01Facts
The petitioner, appointed as a Mining Sirdar, joined the respondent establishment in 1973.
¶ 2On 18.07.1991 he was charge-sheeted and suspended for allegedly constructing a house on the respondent's land.
¶ 2He contended that the construction was made by his elder son, who lived separately, and that the management witnesses were cross-examined and a Sarpanch's affidavit supported him.
¶ 3His services were terminated on 04.06.1994.
¶ 4On an industrial dispute, the Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Jabalpur, by award dated 01.11.2013, set aside the termination and directed reinstatement but denied back wages.
¶ 4The respondent's case was that the Enquiry Officer found the workman's construction larger than a wooden thela, and that the Tribunal noticed he ran a bicycle-repairing business from the premises.
¶ 7–9The petitioner pleaded he was not gainfully employed elsewhere, but this did not alter the outcome.
¶ 6, 18He sought quashing of the denial of back wages, with 12% interest, along with consequential pensionary and retiral benefits.
prayer clauses · pp. 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in denying back wages to the petitioner while setting aside the order of termination and directing reinstatement.
¶ 13ii.2. Whether the Tribunal's findings on the unauthorised construction and the petitioner's income-generating activity are perverse, based on no evidence, or otherwise amenable to interference under Article 226.
¶ 16–17, 22–2303Law Applied
The Court treated reinstatement and back wages as distinct reliefs, so that back wages do not follow automatically from reinstatement and must be decided on the facts, the nature of the misconduct, the evidence, and gainful employment during the intervening period.
¶ 14Following J.K. Synthetics Ltd. v. K.P. Agrawal (2007) 2 SCC 433, back wages are neither automatic nor inevitable and depend on each case's facts.
¶ 10, 19Following Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan v. S.C. Sharma (2005) 2 SCC 363, the workman must plead and establish non-gainful employment, and the Court considered this relevant to the claim.
¶ 11, 19Fisheries Department, State of U.P. v. Charan Singh (2015) 8 SCC 150 was held not to lay down an absolute rule that back wages must follow reinstatement.
¶ 21Under Article 226 the High Court's jurisdiction is supervisory; it interferes with Tribunal findings only where they are perverse, based on no evidence, contrary to law, or show patent illegality causing miscarriage of justice.
¶ 2204Reasoning
The Court held that the Tribunal had separately considered reinstatement and back wages. It set aside termination as disproportionate, but denied back wages because the record showed the petitioner earned income from bicycle-repairing work at the disputed premises.
¶ 15, 17, 20The petitioner's plea that he was not employed in any other organisation did not, by itself, entitle him to back wages, since the relevant question is whether he engaged in any income-generating activity, not only formal employment.
¶ 18On the evidential challenge, the Court held that the Sarpanch's affidavit and the son's construction plea had to be assessed against the Enquiry Officer's findings and the evidence led at the enquiry. The petitioner had shown no perversity or patent illegality in the Tribunal's appreciation of evidence.
¶ 16The Court distinguished Charan Singh on the ground that the Tribunal had recorded a specific finding of income-generating activity.
¶ 21Applying the supervisory standard, the Court found the denial of back wages neither arbitrary nor unreasonable and supported by reasons germane to the issue.
¶ 23–2405Holding
The petitioner failed to show any perversity, jurisdictional error, or patent illegality in the Tribunal's award dated 01.11.2013 insofar as it denied back wages. The Court held that the Tribunal had given cogent reasons for denying back wages despite granting reinstatement.
¶ 23, 25The writ petition, being devoid of merit, was dismissed without costs, and the award stands.
¶ 26Original Court PDF
Ramlalit Dead Through Lrs Smt. Lachi DevivsSub Aria Manager
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
