNION TERRITORY THROUGH POLICE STATION KAKAPORA (POLICE / HOME)
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
