01Facts
The petitioner, a private firm trading in fertilizers, held a state trading licence valid till 16/10/2026.
¶ 2On 27/11/2024, the Sub Divisional Agriculture Officer, Rewa, received an unverified video depicting alleged black-marketing of fertilizers. Two identically worded communications were issued that day, directing the Fertilizer Inspector to conduct an enquiry and register an FIR.
¶ 2An FIR was registered, and the petitioner's challenge to it is pending in separate proceedings.
¶ 3The petitioner asserts that no enquiry was conducted into the video and that no material shows DAP was sold at an inflated price.
¶ 3The impugned order dated 23/12/2024 (Annexure P/5) held the petitioner guilty and directed registration of an FIR. It was based on an order dated 09/12/2024, which the petitioner pleaded was never communicated to him.
¶ 4The petitioner's appeal was dismissed on 21/03/2025 without considering his grounds.
¶ 4The respondents produced the 09/12/2024 order (Annexure R/1) but did not show its communication, acknowledgement of service, or the mode of service.
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether the underlying order dated 09/12/2024 was communicated to the petitioner, such that the impugned order founded upon it can stand.
¶ 7–8ii.2. Whether the adverse findings and direction to register an FIR, made without any enquiry into the viral video and without natural justice, are sustainable.
¶ 8iii.3. Whether the Appellate Authority's dismissal of the appeal, without considering the grounds raised, is sustainable.
¶ 4, 903Law Applied
The petition was filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
¶ 1Natural justice and fair play must be observed before any adverse order is passed, particularly where the order has civil consequences.
¶ 8An order relied upon for adverse action must be shown to have been communicated to the affected party, so that the absence of proof of service is fatal.
¶ 7–8An appellate authority must consider the grounds raised in appeal; failure to do so renders the appellate order unsustainable.
¶ 9The judgment cites no statutory provisions and no precedents.
04Reasoning
The Court first examined whether the 09/12/2024 order, on which the impugned order rested, had reached the petitioner. Although the respondents filed the order, they gave no marking, acknowledgement, date, or mode of service, and did not respond to the petitioner's specific plea in paragraph 5.6 of the writ petition.
¶ 7–8The Court inferred non-communication from this absence of justification.
¶ 8On merits, the action rested solely on a viral video, and neither the reply nor the impugned order showed any enquiry into it. The State counsel could not explain these defects.
¶ 8Given the civil consequences of the findings, the absence of notice and enquiry violated natural justice, so the order of 23/12/2024 could not survive.
¶ 8–9The Appellate Authority, having affirmed the order without addressing the petitioner's grounds, committed the same defect, and its order fell with the original.
¶ 905Holding
The Court answered all three issues against the respondents: the 09/12/2024 order was not shown to have been communicated, the adverse action was taken without enquiry or natural justice, and the appellate order did not consider the grounds raised.
¶ 8–9The writ petition was allowed. The order dated 23/12/2024 and the appellate order dated 21/03/2025 were quashed. The authorities were left at liberty to initiate fresh proceedings against the petitioner if they so desired. The petition was disposed of with no order as to costs.
¶ 9–10Original Court PDF
M/S Shiv Khad Beej BhandarvsThe State Of Madhya Pradesh
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
