01Facts
The petitioners, poor agriculturists of Village Chowki, applied for settlement of Survey No. 473 (0.45 hectare), Bhind, pursuant to a public notice dated 26.07.2000 inviting objections by 24.08.2000.
p. 2No objection was received. The Naib Tehsildar, Circle Pipri, by order dated 29.09.2000, settled the land on payment of a premium of Rs. 1,170/- and issued Bhumiswami certificates.
pp. 2–3The Collector, Bhind, initiated suo motu revisional proceedings (Revision No. 55/2000-01), and on 04.06.2001 dismissed them, finding no illegality.
p. 3Respondents No. 5 to 8 then filed Revision No. 42/2002-03 before the Commissioner, Chambal Division, Morena, which on 02.06.2009 allowed the revision and set aside the Collector's and Naib Tehsildar's orders.
p. 1 · p. 3The petitioners challenged that order under Articles 226/227. Respondent No. 5 was unrepresented at hearing.
p. 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Collector had jurisdiction on 04.06.2001 to exercise suo motu revisional powers under Clause 30 of the Revenue Book Circular, given that the enabling sub-clause had been deleted and not reintroduced on that date.
pp. 4–5ii.2. Whether the Commissioner could entertain a revision against an order passed by the Collector in suo motu proceedings that were themselves without jurisdiction.
pp. 5–6iii.3. Whether the Commissioner's order could be sustained on the merits (respondent No. 5's prior rights, non-publication of notice, irregularities) without first establishing the Commissioner's jurisdiction.
pp. 6–703Law Applied
Clause 30 of the Revenue Book Circular, under which sub-clauses (4) to (6) were deleted by amendment dated 09.02.1984, removing the Collector's suo motu power. That power was reintroduced only by amendment dated 02.05.2003.
p. 4Under Clause 30, an appeal against an allotment order of a Tehsildar or Naib Tehsildar lies before the Sub-Divisional Officer, so no revision lies to the Commissioner from the Collector's order in such a matter.
pp. 5–6Vishnu Kumar and Others v. Satyanarayan Sharma and Others, W.P. No. 3868 of 2006 (decided 10.04.2023), which held that a Collector's suo motu revision without enabling provision is a nullity and that the Commissioner cannot entertain a revision against it.
pp. 4–6The principle that jurisdiction goes to the root and must be examined before merits.
p. 6Provisions in the judgment · 1
Revenue Book Circular Section 30
04Reasoning
The settlement was made by the Naib Tehsildar on 29.09.2000. The Collector initiated suo motu revision and decided it on 04.06.2001, when Clause 30(6) was not in force.
p. 5The Collector's order therefore could not be a valid exercise of suo motu power, and because its foundation was defective, it could not support a further revision before the Commissioner.
p. 5Since the Commissioner lacked jurisdiction, the Court held that it did not need to reach respondent No. 5's contentions on prior rights, notice and irregularity, which could not be considered without first establishing jurisdiction.
pp. 6–7The Court also clarified that the Collector's order was not being affirmed as a valid suo motu exercise.
p. 705Holding
The Commissioner's order dated 02.06.2009 in Revision No. 42/2002-03 was without jurisdiction and is set aside.
pp. 7–8The petition is allowed, and the Naib Tehsildar's settlement order dated 29.09.2000 in favour of the petitioners remains undisturbed. The Court did not adjudicate the rival claims of title or possession raised by respondent No. 5 on their merits, and the parties may pursue remedies available in law. No order as to costs.
pp. 7–8Original Court PDF
PurusottamvsState Of M.P.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
